Ayyantu is a bit defensive in his/her/their responses. Being defensive is scummy.
If I trust Water for joking and no one so far interpreted it as anything else, then Ayantu is the best candidate.
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
373
-->
@Ayyantu
its not im just asking why am i immediately a town read
please answer croc's question, he posted a whole page criticizing you, how is he a town read for you?
-->
@Vader
OK everyone does that. How does that justify you reading Water as scum? How does that justify your suggestion to out everyones role? You have the main concept yet you fail to provide logic behind that process is my concern, which leads me to believe you are scum
I explained why I voted Water & why I support mass claim. Disagreement isn't scummy.
-->
@Intelligence_06
Ayyantu is a bit defensive in his/her/their responses. Being defensive is scummy.
I'm answering questions. This isn't scummy.
Why am I being ignored
-->
@Speedrace
You're not saying anything?
-->
@Ayyantu
Guy1: (kills guy2)
Police: What did you do? That is against the law! You can't do that here!
Guy1: No, sir, I am just using a knife.
-->
@Ayyantu
I asked you what your reads were
Croc's a townread because he could have been an anti-town scum but instead chose to play pro-town.
-->
@Speedrace
I've told you my top suspect, and it's fairly obvious who my town reads are. Why don't you involve yourself in the game a bit more?
-->
@Ayyantu
Croc's a townread because he could have been an anti-town scum but instead chose to play pro-town.
...
wow, the floor here really is made of floor. please explain in more depth by what you see as pro town.
-->
@Intelligence_06
Which specific "defensive" post did you find scummy?
-->
@WaterPhoenix
wow, the floor here really is made of floor. please explain in more depth by what you see as pro town.
I explained above. I guess you're having trouble understanding why I town read someone who attacked me. It's because I expect town to get things wrong & I assume at least some of the players pushing me are town.
-->
@Ayyantu
You said his response "which was sarcastic" was scummy. That's it. You're basing your entire case on Water because he randomly voted and how he reacted. This is you forcing a mislynch. Give me another reason
he could have been an anti-town scum but instead chose to play pro-town.
The ceiling is above me and the floor is below me. This is basic evidence. He could be faking.
-->
@Vader
I'm not trying to persuade you I'm right. It's just where I'm keeping my vote at the moment, until I find something scummier.
You keep saying I'm trying to push a mislynch. Why are you so sure that Water is town?
VTL Supa
-->
@Ayyantu
I'm not trying to persuade you I'm right. It's just where I'm keeping my vote at the moment, until I find something scummier.
Yes but your justification is extremely weak to be putting a vote on someone. A sour reaction isn't enough to trigger a VTL, especially if it's satire. We are saying that you don't give enough evidence your strategy and hesitation is detrimental
You keep saying I'm trying to push a mislynch. Why are you so sure that Water is town?
Because I think you are scum forcing a mislynch. Granted you could be town and Water is scum, but from my reads you are scum
Nice OMGUS
-->
@Crocodile
kill intelligence now
-->
@Greyparrot
Reason?
Vote Count:
Ayyantu (3/6) - Water, Supa, Intel
Intelligence (2/6) - Greyparrot, Danielle
WaterPhoenix (1/6) - Lunatic
Lunatic (1/6) - Croc
Supa (1/6) - Ayyantu
-->
@Intelligence_06
So town can win
-->
@Greyparrot
Well, the same logic could be used on you yourself. Why don't we wait a day till something happens?
thoughts?
My thoughts are Ayyantu is playing aggressively. He's not a noob. He's jumping to conclusions and speaking assertively with little to nothing to go on (very reminiscent of Mikal though I agree with 4 debates it's prob not him). And now he's asking for input from Lunatic which would be dangerous for scum to do unless they were scum buddies. I don't see a "new" player behaving this way at all as scum, so I think hyperfocusing on him is a waste of time. I believe the exchange about his read on Croc and I don't think his vote on Supa was omgus. I think Ayyantu doesn't know how to read Supa's persistent attention on him and neither do I. For now I'm giving it the benefit of the doubt and considering it novice scum hunting though we'll see how it goes. Keeping my vote on Intelligence.
-->
@Greyparrot
wait what
Again, I think I know almost certainly what Ayyantu's role is and I don't really see the purpose of hyper-focusing on Ayyantu who is clearly not scum. Let's just take the FOS off of Ayyantu and see what's happening here.
There are 11 people in the game. Judging that Greyparrot claimed Tracker, and nobody else counter-claimed. We can remove Greyparrot from the potential mafia list.
Deducing from the "clue" Ayyantu gave us in the beginning, it is clear what his or her role is, thus could be a potential advanced gambit for mafia, or just a regular town move. I am pretty sure that Ayyantu is a bit on the noob side so, I will remove him or her from the list.
Using deductions from Speed's behavioral patterns, and how he usually acts as scum or so I have seen, it does not match up from when he is scum. Therefore, removing him from the list.
My name is BearMan so I am not scum. Removing me from the list can result in 7 people left:
Bolded are the people I think are lean scum.
3. SirAnonymous
4. Lunatic
5. Danielle
6. SupaDudz
9. Crocodile
10. Intelligence
11. WaterPhoenix
someone say something
-->
@Danielle
Why are you voting for Intelligence?
-->
@Danielle
Why are you voting for Intelligence?
i was thinking the same thing
why is intelligence scum
same for bearman.