I think this should be fine. Something like month + year the character came into existence + where it’s from (ie book, movie, game, play, etc). Still keeps the range open, but heavily restricts it as well.
This is him trying to get more information. It's one thing to try and limit scum teams fake claims, it's another thing to give yourself an easy way to guess someone's chaaracter so you can try and take a stab at their role.
I actually want to move to Mharman for insinuating that no one should claim because it would give scum information.
Here he is moving onto me for mislynch for speaking an obvious truth.
Post 121, he says that he doesn’t support the Wylted train because it’s going to help scum get identify PRs, which doesn’t make sense at all unless he knows Wylted is town.
Terrible logic. He's reaching here.
And then there's his whole overanaylsis into something I said when I wasn't thinking super clearly. I did the same thing last game and he hasn't addressed my point, except with a weak attempt to invalidate my point by saying me doing it last game invalidates the reason I did it this time.
