I'll be active in fits and spurts today, handling filing our taxes early and a bunch of other small tasks. Just a heads up.
Hell Diary DP 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
454
-->
@AustinL0926
Thoughts?
I think we can take Ana out of today's lynch pool. From what I can see, 14 messages is indeed peculiar. A mafia member wouldn't want to make themselves immediately stand out like that.
I also have a slight town read on White flame for their push back on revealing specific information.
-->
@Barney
I distrust Lunatic right now, due to the extra Supa/Vader vote. But if town or scum the answer is too obvious to need to ask, and it’s a valid answer (we all make that kind of mistake).
I can say I genuinely did not see the savant vote, and was kind of thinking it was wierd Whiteflame was posting and not being the third vote so it made sense why when savant pointed out he already was the third vote. Anyways why is that a cause for suspicion regardless, I don’t think Vader said it would be messed up if he got to three votes twice?
-->
@whiteflame
Going to push back on doing something this specific. For some people at least, doing this is bound to give away a number of characters, or at least make it a lot easier to narrow it down. Luna and I were scum a couple of games back and used far less to figure out almost everyone's character and roles.
I’m not full on sussing you yet for this but I find it odd that I pointed out this line of logic out to you last game where you were town and you still suggested we gather some form of information. I find it extra peculiar because this theme seems so “out there” that it would provide an extra challenge to scum in solving it.
-->
@Owen_T
I think we can take Ana out of today's lynch pool. From what I can see, 14 messages is indeed peculiar. A mafia member wouldn't want to make themselves immediately stand out like that.
I disagree. I find it unusual she didn’t read her full role PM and don’t know how she can understand her role if she didn’t read it. I feel like town would have an interest in Making sure they knew as much information as possible to help solve the game. In fact I’ll put my money where my mouth is.
VTL banana
-->
@Greyparrot
so you got your role, but don’t know what it does?
that doesn’t make much sense
-->
@JoeBob
i will probably blow up and kill all the town
-->
@Greyparrot
i will probably blow up and kill all the town
You just love exploding and taking out as many people with you don’t you….
-->
@Lunatic
it's a logical guess.
VTL ANNA
-->
@whiteflame
Worth reading it in full in case there's pertinent information. I received multiple messages as well and while it looks like a lot of it is just WyIted digging into the theme, you should be making sure that you fully understand how your role works and asking him relevant questions.
I don't know that it is relevant. Its 14 pages of his thoughts on the hamas vs israel debate, and the role and how it functions is separate from the rest.
-->
@Lunatic
@Greyparrot
Why are you voting me? I understand what my role is and how it works, the rest of the 14 messages do not impact my role. It seems like it's a copy and pasted diary entry of his thoughts on the israel vs hamas conflict. I don't know why reading all of that would be relevant.
-->
@ILikePie5
Why did you not read it all?
Because it does not relate to the functionality of my role, and quite frankly I don't care about israel and hamas.
I’m gonna believe Banana here. I wasn’t immediately sold, but after hearing Banana’s reasoning here, I buy it.
I'm going to keep Ana loosely in my town pile for now.
*explanation, not reasoning
You get the gist. I’m not surprised Wylted went on a tangent about Israel vs Hamas
A townie makes some kind of claim. Does scum take immediately it at face value to buddy or does scum throw shade? Is their aim to buddy this early on, or is it to plant the seeds of a mislynch? A lot becomes clearer if I can figure out the answer.
And what combination, if a little bit of both?
Because it does not relate to the functionality of my role, and quite frankly I don't care about israel and hamas.
How do you know that if you didn’t read it?
Is everybody's role essay about a political issue?
-->
@Greyparrot
i will probably blow up and kill all the town
of course
I believe Banana for what it's worth. It just kind of made intuitive sense to me that 14 messages worth of info was probably mostly useless and not game-related. My diary entry just served to provide a loose justification for my role and that's basically it; the actual content has no real importance beyond that.
This is the first result when I googles "crab god"
No matter how many times I watch it I can figure out the message WyIted is trying to send.
-->
@Owen_T
I also have a slight town read on White flame for their push back on revealing specific information.
This is good behavioral analysis, though I will counter that Whiteflame is an experienced player and would probably do that sort of thing regardless of his alignment. Right now he's null to me. I would need to see more to have a town read on him.
-->
@iamanabanana
Why are you voting me? I understand what my role is and how it works, the rest of the 14 messages do not impact my role. It seems like it's a copy and pasted diary entry of his thoughts on the israel vs hamas conflict. I don't know why reading all of that would be relevant.
So if pressed for a justification you couldn’t justify your role? How can anyone believe your role is town over scum if you yourself don’t know? I don’t see how you don’t see this as an issue frankly.
-->
@Barney
@whiteflame
I am assuming it is at any point based on the wording of the PM. but I asked to clarify
-->
@Owen_T
I don't think this takes Ana out of the POE but this definetly alligns with what I've seen from Ana as town so I think it is a fair read