Arkhamafia DP1

I remember a couple others gave character hints, but off the top of my head I can’t remember who.

Way back on #18, why did you jump to the conclusion that someone stole your vote against the new player, instead of the more likely moderator error?

How is mod error more likely to you?

Thank u for the info

What's color have to do with it?

I do not to my memory, no. I went through a very long period of massive motivation issues though so I might have been in one with no motivation again. Better about this now so will try to be active. Sorry, just got home from work.

I'm here now DX

This makes sense I didn't really fully consider how this negatively impacts town until after I said it

But yeah I don't see a reason to suspect Pie as faking their claim

Why should I hold off on claiming in your opinion though?

You're good, I heard this started really late for me and I had work early. Just got home today so I'm catching up ATM.

I'm trying to be active now if that helps at all

I suppose I could VTNL, but I was waiting to see if this discussion would find anyone reasonably suspicious to me

The main reason not to claim now is because it would help mafia decide who to target. If you have a powerful role, they could target you. If you don't, they can target someone else, increasing their odds of taking out a power role.

What are your reads? That is, who seems more like mafia and who seems more like town?

Ohhh shit u right 

Yeah I won't then

Uhhh trying to figure that out tbh

All I feel I have to go on is the two people who claimed themselves

I'm Bane, I win with town. I'm going to leave the further specifics to my role secret for now since it was said it might be bad bc of targeting. Not to say I'm stronger or not, for all U know I could be trying to throw mafia off of stronger people. 

I was partly thinking of enjoyment of the game

Pie said he hated being that role and was okay with being lynched 

But yeah it could also hurt us in game to lynch him

No more spontaneous claims this DP, please.

If there's one fake third party Supa is likely the real third party. Pie made the claim first, (I think) he could have been banking on the real third party using a fake claim (if they even claimed) to get away with his claim. I find it unlikely there's two third party but it's possible I think.

Is there anything wrong with me having a Google Docs comp of evidence/thoughts so I can organize my thoughts on this game better?

No

I'm suspecting Barney might be the Riddler. "Part of your costume is green"A
nd if so, given That2 I'm gonna suspect you're the mafia. Thinking Supa/Joker might be the other mafia which would fit well with Riddler and Joker's implied teamup at the end of the newest movie, would make sense.

IK That2 really liked that movie so him making this loosely based on that would totally make sense. Supa's claim also smells suspicious to me, personally.

Aight, awesome. 

Are you allowed to confirm if the vote was error or not?

I haven't played in a while so all I can say is I am an idiot

It was a patient error, WyIted wrote VTO, not VTL, thus the vote didn't count

It does and even if he doesn't confirm he could leave it up in the air to mess with us/keep the discussion going, so feel inclined to agree it was probably mistake
EDIT: Didn't see he confirmed lmao

YAY WE'RE NOT THE ONLY IDIOTS

its alright im sure im more dumb here