BAMF Mafia - Day Phase 1

wifom.  Dudz had just made the SLJ connection so a couple of iconic SLJ quotes seemed appropriate.  

So... you think I might be SCUM who breadcrumbed both Jules and Nick Fury (probably SLJ's two biggest roles) as fake claims in the sixth post of the game? 

I haven't dropped good guy vs. bad guy or badass vs non-badass.

All 3 splits seem possible at least.

Yet your conviently gonna vote based on one of the theories directly after I point out your scummy bread crumb. 

You suggested the ideal situation would be for this information to come out dp2 post flip though, so obviously a flaw in the logic if we used it dp1 to lynch scum lol.

Post 35 and 37 heavily imply that you are shaming him for his not knowing (basically calling him dumb), right after you suggested it was scummy of him not to know the theme in post 22 lol. 

If you are speling it out for him that way, do you think mafia is also too dumb to not figure it out? I guess in some apeball scenario where croc and skittlez are scum maybe that makes sense...

Which means you were originally saying you thought it would be ideal to lynch someone before they could claim which makes even less sense if your town. lol

Don't know what you you mean with the lazy part, but I find it ironic that you town read oro for being knowledgable, and oro thinks you town read him for being bad at scum.

->@oromagi

I've been thinking here and let's assume were both town for a second. Shouldn't we just mass full claim, starting with me you and speed and Danielle? I'll even go first since I'm like 75% sure mafia can figure out what I am anyway. This isnt a large game and mafia have some decent POE already with having the cop out and a vanilla to narrow down from. Why don't we just turn the POE in towns favor since croc fvcked us? I think the order should go me, you, speed, Danielle to cross off the vets with the best chance of coming up with something really good then we go down the list for the rest of the more noobier town, going supa and mharman and whoever else I'm missing.

0

• Persisting in demanding ROLE claim in DP1 even after being told anti-town
  
• Ignoring inactives
  
• picking fights
  
• requesting mass ROLE claim DP1 before we've even gotten characters.  Its as if you aren't even interested in theme because, as SCUM, the theme split is already obvious to you.
  

I am not voting on theme split, esp. since nobody else has claim animated and the choices don't look all that apt.

I am voting on your behaviour. 

You asked for character claim.  

I told you that would be anti-town.

You insisted.

I gave you character claim.

Now you want role claim.

I told you that would be anti-town.

You insisted.

That makes you much more likely to be scum.

Additionally, your gameplay is so disruptively combative that even if you are TOWN there's some utility to your quick disposal.

Additionally, I have asked you to help pressure Danielle for lurking and you have ignored.

... and now you are asking for a mass role claim without even bothering to start with character claims.

Huh? How is that a flaw in logic if it's used to catch scum DP1...because my whole point is that it's used to catch scum period.

Please tell me Lunatic, where did I call Supa dumb, and where did I tell him that he's wrong for not knowing? These posts EXPLICITLY show that I was telling Supa that he shouldn't have REVEALED the theme.

This was after I told him to look up the character and he still didn't get the theme, at which point it's perfectly reasonable to suspect him.

No, the whole point is that town would not reveal the theme even if someone claims...if they do then welp

Lol I seriously doubt that Oro actually thinks I town read him because I think he's bad at being scum (I don't btw). I'm like 98% sure that was a joke.

I already knew Lunatic was Frozone (duh) and figured he was roleblocker. He claimed Jailkeeper as roleblocker during live mafia. I think that's another reason that he's scum

And before someone says "yoU sAId yoU hAd a cALL" the first one ended a few minutes ago and the next is at 3 est

@oromagi

I already knew Lunatic was Frozone (duh) and figured he was roleblocker. He claimed Jailkeeper as roleblocker during live mafia. I think that's another reason that he's scum

And before someone says "yoU sAId yoU hAd a cALL" the first one ended a few minutes ago and the next is at 3 est

Because you said that the information was best out in DP2, meaning you were suggesting lynching someone without getting a claim from them which makes no sense.

Those posts are the evidence of you implying he was dumb by shaming him lol. You trying to spin it as not shaming him is silly when you are literally saying you are in the same sentence lol.

Except you dropped your suspicion on him even after spoon feeding the information to him, which should have made you more suspicious of him. The fact that you are still defending the idea that not knowing the theme = scum shows that you should still think it was a scum tell. The point is, that initial "supa is scum" post was contrived af to show off that you had information that others didn't as a hope to town tell yourself. Common scum tell, reminds me of how I caught bearman in naruto when he wouldn't directly admit he did something scummy lol.

Then welp? So it's just a bruh moment? Then why are you still defending the initial idea that using the information would have helped you catch scum at some point? lol

Regardless it's still ironic the two people I scum read are heavily OMGUSing, especially after one of them ranted on me for "OMGUSing" in naruto mafia recently lol. 

BTW when I claiemd jallkeeper in that liev mafia game, it was a huge risk that shouldn't have worked out for multiple reasons, and I fully expected to lose that game from the gambit. It was a miracle of god I wasn't counterclaimed, and the watcher results on max were dismissed. But to dismiss the possibility that there is a protective role entirely because of that instance is pretty ridiculous. I welcome any potential counter claims. 

yoU sAId yoU hAd a cALL

The fact that you are instantly dismissing me is scummy af btw lol. I can easily prove my role (but that isn't ideal for mafia), lynching me would be better for them. Save them from having to night kill the jailer, which subsequently looks bad for you and oro. Tsk tsk speed, gonna have to try harder than that. The win/win here is that even if by some miracle you can mislynch me, if town is competent past day phase 1 and looks into the Versus interactions here, you are likely to be looked into pretty closely unless you got some rock solid fake claim.

Mafiawiki:

" it's fairly common for Mafia to claim to be a Jailkeeper when they're actually a Roleblocker; this is hard to disprove without a Role Cop and makes the role sound more townsided."

Just because it's best out DP2 doesn't mean it *will* be out DP2, one, and two, I literally already said that depends on town not revealing the theme bruh

And you have yet to show where I shamed him for not knowing the theme :|

I should have been more suspicious of him for making a mistake that I would've made had I not researched my character? That's literally anti-town to scum read him while knowing that it probably was a mistake from personal experience. And why would I try to "show off" that when I had already revealed that info in an earlier post? Like what?

If it doesn't work then it doesn't work, it's not a guaranteed method.

OMGUSing is voting someone simply because they voted you. That's not what is happening right now

Doesn't mean you wouldn't try it again with pressure on you.

But how do you know mafia doesn't know the theme?