Holy Diary DP2

That explanation makes sense. However, it doesn't reduce tracking information on a dashboard to equal someone being a bitch; nor does it explain what the crab God mechanics actually were. You're reflecting with insults rather than answering a really basic question; that combined with an inconsistent story on what powers your role has/had, have me worried.

Just paraphrase your original PM

Have you given your thoughts on Banana vs Supa yet?

My character is carcinization, my role is Crab God, I win with the town, and I do not get to know what the crab God does

lol nice omgus

I'm convinced either Barney or Savant was the role thief.

I am a bit confused on Barney's read on GP. I took #85 as he states as joking and GP did soft claim someone swapping his role early in the DP. 

However, I think there is some valid issues about how GP doesn't know what the Crab God role did. We have some unconventional roles but there was some justification. I'll ask GP, how did you not know what your role did? Was it because the grammar sucked and was written like a 3rd grader, or was it because it wasn't explained the actual function?

Oh now do the same for the new role

Nvm u answered my question

No lol, the mod specifically said I was not allowed to know what it did...I know it's fkn weird but I am brutally honest, and you know it.

Yeah just saw. Cause if it was the front I will say Wylted's grammar was pretty dogshit and I could not understand what the fuck he was saying so I had to ask a bunch of questions for clarification

This is all the mod gave me:

(no essay)

New Role:

I am the The Bio-Engineer (Playing God with Mortality)
My ability: Once per game, can swap the roles of two players.

I asked if I could try to swap back and he said the ability was used up....

If Savant is scum and GP is town and Savant switched roles with GP, it sorta explains why the role and affiliation are technically hidden. With 2 roles, it makes sense to just hide both

That's taken a bit of a backseat to both Banana and Greyparrot suggesting that their role kills if they're hammered, then changing their minds.

Greyparrots answer seems to be that anyone who questions him on it is a bitch and committing OMGUS to push for said answer.

Still awaiting Banana's answer (in fairness, I initially tagged the wrong Banana). 

...

I find Banana's killing role to not be much of a counterclaim to a vig.

I also find two characters being about Israel to be odd, even more without any commentary from them on it (Banana and Savant), which means their CC is backed by less credibility than normal CCs are.

If lynching either Vader or Banana, I'd go with Banana. I also don't see much point in not powering Vader up (better to test that his role indeed retains the killing power as claimed, than to test if he fails to make a kill when not empowered).

I haven't yet gone digging for Wylted's previous statements on Incels, but I'll get that knocked out tonight.

Your god awful take on post 85 shows you are either scum, or an idiot. I will be kind and say the former. It's more likely scum would spin a false narrative.

You’re both town, chill

So, are we all forgetting about Vader vs. Banana here?

I have some thoughts on that... although it is certainly going to depend on Banana's full claim. Give me bit to type it up.

I don’t recall GP saying this. Where did he say it?

The only way you'd know that, is if you're SCUM! 

/Obviously a joke.

Ultimatum time. Give all the details of your role or get lynched. 

GP: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/12366-hell-diary-dp-1?page=3&post_number=69

Banana: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/12381-holy-diary-dp2?page=4&post_number=96

I'm gonna have to second Pie here. Give all details or get lynched.

I know you say you've given all, but I don't think that's the case.

Please give a synopsis of everything, even if you've already stated some of it.

I’m pretty sure that was sarcasm over the fact that he doesn’t know what his role does

Oh here's something btw...

Savant isn't in the purgatory thread, despite being dead.

Actually that changes things though. I was gonna take Banana's side thinking she explained things poorly (and some sketchy things about Vader)... but now I may have to conclude he shot correctly, which would imply he's town. Hold on lemme think.

That’s a good point

Did you forget to add someone to the purgatory thread?

This is going to sound extrmely OMGUS and I hate it, but #206 from Mharman is a bad post. Townreading Banana I think is fine if you can write off some of the inconsistencies, sure. Even scum reading me is fine if you think I'm some OP mafia vig role and that I am big braining the fuck out of this game. However to have a 1 on 1 read for something that isn't even remotely a CC just urkes me in the all wrong ways and honestly, just subjectively incorrect

I don't know if I should town read this more because I feel as mafia the objective is to blend in and try not to draw so much attention and this completely draws attention

On the other hand. The lead lynch candidate is Banana from what I'm gathering to an extent. Mharman has enough town cred from a majority of the town to maybe push a 1 on 1. As scum I think that's the best way to secure a mislynch especially if they are a person down.

Ugh I am torn because I hate the fact that 2 posts throw me off so much and there's decent reasons to town read him but also some scummy shit that I also can't excuse too but now that he was going to vtl me it just makes me look omgus