Top scumread is still pie, lunatic less so since my last look at this game, he's no 3 in my book.
No 2 would be Vader. I kinda just noticed this but I think there may be a CC between Owen's role and Vader's in that they gain a power over the NP
I don't trust is Barney's reads. If he's thinking of 3p why not Greyparrot? I don't fully trust GP's claim here bc a Crab God that whose character is carcinization (the process of turning species into crabs) sounds like a recruiting role (cultist) if it's 3P. Could a different townie that I wont talk about but I don't get why Barney is thinking Owen of all people is some third party. Even based on Owen's role, why not apply the logic to Vader?
And of course there's the idea that I'm wrong and scum is taking advantage and gone silent, but then what if calling it out is also for town cred?
I have Banana, Owen, and Casey in my town pile and that's it.