Pie Recycled Roles Mafia DP1

I want to hear from Luna before I proceed, but given my earlier intuitions and whiteflame's scum read, I think Austin will probably be the best lynch target today.

Does it matter? If he cops you, then explain yourself or just say he was misdirected. 

It doesn't look good for you tbh. It just looks like the scum team doesn't want to target Austin tonight for whatever reason so you claimed a miller role

whiteflame and Luna both disagreed with your earlier intuitions

I can call this move a lot of things. “Calculated” is not one of them. You’re guaranteed to be our lynch unless someone else proves clearly sus just because your role is unconfirmable and negative utility, but you’ve made it worse by selecting a uniquely bad time to give it.

You cannot be seriously suggesting that you as a townie would buy that.

I think the new claim could recontextualize what you said earlier. I'm still giving some weight to my earlier intuitions even if other good players disagreed with them. Scum players tend to give multiple tells, and different players will notice different ones. I was mostly town reading you because Luna said you were acting super townie, idk if he will still feel that way. And if I gave weight to whiteflame's defense of you earlier, then I also have to give weight to his wanting to lynch you now.

I would buy it. I would because I have said numerous times before miller's should not claim DP1, but if they do it should be immediate and if they find themselves on the block DP1, they typically should fake claim.

I have also said, after DP1, if copped they should be honest and we then have to evaluate the claim and treat it like any other claim.

I have been miller and I can tell you the cop has never investigated me as a  miller so it's not a huge risk, and cops usually die early in the game anyway

I don't really see a world in which you could plausibly argue that I would go for this specific claim and timing as scum instead of sitting tight and letting another lynch go through.

If Austin was really scum, I think it would have been pretty dumb of him to claim so late

Odds shifted from 7/9 chance of you being town to 3/4 chance of you being scum if you are telling the truth about your game.

If you thought I was going to cop you, then this is your best play at the moment whether you are miller or scum. I believe you are telling the truth that you think I may cop you.

But statistically, scum are more common than millers.

Another thing is that a miller claim is more advantageous for scum after they know there's a cop, whereas a miller might claim right away because they already know there's a cop. So claiming after my claim is a bit suspect. It's also odd you didn't breadcrumb anything about knowing a cop is probably in the game.

Instead of challenging people's perception of you, why don't you hunt scum? If you are not scum, the wah out of this is to show stronger evidence that somebody else is scum. Everyone posted and I promise, somebody tucked up somewhere and it was overlooked

Everyone posted and I promise, somebody tucked up somewhere and it was overlooked