Captain America: Civil War Mafia - DP1

In situations like this, where there is some anti-utility role, scum is usually smart enough to realize that they have to be on that lynch otherwise they look scummy by comparison.

Consider just last game with oro as Turn Coat. Scum would have preferred oro stay alive so they can convert him, but being conspicuously not on his lynch would have been suspicious, so they pushed for his lynch to look town sided.

This is also the exact same scenario. It is a better guarantee that scum is on Grey's wagon than it is that Grey is scum himself.

It doesn't matter his suicide day. He is lying g. There would not be a suicide and lovers in the same game with the game being this small.

THERE IS NO THEME SPLIT

My bad

There is definitely scum on Grey's wagon.

There is nothing saying the game can't, in fact, be [UNbalanced].

we should have people inviting GP

can lunch him under the 'lynch all liars' policy.

I hate to use mod psych again on an inexperienced mod but grey is semi-confirmed, or else why would speed just come out and say "there's no theme split."

No, antagonist doesn't have to be scum.

This was before speed outed that there is no thematic split. Any sane person would have assumed that bad guys = scum, like the way it is in the vast majority of themed games where there is an obvious good vs evil split.

Why would you say this:

No, antagonist doesn't have to be scum.

???

No, there are any number of possibilities, such as Cap-aligned heroes vs. Iron Man-aligned heroes.

In Speed's earlier game (The MCU Heroes game DD linked), all the characters were heroes.

Ok and in this scenario where does that put Zemo? TP at BEST. always lynch TP.

And you had to think that these "other" thematic possibilities are VERY likely in order to just come out and defend Grey like that.

Yeah that's cause the word "heroes" is literally in the title of the game.

Because what grey claimed was objectively scummy, and if you let scummers do scummy thinks and excuse it for "oh it's just retardation/WIFOM" then you're just letting scum get away with doing scummy things

Town Bullish comes in on post 61 and sees GP claimed a character that is an antagonist then votes for GP after thinking to himself "Yes, it makes sense that scum would claim their actual character under no pressure whatsoever and GP claimed an antagonist character so GP must be scum." This seems unlikely due to the fact that this line of thinking is retarded and Bullish is quite well known as a decent mafia player. Notice also how post 61 advocates for the DP to be as short as possible. Again, unlikely to come from someone known as a decent town player.

Are  you defending drafterman? If so then you have employed a LOGICAL FALACY. Just because staring someone down is a lie tell, does not mean not having the balls to look me in the eye is NOT a lie tell.

From this I have determined that you and drafter are scum together. And the third scum on your team is Lunatic.

My PM explicitly states supa as town. We can confirm each other.

Because what grey claimed was objectively scummy,

Firstly, that was a possibility. I didn't know whether or not it was correct. Secondly, this goes beyond thematic analysis into mind-reading the mod. No, he would not have to be third party. Thirdly, why would you even bring this up after Speed already clarified that there is no thematic split?

Or I could just think that no one possibility was more likely than another, so there was no thematic basis to use to reach conclusions about Grey's character (which is what I thought).

There's still an interesting contrast between this game and that one. In DP1 of the MCU Heroes mafia, several players assumed that the villains would be scum, until Speed clarified that there were no villains and no thematic split. Sounds familiar, no?

Why not?