-->
@Savant
Wait when did you role claim?
Ace Attorney Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
884
-->
@Earth
I didn't, but I character claimed. I am Athena Cykes.
Slight townread on Earth for that question, since if he was scum I think he would be keeping track of all claims, or his scum partner would be.
-->
@Earth
@Savant
I interpreted this as a reluctance to get a read. I don't think it is the only post though
Earlier I was accused of "tunneling" for saying I scum read someone
I haven't seen tunneling from you this game.
-->
@Savant
Slight townread on Earth for that question, since if he was scum I think he would be keeping track of all claims, or his scum partner would be.
Why do you think this, Because as scum I just am too lazy to do that. I know earth is not me but is it normal to remember claims
-->
@Savant
You said back in #236 that you role claimed. I assume that was a typo?
You guys really dont understand RVS do you. Why are we still talking about that
-->
@Earth
@Lunatic
Yeah, probably a typo.
You guys really dont understand RVS do you. Why are we still talking about that
Scum is between you and me at this point. You should probably claim.
-->
@Savant
Why are you being so friendly towards him if he is scum?
Maybe say something about his mom or call Jim gay. This is unconvincing
-->
@WyIted
We'll get him this round or the next one. I don't think it matters if I'm nice to him.
-->
@Lunatic
@whiteflame
@Mharman
@AustinL0926
@WyIted
Luna is probably panicking right now. He knows we've narrowed it down to me or him, but he can't admit that without getting himself lynched today or tomorrow. He probably hoped we would come to a different conclusion while he was offline, but there's no way I'm letting him off the hook until he at least responds. And I don't see any way out of this for him.
-->
@Lunatic
I'll do it for you Savant.
I find you mildly annoying at times and your hair is exceptionally hairy.
I find you mildly annoying at times and your hair is exceptionally hairy.
I'm sorry. That was too far.
Let's say Austin is scum. What would this gambit gain him? 2 town kills for 1 scum kill. Maybe 3 if he got lucky, but probably 2 at most.
Serious question. Why are we so suspicious of Savant?
-->
@Owen_T
Luna has a birth mark in the shape of a lightning bolt on his left testicle. Make fun of that he hates when I tease him for it
-->
@WyIted
This is why I want us to lynch Luna. May as well let him full claim, but he'd still be my top scum read.
-->
@Owen_T
Austn said he has an ability which makes 1 mafia person between me, savant and lunatic. If Austin is being honest it puts scum between savant or scum, because they assume me fucking up my claim earlier is a town tell. Is barney helping you at all?
-->
@Owen_T
Why are we so suspicious of Savant?
Happens every game, whether I am scum or not.
-->
@WyIted
it puts scum between savant or scum
Do you mean savant or Luna?
-->
@WyIted
More importantly, how do you know about the scar?
-->
@Savant
I honestly think Austin should full claim first. Once you narrow scum to 2 possible people you should give us a reason to trust you. Usually being that scared to claim after something like this is indicative of town caring too much about their role instead of behavioral analysis. If I was a 2x cop and got a guilty I would likely fill claim and lose my roles utility before even stating my results to build trust
unvote
-->
@Savant
Do you mean savant or Luna?
I guess you know which way I am leaning now though that was meant to stay in my head so he felt more comfortable
-->
@WyIted
What else could he say that we don't already know? If his role has any more features, he will just not say them until later.
-->
@Savant
Could you lay out your case for sussing Luna? It seems like it's all over the place at this point and it's late enough that I'm not going to go back through the DP and compile it myself.
-->
@Owen_T
More importantly, how do you know about the scar?
2 drunk guys in Vegas at a Trump rally. Shit happens
-->
@Savant
What else could he say that we don't already know? If his role has any more features, he will just not say them until later.
It's fine to lie as town, but he should make a claim and then lie and say there is nothing more to it if he wants to keep something to himself
-->
@WyIted
Let's say Austin is scum. What would this gambit gain him? 2 town kills for 1 scum kill. Maybe 3 if he got lucky, but probably 2 at most.
Not that I am saying Austin is mafia or lying, but if Mafia!Austin's gambit worked in mislynching 2 towns, that'll place town at MYLOLYLO.
If he's being honest scum won't keep him in the game too long anyway so not like lying will cause a mislynch
-->
@whiteflame
Could you lay out your case for sussing Luna?
The main reason is that I know I'm not scum. Here are more reasons that should appeal to the rest of you:
1. I'm willing to admit that scum is probably me or Luna. Luna hasn't admitted that. My question is, why would a scum player admit they are in a very small POE? It doesn't work in their interest.
2. Luna sussed WyIted solely based on mod psyche and voted for WyIted based on that suspicion. It seems like such a stretch to actually vote based on WyIted not being scum yet. Now we know that WyIted is probably town due to an earlier slip, which makes Luna's read make even less sense.
3. Luna said that lynching me might be a good call even if I am town, because I was wrong about scum and tunneled in a previous game. Advocating lynching someone even if they are town seems more likely to come from a scum player than a town player, imo.