Inheritance Cycle Mafia DP1

Fair though I mostly see the use of this list being to identify characters that are too "sidey" as being more likely suspect claims. There are only 9 players and there are at least that many main or big characters, probably a few I left out too. Characters not on that list will be a big red flag for me, assuming its just not a big one I forgot about.

According to him its automatic right? If we lynch someone as normal, and get them to l-1 his role should automate.

That's a fair point, actually. I know when I was designing Ace Attorney Mafia, I didn't get to include all the main characters I wanted. Miles Edgeworth and Dick Gumshoe were both notable omissions, but all the characters I did include were at least fairly important characters. Ace Attorney just has a ton of characters, and from the looks of it, it seems like this series has a lot of characters as well. That makes Cerulean seem a bit more sus. 

My character and role are also very closed tied together.

It might be worthwhile to say if our characters are on the "Important Characters" list here. I ask specifically because mine isn't. This might narrow some things down.

Keep in mind we have until january 5th so even with limited activity right now we aren't in a super huge rush. 

Oh I see it. Yeah this is a bit sus. I'd like a character claim in this case. Chance are it is a bigger character than he thought, but if it isn't that is a bit odd. Cerulean can you at least answer if your character is on my list?

Main Characters Likely to exist:

Main Protagonists:

Eragon: I would be surprised if Eragon wasn't in the game as he is literally the protagonist of the books. He's the first person to bind to a dragon since the fall of dragons.

Roran: Leader of the Caravahall resistence, Eragon's cousing. A complete Fvcking badass and my favorite character in the books. "Stronghammer". Wields a basic blacksmith hammer but destroys everything he comes into contact with. Doesn't have powers like Eragon to be a complete badass. 

Saphira: Eragon's dragon, can communicate with him telepathically. Can do basically anything a dragon can do. Likely in the game.

Brom: Brom is like the Gandalf of this series, there is a very high chance he is in the game. He teaches Eragon Magic, and mentors him. It's also later revealed that he is actually Eragon's father as a big plot twist. He dies fairly early on in the first book, but is still likely to be in the game with how prominent he is.

Arya: Eragon's love interest, she is the daughter of Queen Islanzadi.She accompanies Eragon through most of his adventures. I think she rejects him due to an age gap initially despite having feelings for him. She is  like 100s of years old of and hes literally a prebuscent teenager. She's a badass in combat too if I remember correctly. 

Big Side Characters:

Orik- King of dwarves

Oromis- Eragon's second mentor

Nasuada- Daughter of Ajihad, leader of the Varden after he father dies.

Angela- A Fortune telling time space and dimension traveling witch, who has a cat and gives Eragon a big hint to his future early in book 1. 

Do you see any big harm in claiming it?

yes, the fact I think it could make me a utility lynch if there are no good suspects, which I think would be a mistake.

Fair though I mostly see the use of this list being to identify characters that are too "sidey" as being more likely suspect claims. There are only 9 players and there are at least that many main or big characters, probably a few I left out too. Characters not on that list will be a big red flag for me, assuming its just not a big one I forgot about.

I read this book series probably three or four times in my youth, but i'll admit it has been at least 10-15 years since I have read it so I am very foggy on the details. Paolini was my favorite author when I was like 16. 

Fuck it. I think Earth claiming while normally dumb is smart here. I have to visit one person a night and who I visit gets vanillaized so I can just vanillaized Earth and he is no longer a liability assuming he is honest

That's a bit of modpsych and I'm not going to lean heavily on that view, but Cerulean's decision to out this in the same post where he was asking if anyone was among the major characters gives me a bit of a behavioral counter to said red flag.

I know its WIFOM, but I would do that as scum too if I was going into a theme I wasn't all too familiar with and didn't want to risk getting CC'ed by anyone.

Fair enough. I tend to think that games like this where scum can ask about two characters' presence in the game are more likely to feature scum taking what look like bigger risks with their claims, if only because they have a greater opportunity to do so at low risk. That's WIFOM as well, but I can see how they might reach your conclusion as well.

It works immediately.  I have not asked if it resolves before their night action yet, but I assume bothe actions resolve simultaneously 

Also.hopefully we can get agreement that anyone vanillaized, admits to it on their very first post the next dp.