After skimming through the previous DPs, I've changed up my reads a bit.
We have two lynches to work from, and I think it's likely that at least one scum was on both lynches, possibly more. So I'll start with the overlap: SirAnon, MC and Badger.
SirAnon - He's probably the least sus of the trio, but I do have reservations. It's not so much that the justification rubs me the wrong way, but rather the role itself sticks out. That being said, SirAnon was the one to point out that scum might not have role claims based on what Mharman has divulged so far, and while that might have just been a way to get us to townread him, it also revealed that the kind of role he has claimed is likely to come from scum who would want to avoid being CC'd. Seems like he'd be undercutting himself by pointing that out. Still townread him behaviorally.
MC - Behaviorally, I think MC's scum, but based on the fact that we've now tested his lynchproof two DPs in a row, I just don't see a reason to pursue him. We can't lynch him even if we want to, but despite the balance being weird and so much of his role being weird, I have to buy that MC is lynchproof, that it wasn't a one-time thing, and that that makes it exceedingly unlikely that he's scum. That2 pointed out that "MC can get lynched in MYLO/LYLO," though that's really only a reason to keep him on the table for the future, and that actually makes it more difficult to sus him. Having a lynchproof scum who clarifies that they can be lynched in later DPs just doesn't make sense.
Badger - Yeah, this one's weird. I still largely townread him behaviorally, but I seriously do not understand why he was on the lynch if he was so confident that Earth was town. That could just be because he was fed up and just wanted a lynch at all, or maybe he was trying to prove himself right, but it's strange behavior regardless. It's making me second-guess my townread.
So, from this group, Badger is the most sus to me at the moment.
As for others to consider, I'll start with anyone who was on either of the two lynches separately. Starting with DP1:
That2 - I'm getting a pretty hard townread on That2. The early DP2 Vanilla claim is just an incredibly weird move for scum to make coming off of two town Vanillas being confirmed. Behaviorally, I can't say I've seen anything too concerning. She has been more active than I've seen her before, but I'm not sussing that.
Danielle - She's null for me. Danielle is bringing a lot of good analysis to this, but my experience with her is that this isn't unusual whether she is scum or town. The main behavioral element that has me slightly tilting town with her is the question about the no lynch. I would expect her to be more aggressive as scum and push for a lynch.
Onto DP2.
Speed - I've always had a hard time reading Speed and I'm feeling that again here. Still null at the moment. We were of similar minds on the Earth lynch, so I can't fault him there, so I'm having a hard time determining whether it's just us being on the same page or buddying.
GP - There's so much I don't like about GP's behavior and claim that I've already explained. None of that has changed. I'm still scumreading him. He remains my strongest scum read.
That leaves WyIted. He hasn't been on either lynch. He keeps jumping on and off of lynching me, though he has gotten less interested in the "why" of it, instead piggybacking on what Danielle said about scum likely being between me, SirAnon, Speed and MC and just placing a vote on me... I guess because he already sussed me earlier? I wasn't clear. He's kept saying that GP should be a last resort without much in the way of justification. Earlier in the DP, he was fine voting for him until he felt that his role somehow balances with GP's (we've confirmed MC's role, so if WyIted's soft claim is true, it's not balanced), then decided to push the last resort part after we'd confirmed MC's role. His interactions with GP, as far as I can find, have just involved GP literally asking him "Are you talking to your scum buddy?" and WyIted responding with "Is this a yes or no question?" and responding to a "I still don't trust Wylted" directed to badger with "Bro, I'm white." Fluff interactions. He was also needlessly defensive early in DP2, claiming that he was an easy mislynch despite a lack of votes on him or even anyone sussing him.
So, at least right now, GP and Wylted are my strongest scum reads. As for a third, I have it mainly between Badger and Speed at the moment, leaning towards the former.
