Bloodline Day Phase 1

But I also wanna keep an FOS on him because then I lose any reason to have an FOS on you and my gut says to keep an FOS on you

You can FOS me at some other time. There's really no reason to now. I think Budda, drafter and myself have put forth the most analysis. Plus I breadcrumbed so I can always refer everyone back to that if/when I have to claim. I assume I'll be dead tomorrow though tbh. 

note that the 2 going after drafterman are both uncc'd likely-to-be-town characters; Sally  more so than Jane.

in the people going after hammer, one is an unconfirmed innocent child and the other is a not at all outed individual who  has beeen shady and opportunistic all game from bwing me to bwing hammer.

What do you think of Earth and Supa? I'd vote for GP today if we had no better options, but I think those two might be (especially Supa). Supa's behavior is weird/anti-town, but I can't tell if he's just generally a poor player. 

Earth hasn't done squat so he's just null. Supa early on was an FOS of mine, but don't want to lynch him yet b/c of his claim. Budda is right that it seems noob town and I know he doesn't have a ton of experience. 

But I also wanna keep an FOS on him because then I lose any reason to have an FOS on you and my gut says to keep an FOS on you

You can FOS me at some other time. There's really no reason to now. I think Budda, drafter and myself have put forth the most analysis. Plus I breadcrumbed so I can always refer everyone back to that if/when I have to claim. I assume I'll be dead tomorrow though tbh. 

Earth hasn't done squat so he's just null. Supa early on was an FOS of mine, but don't want to lynch him yet b/c of his claim. Budda is right that it seems noob town and I know he doesn't have a ton of experience. 

Fair enough. I agree, but I do think TUF likely gave 1 fake claim so I could see a noob being eager to "confirm" themselves with it. 

sally is much more likely to be cc'd than jane by town if I'm mafia -RM

Also despite what everyone says about him, he's seen the show (I think). I'm willing to push a Supa lynch back regardless of what I say about theme. It's an outed character and we can gauge it with the characters that pop up in DP2. 

I mean it in a practical sense in terms of generating enough votes. Everyone else I think is split among how people read them. I don't know of anyone that TR's Hammer

I think Danielle mentioned previously she thought he was town. Slipped my mind to ask, 

@Danielle- why the town vibe on Hammer? 

Earth hasn't done squat so he's just null. Supa early on was an FOS of mine, but don't want to lynch him yet b/c of his claim. Budda is right that it seems noob town and I know he doesn't have a ton of experience. 

Fair enough. I agree, but I do think TUF likely gave 1 fake claim so I could see a noob being eager to "confirm" themselves with it. 

Do you think it's weird that you find Earth null but me as a scum read despite my activity/analysis? (I do.) Is there any part of my analysis that you disagree with? How about drafterman's? 

lunatic will replace me on d2 or i'll just post 0 content unless all agree to acknowledge me, I've notified him that I quit.

tell ya what, once we've got some theme analysis to go off of (legit theme analysis, not "oh they're like this in the show so I bet they're good here"), I'll listen to your arguments

you don't get it. I have established the four possible mafia characters. there's no way sally is more mafia than those 4 and no way there's more than 4 mafia.

I've played games where the mafia were heroes (or at the very least weren't villains). Idk the show and we don't have a huge hint towards theme yet so I'm gonna push it until DP2 at the earliest

Lord I would be scum reading him so hard if this wasn't par for the course with rational regardless of affiliation. 

Like I said, he seems genuinely dim regardless of Mafia. I honestly think he lacks reading comprehension (for instance, in addition to the whole John/Robert thing he said that I "scum slipped" by revealing Danny was not in the game. Meanwhile I only speculated that he MIGHT not be in the game, along with my reasoning: that Danny is TUF's profile pic. I have no idea if Danny is in the game or not).

It's funny because I always scored really high on literacy tests and wondered how the hell anyone could get less than like a 95% on reading comprehension. They literally ask you a question with the answer in the reading; you just have to go and find it. Now I see that some people just legitimately can't understand the text in front of them lol.

I do hope RM replaces out. I can't see how it's fun to play with someone who will be scum read 100% of the time regardless. It would be easy to exploit if he were actually scum, and his very presence in the game is a detriment to town. I'm also concerned that he thinks I'm "bullying" him. All I said is that everything he posts is wrong and should be ignored for the sake of the game. He probably is town despite horrible play. His vitriol toward me is a bit amusing if not concerning for his mental health. 

I think Danielle mentioned previously she thought he was town. Slipped my mind to ask, 

@Danielle- why the town vibe on Hammer? 

Have you chimed on with thoughts on GP yet? We have 30 mins to vote and I g2g soon. I'd prefer to lynch Supa or GP. 

GP: If you didn't have the no cc role claim, I'd put you as susp too

I do like the consistency in application I can see from this though. Not specifically in uncc'd role claim, but CC's in general. Earlier you mentioned that vanilla is not cc'able, ergo suspicious. 

I may disagree with me being uncc'd in my role claim makes me town. But your FoS on Supa actually is consistent with this if this is one of the primary factors your using thus far in gauging that determination. 

I'm gonna slide you into the lean town category. 

 I definitely don't town read Hammer, but I see no reason to lynch him today. He's null