Let's do this. I'm going to separate this into two so I can focus on the claimed people first and the rest after I've had dinner.
Among the claims made so far, since I was asked, the order (from scummiest to least scummy) goes:
Moozer > Owen > Earth > Banana
To my mind, Banana's the obvious one we're not lynching. The pseudo-CC in particular sets her apart, and much as there's room to argue that her scum partner might have pushed her to do that, I don't think the way she did it comes across as coached.
Earth's early Miller claim and general behavior make me townread him a bit more than the other two. I know I said he could potentially take a big swing like this, but I just don't see him going for an early Miller claim. At the very least, he's not my priority.
Owen is a tougher one. His role claim has, essentially, two distinct points of confirmation: the inventor giving out items and the legacy role acting as messenger. It's a bit of an odd claim, but that's not the major problem I have with it. He's jumped back and forth on how he's claimed it, starting by saying that he's a rolestopper-inventor, then that he's an inventor who can give someone else the ability to rolestop, then saying that his justification focuses on the rolestop... even though he just clarified the inventor is his role. I get that the inventor appears to only give out the rolestop item, but it's still weird that he can't seem to keep them straight. I want to give him an NP to use his role, but he's behaviorally all over the place.
And then there's Moozer. I'm still hesitant to lynch him for reasons I've already mentioned about how his role of Strengthener sticks out as odd, even if the legacy role is pulling me in the opposite direction. It seems a little... inside baseball, if that makes any sense, requiring a lot of work of town to figure out how to use it effectively, and I agree with Pie that it doesn't make sense that he has to stay quiet about the number. In part, I wrote that off as "he saw that he would be modkilled if he said it," but I've noticed that Moozer has never said that that would happen. So... I guess he's just not allowed to say the specific number he's been given? What are the limitations on that? Can he give a number close to it? Can we try to guess it and can he give confirmation of whether we're too high or too low? If Austin's set limitations on what he can say about it, then Moozer should have informed us by now on what those limitations are and, at the very least, tried to make use of his knowledge now rather than just waiting to see if he gets to use it.
So, yes, Moozer is my choice among these four.
