So, I clearly had the wrong call on Earth. That's my bad, and I understand if some people sus me over it. I think I was pretty thorough in explaining my reasons and I still feel that those were justified, though clearly, I need to listen to Badger's gut reads more closely.
That being said, we now have a loose thread: how was there no NK? SirAnon did a pretty good breakdown of how this could have happened, and I think we should be able to eliminate at least the first of these options.
We have several people who remain without full claims, myself included. I do not have a protective role. GP claimed Hated, That2 claimed Vanilla, MC claimed lynchproof (I'll come back to that), and SirAnon claims not to have used his role. Wylted has soft claimed a role that affects lynching, and based on his posts so far, he doesn't have a role that afforded protection. Badger hasn't said anything about it. Danielle hasn't said anything about it. Both of them have no reason to hide that they successfully defended someone from an NK, since that would town-confirm whoever they defended (or town confirm themselves, in case they're bulletproof). That just leaves Speed, who I'd like to hear from ASAP. If there's something to this, then the apparent mafia strongman either isn't something they can use repeatedly or they had some other ability that they chose over the strongman. The latter could be true considering that they knew the doc was dead.
Assuming that Speed says nothing pertinent, we can move onto the other explanations.
Anyway, coming back to MC, I said it in the last DP: we need to double-check his lynchproof in this DP. Unusual as it might be, a 1X lynchproof mafia would be a very effective way to throw off town without doing something ridiculously bastard. We have no reason not to re-test him in this DP while we gather information.
VTL MC
