I can think of some, but I'll wait for Earth to respond so I can get a better read on him.
My rap battle is not on the list.Also unvote. I can buy lunatic's response for now, and admittedly it is a bit of a stretch. But he is contributing a lot more now, so I guess we will have to watch him and see from here.
Can you link me the question? I am not following
It's honestly nobody's business. If you believe his claim you just avoid visiting him. If you don't than visit and expose him the next day. Asking so the scum team can redirect people to him is bad.
Can you link me the question? I am not followingPost 147
Yeah I seen it. I can see what your point is, the only reason I am giving him a pass for it though is because he literally just had PGO as a role option in my last game, and I had strictly limited the role specifically because of that mestari game I mentioned. I think it's natural for him to be curious about seeing that unusual role claimed without a limitation, considering he just saw it limited in the last game. And while I can see where you going with on it being "anti-town" for him to question it, I think that part of it is going over his head if you know what I am saying. I mean he could be scum I just don't know if that alone is really enough to justify it. I don't have an alternative though, and if there was a bit more to push him on I am sure I could be sold to the lynch, and I'd rather not no lynch, but considering we have more time I am hoping we can find a more promising option.
Why does Luna make my antennae wiggle?
If I’m SOP claiming, why would I leave it out? It’s not like I’m a noob or Wylted who would leave stuff out. Also for someone as experienced as Earth, I don’t buy the “curiosity” argument.
i'm gonna sheep your vote bro.
The majority of players have voted in favor of the extension. This DP will end in approximately 9 hours at 6:00 PM EST.Votes:Lunatic (2/6): Banana, SavantEarth (2/6): Pie, WyItedBanana (1/6): Vader
Can someone explain the earth scum read to me like i'm five? I am a bit confused.
As for Luna, I'd like to see a lot more from him next DP and I'm fine seeking a full claim from him as soon as it starts. If we get Earth's claim, that will be three full claims (GP and Pie included) and a character claim + softclaimed role from WyIted, which already seems like a lot given that we know scum can ask about two characters and roles this DP.
Luna’s non-substance is not affiliation indicative. He was inactive for DP1 in the game where Savant and I basically 1v1ed. What’s pinging my radar of Luna is his defense of Earth’s action being anti-town. I feel like Luna does this a lot where he defends someone he knows is a townie. My only concern is that he has no alternative lynch atm.
I don't really think I am hard defending earth here, and I specifically only want to give him a slight pass here because of the role I gave him in my last game kind of makes sense to me why he would ask that question.
Would you agree that PGO is kind of an uncommon role? I haven't seen one in a while, and the one time I do remember the role being used, it ended in chaos and a game ending after a single day phase. I nerfed that role specifically because of said game, and earth had the option of picking said role.
I don't know that he is town or scum, just pointing out that I can see a world where earth specifically could do an anti town thing like that without thinking about it. It kind of sounds like im calling him stupid, but its more like an "airheaded" thing. He could be just trying to sus out information as scum as well, I was mostly pointing out that I would like something a little more tangible added to that to secure my vote. I have no reason to believe earth is town at the moment. And yes I admit I do not have an alternative option at this time.
I am Einstein vs Hawkings and I am the DP3 Informed Townie. Come DP3, assuming I still live, I will be given information town doesn't have.
