Total posts: 15,583
Posted in:
-->
@Mharman
@AustinL0926
@CatholicApologetics
Need 2 more?
Created:
Posted in:
1. whiteflame
2. iLikePie5
3. That2
4. WyIted
5. Casey
6. Earth
7. Moozer
8. Lunatic
9.
10.
Created:
Posted in:
Oh wait lol Wylted claimed 2x tracker yeah game over
VTL Wylted
VTL Wylted
Created:
Posted in:
I want to think about this a bit more than what is given. Pretty easily could just say fuck it and be done but I want to make sure all the alternatives are right here.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
I find it hard to believe that there is no investigative versus 2 protectors. I think we lose more if we keep Bullish alive. Either way game is essentially solves
Created:
Posted in:
1. whiteflame
2. iLikePie5
3. That2
4. WyIted
5. Casey
6. Earth
7. Moozer
8.
9.
10.
Created:
Posted in:
Yeah I think this game is over for the most part. If Pie is somehow a 3p or something then GG. Scum is deffo between Wylted or Bullish with me leaning a bit more towards Bullish
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Because I was known for being extremely charismatic to women by offering rides; as well as being one of the more popular and world renound serial killer, you are Popular Townie
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WyIted
I feel like everyone alive has a case to be town and I don't see any scum tendancies from a behavior and a mechanical standpoint.
Pie's role makes sense being my role but at the same time I am not fully convinced he could be town. I am not loving the hesistation to at least character claim 1 of his characters. He also said his characters are involved are 2 seperate entities. What if one of them was a 3p or something like that? I am not sure to be quite honest. Mechanically he makes sense as town just cuz bastard to have one be scum and one be town, but what if both are 3p?
Casey is virtually town IMO. I thought there behaviort alligned with their town play with being very vocal, taking charge on certain topics, and not shying away from the debates. Then the whole doctor CC happens and the That2 flip scums and it just solidifies my read
To be honest I don't really have strong behavioral reads but my gut is telling me town because I feel like you were mad asf with Luna for being a nerd about the theme that you tried to be the same way when it came to this game. I don't know how town affiliated plus the only un CC'd investigative role makes it hard for me to think you are anything less than town
Bullish is null. I feel like his initial reactions are towny and I get the vibe but I also can not remember a game where Bullish is scum. He was also hard on that2 pretty quickly and stayed consistently on Savant. I do agree with Pie where I find it weird that he asked for a mass claim and still hasn't revealed his claim yet... I also can't remember the last time I played in a game where Bullish was mafia so if someone has a link to that perfect
Pie's role makes sense being my role but at the same time I am not fully convinced he could be town. I am not loving the hesistation to at least character claim 1 of his characters. He also said his characters are involved are 2 seperate entities. What if one of them was a 3p or something like that? I am not sure to be quite honest. Mechanically he makes sense as town just cuz bastard to have one be scum and one be town, but what if both are 3p?
Casey is virtually town IMO. I thought there behaviort alligned with their town play with being very vocal, taking charge on certain topics, and not shying away from the debates. Then the whole doctor CC happens and the That2 flip scums and it just solidifies my read
To be honest I don't really have strong behavioral reads but my gut is telling me town because I feel like you were mad asf with Luna for being a nerd about the theme that you tried to be the same way when it came to this game. I don't know how town affiliated plus the only un CC'd investigative role makes it hard for me to think you are anything less than town
Bullish is null. I feel like his initial reactions are towny and I get the vibe but I also can not remember a game where Bullish is scum. He was also hard on that2 pretty quickly and stayed consistently on Savant. I do agree with Pie where I find it weird that he asked for a mass claim and still hasn't revealed his claim yet... I also can't remember the last time I played in a game where Bullish was mafia so if someone has a link to that perfect
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Is there a reason you are adamentally waiting vs claiming now that's based on your role mechanic, or is you just being stubborn
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
I kinda want a claim out of you for both of your personas tbh. It's not that I think you are scum but I think since everyone at the minimum has outted their character I feel like you should too at least. Maybe not role but I am still very confused about that role and feel like at this point with the DP and being L-1 there is no point to not claim what is going on with you
Created:
Posted in:
Honestly considering the setup of this game and what roles mafia had I feel like it's more likely than not they had a 3rd player. Messenger and Janitor are relatively weak.
Created:
Posted in:
There is no way to justify the CC. You CC'd a Doctor which wouldn't even have revealed anything damning. The only way you get caught by a tracker and even then this didn't happen. There might have been either a 0 iq play or a big brain bus from casey but my reads and the overall claim given from Casey just align too well
Created:
Posted in:
I still can't wrap my head around the CC lol what was even the point
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Casey_Risk
Yeah mine have some spoilers unfortunately. Not all but some do.
Created:
Posted in:
1. whiteflame
2. iLikePie5
3. That2
4. WyIted
5. Casey
6. Earth
7.
8.
9.
10.
Created:
Posted in:
1. whiteflame
2. iLikePie5
3. That2
4. WyIted
5. Casey
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Mharman
@That2User
@AustinL0926
@Savant
@Casey_Risk
Interested?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
@whiteflame
@ILikePie5
@WyIted
@CatholicApologetics
Interested?
Created:
Posted in:
Oyyyy marrone!
Welcome to my first mafia game that I am hosting in awhile. Feels good to finally host and I am glad is for this. This is a game that is made for 10 but can be run for 9.
Mechanics of the game will be explained in DP1
Mechanics of the game will be explained in DP1
- No editing or deleting posts of any kind
- No outside communication of mafia game (private PMs, other forum chats, other members) unless designated to do so
- There will 72hr day phases and, 24hr night phases unless there is activity level that below 75-125 posts within this time frame. From there, 24hrs extensions will be given ONCE and ONCE only for the DP.
- To contact Vader about anything, private message me or ping me in game
- If I mess up a vote count, please let me know asap so I can correct it. If I mess up anything within the game, please let me know. Humans are not perfect
- Follow the basic CoC rules (no doxxing, attempt to doxx, etc.)
- NEW RULE: AI can not be used when paraphrasing PM's. This will be checked using an AI humanizer that was personally developed by friends and you will be modkilled for doing as such. AI can be assisted with fake claims, but be weary as sometimes it can be a bit unconventional
Failing to do any of these things will result in a warn or modkill
Clarifications
I have no rules when it comes to calling people using foul language. I believe the freedom of speech is important to moderating a game. If someone is making attacks on you, they are just ruining their character. However, very rarely will I intervene. I will only intervene where the feud and obscenities becomes so excessive that is derails a game. You will not be modkilled for this, but a hard warn will be in place. I have a high tolerance for those feuds and have no problems with them, but don't make excessive to the point of ruining the game.
FOR RESOURCES ON HOW TO PLAY
A GUIDE TO FORUM MAFIA: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/21-guide-to-forum-mafia
A GUIDE TO FORUM MAFIA: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/21-guide-to-forum-mafia
Note:
In case for long periods of stretch of mod inactivity for vote counts (which are bound to happen due to me being in my final year of college living it up), if anyone wants to volunteer to keep track of votes I would much appreciate it.
9 mininum. 10 max
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Created:
Posted in:
Yeah I don't understand. That2 got tracked to WF. I feel like That2 just said fuck it let me just CC. Feels way more last ditch than anything else. Plus consider the setup of Popular + Lover + Pie's 2x voting.
Created:
Posted in:
Ok this is interesting to be quite honest. I am honestly really interested but hard gut read is we lynch That2 and my vote will likely stay that way
Unabomber was not a serial killer. Terrorist maybe so but I doubt a serial killer
Unabomber was not a serial killer. Terrorist maybe so but I doubt a serial killer
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Savant
Tbh i have a gut town read because in the last game where Wylted and I flopped as scum he was really pissed at Luna for being a theme-aholic and trying to meta analyze every theme and I think as a way of venting he might just be doing the same thing here which makes me he's a town lean but I am not sure I can never get a solid behavior read on him
Created:
Posted in:
I am also really sus of Austin. I hate putting the basis of activity but for someone who says, "they know a lot about this theme" and really hasn't contributed much to the analysis besides a few saying and they gave off behavioral vibes. Which isn't bad at all but I felt like they would be putting way more time into theme analysis. Makes me think they are withholding info as scum
Created:
Posted in:
Casey is a slight town lean in this game. Way more active and engaging with different players than I think I have seen them which makes me feel like they are pretty much town and genuinely trying to hunt scum. The interogation of Savant puts that in
Created:
Posted in:
Ok so from what I have gathered I am honestly leaning a bit more on Savant because of the nature of his killer but I also am not very fond of That2's claim. I don't know I feel like claiming Hider and with that justification is pretty weak IMO because you can make that argument for every serial killer there is a hider. I also made this mistake as scum with Hider where I claimed Hider but it was actually a weak hider
Created:
Posted in:
Going to catch up a bit but I feel a bit burned out of mafia but still going to try and put in the effort
Created:
Posted in:
That2's posts are a bit scattershot tbh and don't have true overall merit but I get some of the justifications for it as well.
I feel like Casey butting heads with Wylted signals town behavior from Casey. I also know Wylted was bitching about how well Luna knew the theme of the last game so maybe he decided to be a master at serial killers for the theme analysis and in that case could be town, well seems town.
I feel like Casey butting heads with Wylted signals town behavior from Casey. I also know Wylted was bitching about how well Luna knew the theme of the last game so maybe he decided to be a master at serial killers for the theme analysis and in that case could be town, well seems town.
Created:
Posted in:
My role talks about giving women rides and such as well. Interesting. I feel like Wylted talking about the theme could be honestly right tbh
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Earth
Should be but I’m going to double check it tmrw cuz it’s been a minute since I made game
Created:
Posted in:
I feel like Wylted never theme analyzes to a certain degree so I feel like him doing it now feels town??? Idk he could just be passionate about crimes with rape
Created:
Posted in:
Aight I don't think I have any strong reads at the moment. I want to hear Savant for activity purposes but right now my reads are virtually zero besides Pie but I do have some concerns with That2. A bit more agressive from what I have seen from them last game
VTL Savant
VTL Savant
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Bullish
I tend to air on the side of caution when it comes to claiming right away in DP1 because I think it gives mafia a lot of information and if the setup is given in a certain way, it could cause mafia to take advantage. However lately I've been noticing that it's been a bit better since scum have open access to chatgpt to find claims that will fit. So I am honestly leaning toward that philosophy but who knows
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Honestly it would've worked out WAY better if things went better character wise. Full transparency I would 100% try it again.
I generally hate early claiming in general in town unless I have to. Even then I don't think some people consider popular SOP but I still think it should be claimed based on the nature of how it's been used in recent games
I generally hate early claiming in general in town unless I have to. Even then I don't think some people consider popular SOP but I still think it should be claimed based on the nature of how it's been used in recent games
Created:
Posted in:
I haven't seen a lot besides Pie's role. But tbh I don't know what to make. I feel like 2 tp is pretty op and can't happen. I also think it's insane that it would 1 town 1 scum. It has to be both as town/scum. I could see a world where both are scum but I think it would be town flavored cuz if Pie 1 got lynched then Pie 2 would. Which i think makes me feel like Pie is town.
Created:
Posted in:
Gonna catch up but tbh I'm tired and might only make like 1 page
Created:
Posted in:
Hello everyone. Despite the theme not being solo leveling I am still excited for the game.
In a meeting right now but I am going to claim this (I feel like GP always claiming early nowadays but I keep giving SOP roles). I am Popular Townie. My role lasts til MYLO/LYLO. I am Ted Bundy. I can give justification when I am out of this meeting
In a meeting right now but I am going to claim this (I feel like GP always claiming early nowadays but I keep giving SOP roles). I am Popular Townie. My role lasts til MYLO/LYLO. I am Ted Bundy. I can give justification when I am out of this meeting
Created: