Fuck I mean PGO.
ERB Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
336
-->
@Earth
Yes, Casey would, given I am town. And have you already forgotten that Pie is PGO?
Very very different from the role I implemented though, as I have been pointing out to pie recently. Your version of informed seems a bit arbitrary on the other hand, seems kind of weird to make a role like that wait til dp3. If you were scum fake claiming of course that would buy you time though, similar to a innocent child claim, difference being we'd have to take you for your word that the info wasn't wrong as you wouldn't be confirmed, and by dp3 town probably couldn't afford a mislynch, so that would be a convient way to argue for your survival. It's not impossible or anything, but it does make me question the claim a bit as it is nerfed a bit arbitrarily. I will give you though that prima facie, it seems to fit your character.
-->
@Earth
@Lunatic
@Greyparrot
@whiteflame
@WyIted
Yes, Casey would, given I am town. And have you already forgotten that Pie is town?
Thanks for the scum slip
-->
@Greyparrot
Can you paraphrase your justification? I want to see something
Isn't the justification just that Einstein and Hawking are smart (i.e. informed)?
-->
@ILikePie5
Wasn't a scum slip but okay.
-->
@Savant
That would my interpretation, but its not in my PM.
-->
@ILikePie5
I did paraphrase my justification, I paraphrased the entire PM. Left nothing out.
-->
@Earth
Wasn't a scum slip but okay.
That’s a scum slip no matter how you look at it
-->
@Earth
Tbh, at this point I'm not feeling too confident on either of these lynches. Earth made maybe one mistake (I'd like him to explain why he asked, though, before I remove my vote), and Luna was maybe too busy to put in much thought. Other than the few players I'm town reading, I think we (including me) have done a poor job at narrowing down scum.
-->
@Greyparrot
I did paraphrase my justification, I paraphrased the entire PM. Left nothing out.
Okay cool. Check out the scumslip tho
-->
@Savant
Tbh, at this point I'm not feeling too confident on either of these lynches. Earth made maybe one mistake (I'd like him to explain why he asked, though, before I remove my vote), and Luna was maybe too busy to put in much thought. Other than the few players I'm town reading, I think we (including me) have done a poor job at narrowing down scum.
Check out the scumslip
That would my interpretation, but its not in my PM.
See, I don't see scum going to this level of detail. I'd expect scum earth to say he was given the justification off the bat.
-->
@ILikePie5
It's not a slip and never has been. You keep getting townies lynched for "slips" that aren't slips. Most people, including Earth, are pretty sure you are town, that's likely what Earth meant.
-->
@Savant
It's not a slip and never has been. You keep getting townies lynched for "slips" that aren't slips. Most people, including Earth, are pretty sure you are town, that's likely what Earth meant.
He can’t know with certainty I’m Town. Especially since he back tracked to mean he was saying PGO
-->
@ILikePie5
I also don't understand why claiming town explains why Casey would choose such an unusual role to copy.
-->
@ILikePie5
He can’t know with certainty I’m Town
He's assuming you are though. And scum would be way more careful with their wording.
-->
@Savant
He's assuming you are though. And scum would be way more careful with their wording.
No because scum make slips all the time.
Sorry got caught up on some homework last night and passed out early. Gonna give my reads but banana's opening post seems pretty townish IMO. Going in and doing preliminary reads first thing and contributing to town
Unvote
It's hard for me to read Luna at this moment. The scum reads on him are very viable and I think his read on Banana is fair, but I sincerely doubt that the mafia partner is going to give their band for band reads on each player. Not to mention it seems like there reads themselves feel more town. FMPOV, I feel scum try to loop a ton of people into scum reads to try and stir the pot and I don't think banana did this.
Votes:
Earth (3/6): Pie, WyIted, Savant
You couldn't even beat a Salad-in a fightYou're as soft as Monty Python knightsYou went from chainmail to chained up in jailTil Mommy drained England to pay for your bail
- Ragnar Lodbrok, "Ragnar Lodbrok vs Richard the Lionheart"
I am always suspicious of DP3 type claims in this game. I think they are inherently scummy because you are essentially just buying time til a lynch. Especially with Earth's role. I've also seen Luna use these information roles in this game and they seem very scum coded
Okay, I was unsure about earth before, but that role seems very scummy. It seems like a good claim if you were scum and were wanting to not get lynched. I'll think about it some more, but earth was already null for me, and hasn't really done anything to strike me as town, and the role claim isn't helping his case.
I won't bother with Pie today, that line of reasoning is stupid lol.
I won't bother with Pie today, that line of reasoning is stupid lol.
Guess my vote is staying on Earth.
-->
@Lunatic
@Greyparrot
@Vader
@whiteflame
We caught scum, vamanos
-->
@ILikePie5
We caught scum
That's a scum slip. How do you know Earth is scum unless you are his partner? /s
-->
@Vader
I agree, even if earth is town, the utility doesn't seem likely to be used. Scum would surely eliminate before then.
-->
@ILikePie5
VTL EARTH
baa, baa, baa
-->
@Savant
That's a scum slip. How do you know Earth is scum unless you are his partner? /s
🙄🙄🙄