-->
@Elminster
Honestly, you were the main one I was concerned about this DP. When mafia NK'd you, I knew I was in good shape.
How did you know you were next to die lmao
Paranoia - Day 3
Posts
Read-only
Total:
247
-->
@That1User
I kept softing doc trying to bait a nk
(This was before I knew mimes were a thing )
-->
@Elminster
I thought wf was mime and user was scum
Out of curiosity, because you had the strongest read on me (a little too late, though you didn't know there were mimes), what gave me away?
-->
@Lunatic
Btw if both mafia got lynched, you would have had once chance to guess which of the four flipped vanillas was the seer. If guessed correctly you would have won. Who would you have honestly guessed between me, speed, elmin, and that1 was the seer?
Definitely you lmao. But hindsight is 20/20 Ig lol. It would’ve been you cause you could’ve died if you said something, which fits the Seer role. I look at the role list a lot lol
-->
@Lunatic
What was your vanilla mod lmao
-->
@Elminster
I mean when we lynched you I had no idea. After the flip it was all on mafia.After I was dead and drafter wouldn't let me replace I was screaming at luna that wf was a mime lol
Lol yeah I never heard of a Mime either but tbh I like it as a TP in this set-up. I thought it was balanced with 2 scum and especially in a Paranoia theme. Like I said it's cool that once you become aware of a mime, you are hesitant to lynch a "scummy" player cuz you dunno if they are intentionally appearing scummy or not.
Pie and Croc had to use POE much like town did to try and figure out who not to lynch on DP3, while at the same time still getting others lynched to win the majority and not appear informed. I really liked it. I'm not a fan of the Jester role and normally hate TPs, but this was cool.
-->
@whiteflame
Danielle's flip and your refusal to claim a role in hindsight. It broke the idea in my head of you being a noob and turned it to "o shit hes casually trying to die"
-->
@That1User
What was your vanilla mod lmao
I wasn't actually vanilla, I was Seer lol. I used the word thing as a fake claim because I knew I would flip vanilla, and needed a believable paranoia inducing role that would give me longevity.
-->
@That1User
Yeah Idk why it didn't occur to Supa he could be insane cop, he was so narrowly focused that I was guilty and IlikePie was inno, that possibility didn't even come up in his mind
That’s the reason I was second guessing myself on you being Mime lol
-->
@Danielle
@whiteflame
How did you coordinate with whiteflame to win Danielle?
-->
@ILikePie5
Definitely you lmao. But hindsight is 20/20 Ig lol. It would’ve been you cause you could’ve died if you said something, which fits the Seer role. I look at the role list a lot lol
That and I was seeding too much doubt in croc dp1 which I am assuming is why you killed me. I figured if at least one of the other vanillas would have scum read either of you I would have stood a better chance but as the game progressed that seemed unlikely lol. I was praying for a mime win at that point so I wouldn't have to carry towns loss on my shoulders lol
-->
@Lunatic
Might have been more balanced if town didn't lose the potato. with the potato out in play, vtnl can still end up killing mafia with the potato.
After we lost the potato I was like...town be royally fucked.
-->
@Elminster
Well, you totally got it. I was trying to be subtle to invite the lynch, definitely worked in the end.
-->
@whiteflame
Yeah I'm surprised they were so lose with votes cus of a self hammer but seems like they wanted tp to win vs mafia haha
-->
@That1User
Honestly, we didn't have to discuss much. The initial thought was for one of us to claim BP or PGO, and she went with the latter after enough people had claimed that it wouldn't be super sus from the start. I was going to claim a few times, but kept getting cover for it, and inviting suspicion by not claiming ended up being the better route.
-->
@Lunatic
That and I was seeding too much doubt in croc dp1 which I am assuming is why you killed me. I figured if at least one of the other vanillas would have scum read either of you I would have stood a better chance but as the game progressed that seemed unlikely lol. I was praying for a mime win at that point so I wouldn't have to carry towns loss on my shoulders lol
That wasn’t actually our logic. At that point we thought GP was a Mason so killing him wouldn’t be optimal cause of protective roles. So we went with who we thought he’d recruit which was you. It was kinda a two birds with one stone type of thing because of your experience as well
-->
@Elminster
Lol, yeah. Wasn't expecting to ride that to a win, but I'll take it.
-->
@Speedrace
Send roles .
Lego
Lego
-->
@Lunatic
That and I was seeding too much doubt in croc dp1 which I am assuming is why you killed me. I figured if at least one of the other vanillas would have scum read either of you I would have stood a better chance but as the game progressed that seemed unlikely lol. I was praying for a mime win at that point so I wouldn't have to carry towns loss on my shoulders lol
Your prayer was answered
-->
@ILikePie5
That wasn’t actually our logic. At that point we thought GP was a Mason so killing him wouldn’t be optimal cause of protective roles. So we went with who we thought he’d recruit which was you. It was kinda a two birds with one stone type of thing because of your experience as well
Well that honestly makes me feel better lol. Because I don't bear as much responsibility for a town loss in that case for playing seer horribly lol.
-->
@Lunatic
@That1User
I'm happy we could at least help TP out. There's plenty of games where TP cant win and ends up helping town so I consider it karmic payback.
-->
@Lunatic
I had to flip a coin who to toss potato to since it's always either you or dani killed np1
-->
@Greyparrot
I'm happy we could at least help TP out. There's plenty of games where TP cant win and ends up helping town so I consider it karmic payback.
I would’ve helped town win rather than TP cause they destroyed our plans
-->
@Greyparrot
It would have been interesting to see how the game played out if you had seen me claim PGO on Day Phase 1.
-->
@Greyparrot
I had to flip a coin who to toss potato to since it's always either you or dani killed np1
I actually don't get killed often np1 in forum mafia, mostly live mafia. Everyone on forum mafia suspects me all the time, so usually mafia keep me around for a potential mislynch lol
-->
@Danielle
I would have given it to lunatic, although I rarely trust pgo claims without solid behavioral backups
-->
@ILikePie5
@Crocodile
Y'all should've instantly known WF was mime since you knew he wasn't scum lol
Also my game is going up tonight so stop pinging me
-->
@Speedrace
Looking forward to it!
-->
@Speedrace
Y'all should've instantly known WF was mime since you knew he wasn't scum lol
Well ya but he could’ve been town too lol. I started second guessing myself after Supa said I was inno