Alright, I'm home from work and it looks as though things have shifted a bit. I already said that I scumread Corey, and while I still see his response to Earth as pretty townie, the main thing that still sticks out to me (and apparently to Pie as well) is the choice to claim. Setting aside the insights regarding theme analysis (which apparently are shared between him and Crystal), the decision to claim was an odd one. Not only did he choose to claim unprompted without having provided the color of his clothing as Barney suggested (seems like that would have been a more intermediary step), but he hasn't explained why he made that decision nor why he didn't include the role claim.
The fake claims post doesn't help his case, but what's more important to me is his response to being at L-1. Rather than try to defend himself by providing his full claim, he just avoids the opportunity over and over. The delay doesn't sit well with me, seems like he's trying to seek out a reasonable fake role claim to give himself cover.
That's enough for me. VTL Corey.