Arkhamafia DP1

It's not a competition. We can both be retards. 

I would rather not end the DP without a lunch and we have activity from everyone so we should all have a scum and town list even if it is weak

They said they can't say

Been a long day, had to do a bit of catching up.

Supa's choice to wait on providing his JOAT abilities definitely stood out to me, but his willingness to get himself lynched to test the deathproof kind of balanced it out. It wouldn't confirm the rest of his claim, but given that his other idea for how to handle the lynch this DP could have led to a lot of lost ground for town, this makes more sense, even if it would give town scant little other information to go off of given that we'll lose the flip for the lynch. Not sure if this would end the DP, but I'm assuming it will.

It's nice to see more participation by crystal and corey, though I would prefer not to have gotten the Bane character claim from the latter. The reason we generally don't do that (@Corey) is that it gives scum information. Your character claim may not give away your role (though many do and I can personally think of a couple of likely matches for yours), but if they don't have fake claims made available to them by That2, this also makes it easier for scum to fake claim convincingly without getting counterclaimed. For that same reason, I don't want more information on Barney's claim at the moment. Even with the color green alone, he's narrowed the window for characters quite a bit.

And speaking of Corey, it's interesting that he's suspecting the Riddler, specifically. I haven't been clear from the start whether this game is themed around the movies, the games, a specific show or what. I don't want to focus too much on theme analysis in this DP, but if Corey has some reason why the movies came to mind first for a game created by That2, it would be helpful to know.

So a lunch on supa probably ends the DP. I am still down with it. He is apparently TP at best and I am assuming he is only 1x death proof otherwise it makes no sense he is a survivor or even scum would only be 1x unless this is bastard modding of some sort

if it isnt frequent i dont think the mod would describe ur character with green tho  so it seems irrelavant 

someone fill me and Corey in the house on the discord thing?

Why are we lynching Supa for the abilities thing? what is deathproof

In forum games like this, scum communicate via a Discord channel, so the goal here was to see if Corey responded in a way that indicated that he was in such a channel or DMing with the mod, both of which would indicate that he was scum.

As for what deathproof is, it's just what it sounds like: if a player would die (either by lynching or by a night kill), the ability prevents them from dying. If he survives the lynch, that would presumably confirm that he is either lynchproof or deathproof.

I honestly think that the discord trap by earth was very obvious, but I also believe Corey would have fell for it, so he's in my town pile

By extension I feel like earth is town. I think we need to start thinking about our scum pools and where they overlap so we can coalesce around an actual lynch. If we are going to do supa I am fine with it but it will likely end the DP

why do we need to know if they're deathproof or not?

I agree that it's worth getting reads from everyone before the DP ends. Defaulting to lynching one of the claimed TPs, even just to test a deathproof claim, doesn't do a whole lot for us and it doesn't narrow anyone else down.

That being said, I'll post my reads tomorrow morning. Too tired to go read back through the DP and post reads tonight.

It verifies part of his role claim, meaning that he didn't just lie about his role to cover up something else that we should concern us. It also helps that it's a rather rare role for scum to get (we call it "bastard modding" because it's generally agreed that certain roles make scum too powerful and being able to survive a lynch is one such role), though the fact that it's a 1-time use makes it still possible to some extent. It's not necessarily the most important piece of information we could gather from the lynch, but at least it's something.

I see I think I understand now

Thank u for explaining to me! 

I don't think I'll vote tonight at least. Need more time to think

Also it is 11pm here 

Yep, same here. Signing off as well.

night

At any rate, at least for now, I say they passed the "Tell me about the mafia discord" test, so they are town, although it's possible that there is no mafia, and just TPs. It's odd that Joker is TP. Has he ever been admitted to Arkham? 

BANE!    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sBs7Vc0FYmw

Moderators commonly end up in the scum pile, so decent chance of whiteflame, SupaDudz, or myself being scum. As we start dying, I suggest looking to those who remain.

Supa should vig someone tonight (don't say who until morning), on the basis of the Monty Hall calculations. Plus two night kills would strongly imply he's not scum (letting scum kill multiple people per night would seem to be a bastard setup). 

I dislike the Batman claim, as he's not a villain; and the other third party is. I do wonder if the claimed mod kill happens in addition to the lynch or instead of it.

...

Is anyone here a hero other than Batman? I will say that I am a villain, and I assume everyone else to be. ... I'd still like colors too, to limit fake claims later.

Frequently. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Veju4PxhuGc

Sorry I haven't done much today. I'm afraid tomorrow will be even worse activity-wise. I should be more available after that. I didn't expect it to start as soon as it did.

Do you need an extension? If so, how long?

Admitting your a villain certainly makes Coreyinthehouse's theory more likely

Death proof means that lynching him should fail. We should all have abilities I believe. What is yours? 

As far as colors is concerned I have no fucking clue. I think maybe purple for my character but I think it depends on whoever colors the villain or what movie he appears in or whatever, so purple is not 100% confident

Let's at least test this claim I guess so the entire DP isn't a waste