-->
@TNBinc
yea u cant delete ur own posts that's poor conduct
Civil War Generals Mafia DP1
Posts
Total:
767
@GP
Some of the many criticisms of Longstreet's Gettysburg performance by the postbellum Lost Cause authors cite this failure as evidence that Longstreet deliberately undermined Lee's plan for the battle.
Exactly. The Lost Cause was bullshit racism popularized by Klan resurgence. Those people who tried to rewrite history in conformance with contemporary political propaganda . That makes the Lost Cause the opposite of history.
At this point I am perfectly OK with a Croc lynch.
I won't put my vote up til later though
I won't put my vote up til later though
-->
@TNBinc
@oromagiwhat is a "wincon"?
Short for win condition. Some games permit discussion of win condition, some don't. IF its allowed then being an early wincom claimant can offer some
solid town cred. Obviously, after a couple of people have offered the same phrase, scum is clued in. Watch the second wave of claimants for scum.
- You are Town.
- You win with Town
- You win with the Town
-->
@oromagi
I already said I win with town
-->
@TNBinc
good thx
TOWN
C3.Oromagi
U3.SirAnonymous
U3.MisterChris
U3. SupaDudz
U3. BearMan
U2.TNBinc (Rosencrans) (1X)
U3.Lunatic
C3. Speedrace
CX. That1User
C3. Mharman
CX. Croc John Magruder 1X VOYEUR
SCUM
-->
@Crocodile
VOYEUR is like TRACKER- can be either alignment
I agree with SA that the role is useful, testable, and not a particular suspect claim
UNVOTE
Croc- If you are TOWN you can prove that by using VOYEUR NP1 and reporting your findings with alacrity
-->
@Mharman
VTL Mharman
What should TOWN know about your character/role?
TOWN
C3.Oromagi
CX. That1User
U3.MisterChris
U3. BearMan
U3.Lunatic
C3. Speedrace
U3. SupaDudz
C3. Mharman
SCUM
UVC
Croc (4/7) - Greyparrot, That1User, TNBinc, Lunatic
Mharman (1/7) Oro
Vote Count:
Croc (4/7) - Greyparrot, That1User, TNBinc, Lunatic
Mharman (1/7) Oro
Please let me know if I’ve made a mistake
-->
@oromagi
what is 3 and 2 exactly?
-->
@TNBinc
- You are Town.
- You win with Town
- You win with the Town
-->
@oromagi
I'm 3
Pie said I win with the town
-->
@TNBinc
-->@oromagiI'm 3Pie said I win with the town
OK but then you said
I don't invest much in the discrepancy because you are new and may not appreciate that perfect reproduction was the point of the answer. Nevetheless, that makes you 2.
Did you include the in your earlier post?
-->
@oromagi
I agree with SA that the role is useful, testable, and not a particular suspect claim
I don't know about useful or testable. It's only 1x. It is definitely weird, though. From what I've seen, weird roles tend to be town more often than scum, unless Lunatic is involved.
-->
@oromagi
Those people who tried to rewrite history in conformance with contemporary political propaganda . That makes the Lost Cause the opposite of history.
Truth is irrelevant. perception is.
History wasn't kind to Longstreet because history is written by the winners of war.
-->
@Greyparrot
The histories I've read (the ones I mentioned earlier) were kind to Longstreet.
With Croc's new power role claim, it's probably time to call off the lynch for now and have him use his role tonight to see what happens.
As Oro said, it's testable and he can give us info.
Still reading the entire DP (and also taking notes)
-->
@MisterChris
With Croc's new power role claim, it's probably time to call off the lynch for now and have him use his role tonight to see what happens.
Agreed.
As Oro said, it's testable and he can give us info.
I'm not sure how it's testable without anyone else claiming, and I don't think we need more claims. Also, role confirmation isn't affiliation confirmation. That role can be scum as well as town, so I don't think testing it gains us anything.
-->
@Mharman
Still reading the entire DP (and also taking notes)
Let us know what you come up with.
-->
@SirAnonymous
By "testable" I mostly mean that if he gives us bullshit results with his ability, I think we'd be able to figure it out.
But yeah, you're right, it's not foolproof and we don't know anything for certain
-->
@SirAnonymous
What are your opinions on Croc's claim?
I suppose it's testable so there's no reason to lynch it. If he is town I am guessing this is a role heavy game.
unvote. VTL mharman
-->
@MisterChris
That makes sense.
-->
@Lunatic
Moving on to the next inactive? I've been considering doing that. Think I'll join you.
VTL Mharman
-->
@SirAnonymous
Moving on to the next inactive? I've been considering doing that. Think I'll join you.
Yep, he says he is catching up, just adding a little incentive lol
-->
@Lunatic
Yep. I hope he sees something the rest of us haven't, because no one seems to have any scum reads yet. Kinda makes me suspect you and Speed because you two are the best at seeming town.