Total posts: 15,698
Posted in:
My role talks about giving women rides and such as well. Interesting. I feel like Wylted talking about the theme could be honestly right tbh
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Earth
Should be but I’m going to double check it tmrw cuz it’s been a minute since I made game
Created:
Posted in:
I feel like Wylted never theme analyzes to a certain degree so I feel like him doing it now feels town??? Idk he could just be passionate about crimes with rape
Created:
Posted in:
Aight I don't think I have any strong reads at the moment. I want to hear Savant for activity purposes but right now my reads are virtually zero besides Pie but I do have some concerns with That2. A bit more agressive from what I have seen from them last game
VTL Savant
VTL Savant
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Bullish
I tend to air on the side of caution when it comes to claiming right away in DP1 because I think it gives mafia a lot of information and if the setup is given in a certain way, it could cause mafia to take advantage. However lately I've been noticing that it's been a bit better since scum have open access to chatgpt to find claims that will fit. So I am honestly leaning toward that philosophy but who knows
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Honestly it would've worked out WAY better if things went better character wise. Full transparency I would 100% try it again.
I generally hate early claiming in general in town unless I have to. Even then I don't think some people consider popular SOP but I still think it should be claimed based on the nature of how it's been used in recent games
I generally hate early claiming in general in town unless I have to. Even then I don't think some people consider popular SOP but I still think it should be claimed based on the nature of how it's been used in recent games
Created:
Posted in:
I haven't seen a lot besides Pie's role. But tbh I don't know what to make. I feel like 2 tp is pretty op and can't happen. I also think it's insane that it would 1 town 1 scum. It has to be both as town/scum. I could see a world where both are scum but I think it would be town flavored cuz if Pie 1 got lynched then Pie 2 would. Which i think makes me feel like Pie is town.
Created:
Posted in:
Gonna catch up but tbh I'm tired and might only make like 1 page
Created:
Posted in:
Hello everyone. Despite the theme not being solo leveling I am still excited for the game.
In a meeting right now but I am going to claim this (I feel like GP always claiming early nowadays but I keep giving SOP roles). I am Popular Townie. My role lasts til MYLO/LYLO. I am Ted Bundy. I can give justification when I am out of this meeting
In a meeting right now but I am going to claim this (I feel like GP always claiming early nowadays but I keep giving SOP roles). I am Popular Townie. My role lasts til MYLO/LYLO. I am Ted Bundy. I can give justification when I am out of this meeting
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
He wasn't actually a cop. I tailored him to be a cop
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
I don't think your reasons for following me for good. Call me salty but someone that confessed scum when the person had a scum read on them voting them is not opportunistic at all. Your logic is inherently flawed
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
That's not implicative of scum when i already scum read him before I hopped on the hammer for his claim
Created:
Posted in:
So dumb. Don't understand how I'm getting tracked for hopping on a bandwagon on a scum. Actually negative IQ analysis. Lucky ass follow
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Essentially so. I think the game is likely solved at this point. Casey isn't self silencing as scum and wylted's role implies That2and Barney's plot implies me.
So POE is Savant Austin you Luna.
Luna could've definetly hard bus'd Wylted but I feel like if he was scum he would've forced him to make a better claim than he did unless he's 200 iq so I doubt.
I want to see Savant cuz he said affiliation confirmed but I have some doubts about that tbh
So POE is Savant Austin you Luna.
Luna could've definetly hard bus'd Wylted but I feel like if he was scum he would've forced him to make a better claim than he did unless he's 200 iq so I doubt.
I want to see Savant cuz he said affiliation confirmed but I have some doubts about that tbh
Created:
Posted in:
I think That2 is telling the truth based on what Wylted's role is. So That2 is probably town.
The question is what role, if any, does Lunatic have? It could be just pure coincedence tbh
The question is what role, if any, does Lunatic have? It could be just pure coincedence tbh
Created:
Posted in:
That's pretty weird. I am not sure that implicates anyone to be honest just from how I think behaviorally his interaction with Wylted.
Created:
Posted in:
Alright thank god my read was right about Wylted but I think that was pretty obvious considering his behavior.
Anyone have some results?
Anyone have some results?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@That2User
Don't see why not. It's a minimal mistake. Plus I feel pretty confident in Wylted being scum anyway
Created:
Posted in:
Bad fake claim but now he's rewinding it. Yeah this seems like typical scum Wylted play unless someone shows me evidence otherwise
Created:
Posted in:
I find it hard to buy Wylted from the interactions I've seen
VTL Wylted
VTL Wylted
Created:
Posted in:
I took a nap and ran into a ton of posts. Let me see this shit
Created:
Posted in:
Alright I’m responding fully when im off lunch cuz some things said are pure lies
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
I asked that question too I haven’t heard back
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Cuz I didn’t know either why do you think I asked?????
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WyIted
You honestly give some good points. I need to reread some things.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Not sure how I framed it differently. Even in both justifications I never said anything about it. Only reason I asked was because of your post you had talking about a lack of cop figure.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
My PM said you appear guilty on all reports. I wasn't sure if it meant all or just specifically cop reports so that's why i asked? Why are you suggesting that this should have been implied lol?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WyIted
That your character has only 10 minutes of screen time. If he’s actually telling the truth about that then it definetly doesn’t make you look great. But if it’s not true then Luna looks sus. I genuinely know nothing about the theme so I can’t say anything besides what others say
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
I heard back from Whiteflame but apparently my miller compasses everything investigative and not just cop. That’s honestly really weird and I’ve never heard of that before so do with it as you will. Going to be like pie and keep pinging for more clarification
Created:
Posted in:
Wylted making shitty claims aligns with his scum behavior that I saw in his My Favorite Anime’s mafia. I would be down for either a Wylted or a Barney lynch today but if Luna is right then damn Wylted looks guilty asf
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
On an unrelated note, one thing thats tripping me up, is that if supa is town, that means there would have to be a cop. I CANNOT THINK OF A CHARACTER THAT MAKES SENSE AS COP. Maybe as I finish Nocturne tonight I'll have this solved, but there is literally nothing in s1-4 that makes sense as a cop. I can maybe think of one character having justification for a cop based on a scene that happens, but its a very big stretch for cop and never happens again. I can see justifications for trackers/watchers maybe but Cop? What the hell character would be a cop?! Again maybe I'll figure this out as I watch Nocturne.
I have no clue about the theme so can't really say too much about it but I asked a question to WF that could clarify some things.
Do you mind elaborating more on this? There isn't any character that could fit a cop justification? I mean damn that would be pretty crazy imo because a cop is one of the most basic investigative roles in the game. I'm only asking since you know more of the theme than I do
Do you mind elaborating more on this? There isn't any character that could fit a cop justification? I mean damn that would be pretty crazy imo because a cop is one of the most basic investigative roles in the game. I'm only asking since you know more of the theme than I do
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
You could be right about the theme being complex hence why I said I don't want to dig too deep into it.
Created:
Posted in:
Gonna post my reads since I think there's enough activity to give some base reads
Luna - I think Luna leans town. I think he is putting a lot of effort into theme breakdown and analysis into game. In fact a significant amount more. Not really typical of his scum play where he tends to lay low for a bit and not contribute more detail. The mix of behavior to theme has been beneficial to town and he isn't holding back any info for his analysis IMO. I am proceeding with caution, and not because I think he's scum, but if he's scum he could royally fuck us because of the knowledge but I think behaviorally is town
Casey- Casey still kind of feels null but I also like the post dissecting me and Luna's reaction as it shows they are attempting to make connections to different games to align behavior. obviously it could be easier cuz it's there game and they have a good idea, but I think it shows effort that tends to deviate from what I've seen casey play as scum.
Austin - In my null pile for the most part. I don't think he's made any crazy revelations onto his end and I also think he's a bit misguided on the Luna analysis for breaking down theme because I disagree with what he's saying. It would also be beneficial to scum to lynch Luna imo as scum because IF he's town, his knowledge of the game could fuck over scum if they aren't properly prepared
Pie - I was originally sus of pie but I think I'm backing off his sus and putting him in a bit of a null / lean town. I think he's making an attempt to push activity while still being agressive which is pretty townish behavior. His backing off of Savant read feels town but him doubling down on a take and blaming Savant also feels like something he would do as town too so I can't really justify him doing that as towny.
That2 - I was starting them off in a lean town but tbh I'm kind of pushing an FoS. I did not like there 200s post as it seemed dry and assumptive, something which I think mafia tend to do. I haven't played mafia with that2 to pick on behavior queues and such but I think forcing pressure and characters is something I seen them do as scum. Less to a degree here but it seems like he's forcing them here plus the assumption of good v bad is also throwing me off
Wylted - Everytime I play with Wylted it seems like flipping a coin heads or tails and I can never get a solid read. So null. I don't know if anything stands out but some of their agressiveness and reads come off town but honestly idk
Savant - behavior is null and I don't really have much to work with. I think his scum push and scum slip was not a scum slip but I also don't rule him out of potentially scum but no behavior has indicated in his way
Barney - I have an FoS on Barney. I think the fluff stuff obviously is old news and I've said him taking a stand and posting goes against what I've seen from town, but Barney also has adapted a bit to his game. I feel like his early posting and such are a way for him to draw town cred early on so that when he lurks or continues he could be passed down. Barney switched his meta quickly when I mentioned it and I feel like his new fluff posting could be way of combatting his old ways of lurking around
Luna - I think Luna leans town. I think he is putting a lot of effort into theme breakdown and analysis into game. In fact a significant amount more. Not really typical of his scum play where he tends to lay low for a bit and not contribute more detail. The mix of behavior to theme has been beneficial to town and he isn't holding back any info for his analysis IMO. I am proceeding with caution, and not because I think he's scum, but if he's scum he could royally fuck us because of the knowledge but I think behaviorally is town
Casey- Casey still kind of feels null but I also like the post dissecting me and Luna's reaction as it shows they are attempting to make connections to different games to align behavior. obviously it could be easier cuz it's there game and they have a good idea, but I think it shows effort that tends to deviate from what I've seen casey play as scum.
Austin - In my null pile for the most part. I don't think he's made any crazy revelations onto his end and I also think he's a bit misguided on the Luna analysis for breaking down theme because I disagree with what he's saying. It would also be beneficial to scum to lynch Luna imo as scum because IF he's town, his knowledge of the game could fuck over scum if they aren't properly prepared
Pie - I was originally sus of pie but I think I'm backing off his sus and putting him in a bit of a null / lean town. I think he's making an attempt to push activity while still being agressive which is pretty townish behavior. His backing off of Savant read feels town but him doubling down on a take and blaming Savant also feels like something he would do as town too so I can't really justify him doing that as towny.
That2 - I was starting them off in a lean town but tbh I'm kind of pushing an FoS. I did not like there 200s post as it seemed dry and assumptive, something which I think mafia tend to do. I haven't played mafia with that2 to pick on behavior queues and such but I think forcing pressure and characters is something I seen them do as scum. Less to a degree here but it seems like he's forcing them here plus the assumption of good v bad is also throwing me off
Wylted - Everytime I play with Wylted it seems like flipping a coin heads or tails and I can never get a solid read. So null. I don't know if anything stands out but some of their agressiveness and reads come off town but honestly idk
Savant - behavior is null and I don't really have much to work with. I think his scum push and scum slip was not a scum slip but I also don't rule him out of potentially scum but no behavior has indicated in his way
Barney - I have an FoS on Barney. I think the fluff stuff obviously is old news and I've said him taking a stand and posting goes against what I've seen from town, but Barney also has adapted a bit to his game. I feel like his early posting and such are a way for him to draw town cred early on so that when he lurks or continues he could be passed down. Barney switched his meta quickly when I mentioned it and I feel like his new fluff posting could be way of combatting his old ways of lurking around
Created:
Posted in:
Casey's breakdown of me and Luna feels town. Reaching into the toolkit of finding games of my town play is not what I see when I play with Casey as scum. Seems to be a lot of gut reading and going with the flow of things while still justifying a lynch. Casey shifts a bit into the town pile for that analysis
Created:
Posted in:
I don't like how That2 just quickly categorizes good and evil in the first place with the Nocturnal and assumes town. Throws me off. i know it contradicts 239 but we can't limit ourselves to good vs bad for basic themes when it could be something else
Created: