-->
@SirAnonymous
Bearman is suspicious.... he has not really posted other than saying some weird things about day period one
Civil War Generals Mafia DP1
Posts
Total:
767
-->
@Mharman
I only voted next to last because it's highly, highly unlikely for there to be 2 hated roles in a game.
And I wanted people to see that.
What time zone is everybody in?
I'm in EDT
-->
@TNBinc
I may have to look into that. You can ask him about it yourself, you know.
That was a very high effort post. Label me impressed
+1
unvote
-->
@TNBinc
EST! EST! Nothing's worse than CST!
-->
@Mharman
Offended. Would put my vote back if I wasn't townie
-->
@Mharman
That1User: What strikes me about him is that he goes a little TOO far with the theme analysis. He out TNBinc'scharacter and asked Greyparrot if he was McClellan (post #109). To me, he isn't just doing theme analysis like to others including myself. He is pushing way harder thananyone else for precise information. For this reason, I scumread him.
I had the same idea as you had. I thought them being hellbent over pressuring in DP1 was odd, so I had my FoS on that
-->
@Vader
lol
-->
@Mharman
At least I have the White Sox destroying the Cubs to brag about
-->
@Vader
It's a joke about the old arguments on DDO about which time zone was best. It got heated for some reason. It even led to a mafia game being created.
-->
@Mharman
I remember. I know 7th was a big EST person
-->
@Vader
Lol. 2-1 in the series this season isn't exactly destroying. That being said, I haven't watched a lot of baseball this season. I kinda stopped caring after they got woke. Maybe I should watch some more though. And maybe bring back Lolcow of the Week while I'm at it.
-->
@Mharman
The White Sox had no plans of even sitting out, they wanted to play lmao. Cubs wanted to, come join the light side!
-->
@Vader
Supreme lolcow of the year: The entire NBA
-->
@Mharman
dude this is DAYLIGHT SAVINGS
theres only EDT and CDT no EST or CST
-->
@Mharman
Agreed. Mavs should've won the series vs the Clips
Soooo.............. does anyone have anymore contributions to this DP right now?
UNVOTE
TOWN
C3.Oromagi
CX. That1User
U3.MisterChris
U3. BearMan
U3.Lunatic
C3. Mharman
C3. Speedrace
U3. SupaDudz
SCUM
I'm going to wait for the opinions of others on my reads before casting my vote.
-->
@Mharman
@SirAnonymous
The question in Post #8 was just an impulse. I'm happy that we sorted 6blue/6grey and that everybody checked in pretty early. Beyond that, I'm not sure much was gained but that's fine as a first result.
2 union, 2 town was an unfortunate typo. Should have read 2 union, 2 confederate. I encourage you not to read to much into it but if I caught somebody else making that kind of typo I would certainly drop that person a rung or two down the scum ladder.
-->
@Mharman
thx for the detailed reply
I wonder if anybody feels that they have a claim so scummy or unusual that they ought to claim DP1.
- Millers or other non-power roles that might turn up sus under investigation.
- Any general names that are WAY off the beaten path. The wikipedia list is too complete but perhaps if your general's name is not on this list
- https://www.historynet.com/civil-war-generals
- and you are TOWN
- then you might consider letting TOWN know you've got an unexpectedly rare character claim.
-->
@oromagi
I win with the town and my character is on that list.
-->
@oromagi
oh wait nvm you said not on the list
Vote Count:
Mharman (2/7) - TNB, Grey
Oromagi (1/7) - SA
Please let me know if I’ve made a mistake
Reads:
Town:
SirAnonymous: Town. Obviously high IQ and impeccable taste. Scum team should be afraid of this mafia master. Or maybe not.
TNBinc: Obviously noob town.
Lean town:
Supa: He's been putting in good effort and thought. He seems to be pro-town.
Croc: A claim that crazy almost has to be town. There are some people playing who might take the risk to fake it, but I doubt that's the case here. I would like to see more activity from him.
Null: everyone else.
Mharman: Generally inactive, but wrote up some good reads. I've never played with him before, so I don't know what to expect. I
Speedrace: Helpful and pro-town when he's active, which means precisely nothing.
Lunatic: See read on Speed.
MisterChris: He seems to be playing the same way he did in his first game, which could be a good sign. However, he hasn't been mafia yet, so I don't feel comfortable classing him as town.
Oromagi: It's odd that he asked people to say which side they were on when he was Confederate, but I don't think it's enough to sus him. I'll keep an eye on him regardless.
BearMan: Not very active. I haven't seen anything either way.
GreyParrot: Impossible to tell, as usual.
That1User: Never played with her before, so I don't know.
-->
@oromagi
I wonder if anybody feels that they have a claim so scummy or unusual that they ought to claim DP1.
- Millers or other non-power roles that might turn up sus under investigation.
- Any general names that are WAY off the beaten path. The wikipedia list is too complete but perhaps if your general's name is not on this list
- https://www.historynet.com/civil-war-generals
- and you are TOWN
- then you might consider letting TOWN know you've got an unexpectedly rare character claim.
I am town and not on that list, but the way my PM describes me I seem important, so I don't know if I would bank on that list much. Though I am not much of a historian so I don't know many of these generals except for the big names.
-->
@Mharman
@SirAnonymous
Moreover, in Post #23 he says "2 Union, 2 town", as if to suggest Confederates are scum, and that was the purpose of his question in Post #8. However, given how he is a Confederate in Post #84, there would be no reason to ask this question.I asked him about that earlier, but I don't think he saw it. So let's try again.
I don't see why oro would do that as scum; what is the end goal with even asking for this information? Also if he was mafia we would have to assume he has enough knowledge about the theme already that jumping to the conclusion that confederates were scum doesn't make sense. I'd say at best him wanting U/C is a null tell.