-->
@whiteflame
@Casey_Risk
You know what? If Banana's first, she can pick the next target then.
Bo Burnham Songs Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
485
-->
@Casey_Risk
The. Take your shot ASAP. The game needs to be played aggressively
-->
@Mharman
@WyIted
@Casey_Risk
@Moozer325
@Owen_T
I am fine with giving my character. I am "welcome to the internet". I am not giving more though, because I do not feel there is adequate reason for me to do so. What exactly about my post did you take issue with? My guess is that you expect a woman to respond to aggressive males like pie and be completely demure and submissive? Take your world view of women out the equation for a second and look at the argument on its face.
Y’all think this is normal behavior from Banana?
-->
@ILikePie5
8 saw she is on right now so I take back what I said
I am going to bed soon. I am not going to respond to pie's line by line thing he does ever. He's got his mind made up and that is that, I am not giving anything more. If you think that is enough basis to lynch me go ahead. In the meantime I am going to keep my vote on pie, because I stand by the fact that I think he is being overly defensive, and so far my instincts have served me well. This doesn't seem like normal behavior from someone who doesn't have something to hide.
It's like a woman catches a man cheating, he turns around and calls her the cheater, only for mountains of evidence to later come out that the man was indeed cheating. This type of thing literally happens all the time IRL, don't see why it would be different here. Pie is being extremely defensive.
-->
@iamanabanana
Okay so now that you are online and I am sorry about your luck but now you need to full claim because we are going to decide a lynch within the next 30 minutes or so and it's probably between you and pie. Though It could also be a no lynch if you guys look good
-->
@iamanabanana
I am fine with giving my character. I am "welcome to the internet". I am not giving more though, because I do not feel there is adequate reason for me to do so.
Wait this is kinda sus. I've listened to this song.
Banana, since you voluntarily claimed, Imma say I want a full claim from you now. You can get a full claim from someone else in return. Preferably my pool.
You did say you were willing to claim ealier, and you seemed confident back when the wagon was more on Pie... what's stopping you from honoring that? I'm not looking to hear there's no reason for you to fullclaim... that's not good enough now, considering your character claim.
-->
@ILikePie5
Y’all think this is normal behavior from Banana?
And you prove my point by not quoting the argument I made, and pointing out the part that you are insecure about. Thanks for proving me right. :)
-->
@iamanabanana
Just claim. Even if it is anpower role itnis better you die as an NK than as a lynch
-->
@iamanabanana
It's like a woman catches a man cheating, he turns around and calls her the cheater, only for mountains of evidence to later come out that the man was indeed cheating. This type of thing literally happens all the time IRL, don't see why it would be different here. Pie is being extremely defensive.
??? Or maybe he just didn't like his push on you. That's just OMGUS, and it happens male-to-male all the time. It's usually scummy, but it can be towny and now I'm thinking I might flip on you.
What a horrible defense.
-->
@iamanabanana
We are mostly males here so just consider claiming as your way of making us sandwiches if that's easier for you
unvote VTL banana
-->
@Mharman
Noted, but I also get the frustration a little bit from the town perspective. The initial arguments still aren't that great.
I agree…if she was asked to claim at the beginning. She wasn’t.
I'm calling it OMGUS because of the way you took it.
She was lying about me, and using that to form a scumread and justify a vote
You're really not in a position for this, but I am willing to get Banana's first if you still claim. I assume that her claim is the one you're picking here?
I am in a position for this actually. I have the support of 4 people including myself on Banana right now.
I believe that part. I just think your push on Banana is still fairly unbelievable, so it strikes me as one that was done quickly without too much thought.
Okay fine. Let’s take your word for it. Imagine I am town and look at the reaction from Banana and compare it to her actions in prior games. There is a notable difference
Also WTF banana. You know that it is okay for high value males to cheat and not for females. It's a false equivalency. If I accuse my woman of cheating, she doesn't have to accuse me of cheating because I tell her I cheat. She can deal with it or starve on the street.
-->
@WyIted
Holy shit glad your corporate HR's not here to hear this joke... it's so funny they'd want to hear it too
-->
@ILikePie5
Fair. I'm not liking Banana now.
-->
@iamanabanana
I am fine with giving my character. I am "welcome to the internet".
I believe that that claim must be in this game because it's one of Bo Burnham's most popular songs. It's mainly a matter of whether it was given to town or scum.
Don't love all the accusations of sexism.
-->
@Mharman
Just as a matter of principle if she doesn't claim in 15 minutes she should be the lynch. I would honestly prefer to lynch Pie but she needs to be a team player here
-->
@Mharman
??? Or maybe he just didn't like his push on you. That's just OMGUS, and it happens male-to-male all the time. It's usually scummy, but it can be towny and now I'm thinking I might flip on you.What a horrible defense.
The gender part is what you latched onto, but the point remains the same. Could be the man accusing the woman and the woman doubling down.
Yeah Pie is shifting into my town pile. Definetly acting like how he is as town to a certain extent.
-->
@WyIted
That being said... not helping, even though I know you're trolling.
-->
@iamanabanana
I think you're missing the broader point here. It's less the content of your argument and moreso the very aggressive nature of it, which is a typical scumtell. I'd associate a sudden aggressiveness from someone with them being likely scum regardless of gender or anything, all other factors being equal. The point is, we're trying to get claims from players here. I do want your claim, but I also want Pie's, and Mharman feels the same way. If you don't claim soon, you're likely just going to be lynched.
-->
@WyIted
@iamanabanana
Just as a matter of principle if she doesn't claim in 15 minutes she should be the lynch. I would honestly prefer to lynch Pie but she needs to be a team player here
I'll hammer myself if needed.
The time is now Banana. Full claim please. I'm not even offering you anything in return at this point; I'm demanding. We can revisit w deal to get someone else of your choice to claim if you are saved by your full claim.
-->
@whiteflame
Don't love all the accusations of sexism.
Wow, mansplaining much?
Fucking misogynist.
This Owen wagon is out of left field. I know what I said about Owen but it just seems likely everyone is hopping on this wagon without true rhyme or reason
-->
@iamanabanana
I am going to bed soon. I am not going to respond to pie's line by line thing he does ever. He's got his mind made up and that is that, I am not giving anything more.
So you’re not going to full claim?
If you think that is enough basis to lynch me go ahead.
We will 100% lynch you if you don’t claim. If you do claim and it’s satisfactory, I will reconsider
In the meantime I am going to keep my vote on pie, because I stand by the fact that I think he is being overly defensive, and so far my instincts have served me well. This doesn't seem like normal behavior from someone who doesn't have something to hide.
???
It's like a woman catches a man cheating, he turns around and calls her the cheater, only for mountains of evidence to later come out that the man was indeed cheating. This type of thing literally happens all the time IRL, don't see why it would be different here. Pie is being extremely defensive.
What?
I am "welcome to the internet".
I am a reporter, because the internet gives us a little bit of everything all of the time, and we have the whole world of information at our fingertips. Each night I can select a player and I will be told if they acted at night or not.
I want pie to claim next.
-->
@iamanabanana
The gender part is what you latched onto, but the point remains the same. Could be the man accusing the woman and the woman doubling down.
I thought females didn't have bananas?
unvote
That's fair
-->
@iamanabanana
The gender part is what you latched onto, but the point remains the same. Could be the man accusing the woman and the woman doubling down.
Yeah, I'm not viewing this conflict from that kinda lens. Absolutely not. The fact that you would go for an argument so illogical is a sign of desperation. Did I note that you didn't really defend yourself with any good arguments earlier? I think I did.
-->
@Casey_Risk
(as well as the fact that he said I've been asking vague questions, which is just factually wrong), but then he backed off and I'm back to a null read on him.
I have an issue with this statement. Seems extremely OMGUS. I backed off because I mistakenly thought what Luna said. If you had a scum read on me before I switched my reasoning, why did you switch it to null when I switched to null. Seems ultra defensive IMO and tbh out of no where.