-->
@Mharman
I don’t understand why you want a claim from him. It’s not gonna help us find scum.
Personally I usually just ask for claims to avoid a mislynch not as a tool to catch scum
Clash Of Clans Mafia Day Phase 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
742
Anyways, that’s gonna be it for now. That long ass post burned me out a little bit.
I have a long list of things from this DP to analyze, and I promise I will get it to later tonight, like 9 or 10 ish EST. But for now, back to being a lazy ass.
If you see me pop on and off line, don’t freak out; I’m just skimming/making a mental note of the things I should take a closer look at when I do go down that rabbit hole (again, later tonight, I promise).
-->
@WyIted
Wdym by that
Ok that’s actually it for now cy’all
-->
@Mharman
I followed your face reveal link and I expected you to be black just from previously having heard your voice.
-->
@ILikePie5
@WyIted
Like I said, I’m going to be busy for a couple of hours (thanks for the condolences WyIted), but I’ll claim if desired when I come back online later.
-->
@Mharman
I don’t understand why you want a claim from him. It’s not gonna help us find scum.
Why not? If his character doesn’t work with his role or he gets CCed, it’s good for us.
Updated reads:
Confirmed Town: None
Solid Town
420-1776 - I am sticking to my theory that post 56 was a town slip but would still like to hear more from them.
Pie - Thinking on a townie wavelength, pointing out things that it would not benefit scum to point out, and putting in what I interpret as genuine efforts to actively scum hunt.
Wylted - First to lock into a claim and the reads on others seem reasonable, as well as what seems like genuine active scum hunting and aggressive narrowing of scum pool.
Lean Town
Casey - Gut feeling and my town reads town read them. That's enough for me to feel okay with a lean town read at least.
Null (top is closer to town bottom is closer to scum but no strong feelings on any of them either way)
Mharman - Low activity because the game just started yesterday but I like what I see so far
Barney - Similar to Mharman but with less good gut vibes. My gut alone is telling me to put Barney in lean scum but multiple people have described this as normal behavior on their part so I'll leave it null for now.
Savant - I disagree with all their reads which is an indication they may just be coming up with nonsense, particularly in the case of 420-1776, though it is always just possible that we just disagree. Largely moved up to null because of the promise of confirmability.
Lean Scum
Whiteflame - No active scum hunting whatsoever. Though that is normal most of the time in DP 1 when combined with the initial reasons I had them in the lean scum category and the convenient timing of their reads post I feel comfortable leaving them here. Nothing has been done to move them up or down the list in my eyes.
Solid Scum: None
Confirmed Scum: None
unvote VTL whiteflame
Official Vote Count:
iLikePie5- 1/5- savant
Whiteflame- 3/5- wylted, iLikePie5, DD
Here and analyzing. This will take a while.
-->
@Mharman
We are waiting on Whiteflame
-->
@ILikePie5
@Discipulus_Didicit
@WyIted
Alright, I'm back so I'm just going to claim since otherwise this is likely to end in my lynch:
I'm the Guard Post, and my role is the Cop. The role has a limited use case to it, though I think providing that information is net negative to town, so unless someone has a good reason for me to provide it, I'm going to leave my claim here.
unvote
Official Vote Count:
iLikePie5- 1/5- savant
Whiteflame- 2/5- wylted, DD
I think we have enough information for the time being.
unvote
we just have to decide lynch or no lynch and if we choose lynch than negotiate a target
-->
@whiteflame
I'm the Guard Post, and my role is the Cop. The role has a limited use case to it, though I think providing that information is net negative to town, so unless someone has a good reason for me to provide it, I'm going to leave my claim here.
What’s your justification?
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
Whiteflame - No active scum hunting whatsoever. Though that is normal most of the time in DP 1 when combined with the initial reasons I had them in the lean scum category and the convenient timing of their reads post I feel comfortable leaving them here. Nothing has been done to move them up or down the list in my eyes.
I can't really argue with this since I've been relatively absent. I've tried to contribute to a larger degree when I post, but if you scumread me for the timing, I've already said what explains it.
-->
@WyIted
I think we have enough information for the time being.unvotewe just have to decide lynch or no lynch and if we choose lynch than negotiate a target
I would like WF’s justification first. If I find it satisfactory, I think we can lynch Barney or no lynch. He hasn’t posted since last night and it’s been all fluff. Keep in mind Lunatic said this game is very swingy
-->
@ILikePie5
Guard Posts are defensive, they have large ranges, and are good for identifying enemy troops before they hit the base.
-->
@whiteflame
Guard Posts are defensive, they have large ranges, and are good for identifying enemy troops before they hit the base.
Hmm. I don’t like this at all. I need to ask Luna something first
-->
@whiteflame
I'm the Guard Post, and my role is the Cop. The role has a limited use case to it, though I think providing that information is net negative to town, so unless someone has a good reason for me to provide it, I'm going to leave my claim here.
I assume that by limited use case you mean something like 2x uses or even nights or something of that general nature? Not asking for the full details if that is the case, just want to make sure I understand what you are saying correctly and you aren't saying something that's going fully over my head.
-->
@ILikePie5
Hmm. I don’t like this at all. I need to ask Luna something first
Alright, whatever you need to do.
My assumption is that a certain series of events have to occur and whiteflame has a type of weak investigative role.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
assume that by limited use case you mean something like 2x uses or even nights or something of that general nature?
Along those lines, yes.
-->
@whiteflame
Along those lines, yes
When I made my jewdar claim, were you feeling like it was a soft claim for an investigative role, and if yes what were you thinking about that?
420 has almost completely disappeared after it seemed that people were town reading him. This is somebody desperate to get his post count up so he can spam the forum with as much stupid shit as best Korea doss
-->
@WyIted
When I made my jewdar claim, were you feeling like it was a soft claim for an investigative role, and if yes what were you thinking about that?
I didn’t think it was a soft claim. Came off more as something to gauge my response than anything else.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
@WyIted
I have reason to believe WF is fake claiming. Waiting on Luna to answer a question
-->
@whiteflame
Along those lines, yes.
Can you use it NP 1?