Updated reads:
Confirmed Town: None
Solid Town
420-1776 - I am sticking to my theory that post 56 was a town slip but would still like to hear more from them.
Pie - Thinking on a townie wavelength, pointing out things that it would not benefit scum to point out, and putting in what I interpret as genuine efforts to actively scum hunt.
Wylted - First to lock into a claim and the reads on others seem reasonable, as well as what seems like genuine active scum hunting and aggressive narrowing of scum pool.
Lean Town
Casey - Gut feeling and my town reads town read them. That's enough for me to feel okay with a lean town read at least.
Null (top is closer to town bottom is closer to scum but no strong feelings on any of them either way)
Mharman - Low activity because the game just started yesterday but I like what I see so far
Barney - Similar to Mharman but with less good gut vibes. My gut alone is telling me to put Barney in lean scum but multiple people have described this as normal behavior on their part so I'll leave it null for now.
Savant - I disagree with all their reads which is an indication they may just be coming up with nonsense, particularly in the case of 420-1776, though it is always just possible that we just disagree. Largely moved up to null because of the promise of confirmability.
Lean Scum
Whiteflame - No active scum hunting whatsoever. Though that is normal most of the time in DP 1 when combined with the initial reasons I had them in the lean scum category and the convenient timing of their reads post I feel comfortable leaving them here. Nothing has been done to move them up or down the list in my eyes.
Solid Scum: None
Confirmed Scum: None
