Total posts: 96
Can you give an example as egregious as this?
Created:
-->
@SirAnonymous
How could a townie ever come to the conclusion I was being defensive?
Created:
How many scum is normal in 12 players?
Created:
Speed/Intelligence is plausible team.
Created:
The problem isn't that Intelligence is wrong, it's that town wouldn't view my behavior as defensive. It's an unnatural perception for a townie to have.
Created:
Then why aren't you scum reading Intelligence?
Created:
Intelligence said I was "scummy because defensive." Did anyone else share that perception?
Created:
-->
@Vader
I'm not trying to persuade you I'm right. It's just where I'm keeping my vote at the moment, until I find something scummier.
You keep saying I'm trying to push a mislynch. Why are you so sure that Water is town?
Created:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
wow, the floor here really is made of floor. please explain in more depth by what you see as pro town.
I explained above. I guess you're having trouble understanding why I town read someone who attacked me. It's because I expect town to get things wrong & I assume at least some of the players pushing me are town.
Created:
-->
@Intelligence_06
Which specific "defensive" post did you find scummy?
Created:
-->
@Speedrace
I've told you my top suspect, and it's fairly obvious who my town reads are. Why don't you involve yourself in the game a bit more?
Created:
Croc's a townread because he could have been an anti-town scum but instead chose to play pro-town.
Created:
-->
@Speedrace
You're not saying anything?
Created:
-->
@Intelligence_06
Ayyantu is a bit defensive in his/her/their responses. Being defensive is scummy.
I'm answering questions. This isn't scummy.
Created:
-->
@Vader
OK everyone does that. How does that justify you reading Water as scum? How does that justify your suggestion to out everyones role? You have the main concept yet you fail to provide logic behind that process is my concern, which leads me to believe you are scum
I explained why I voted Water & why I support mass claim. Disagreement isn't scummy.
Created:
It's a very simple yet effective style. I recommend it to you.
Created:
I read the game. I look for mafia & town. I vote my top suspect. I wait for reactions. I reevaluate reads. Then I repeat this cycle until a lynch happens.
Created:
-->
@BearMan
I think you're confusing "anti-town" with "different." When you play with the same people over & over, you tend to get locked into a certain way of playing. I'm an outsider so my style isn't the same.
Created:
I suppose the people pushing me could be town. I'd like to hear more from others, especially Lunatic.
Created:
It's been a while since I play mafia, sorry.
Created:
Why's it funny that I town read you?
Created:
I don't think it's Crocodile, though. Could be Bear or Supa.
Created:
I'm guessing at least one of the mafia are painting me as scummy.
Created:
-->
@Vader
I'm not role hunting. I suggested a mass claim because sometimes it breaks the game in town's favor. I know people disagree, so I'm not pushing.
I'll ask again, when have you seen noob scum behave like me?
Created:
-->
@Vader
When have you seen noob scum behave like me?
Created:
I've got a read on anyone who posted.
Created:
Note to self: Sir defends Water without wanting to call him town.
Created:
If not Water, who's your pick for a lynch?
Created:
Water claims scum, then acts surprised that a "noob" would vote him? It's fake.
Created:
I don't believe Water's disbelief. Why is he faking that emotion?
Created:
Look at Water's response to my vote.
Created:
I still think we should lynch Water.
Created:
I think it'd help to mass claim but I won't press on it.
Created:
Well, I should say this much. I don't recommend targeting me with your roles.
Created:
Posted in:
I think challenger should not proceed unless she gets both votes. A tie means I lose.
Created:
Posted in:
Thematically, as a new member, I should be challenger.
Created: