-->
@Lunatic
I feel like this worked well with live mafia. It forces everyone to participate and locks scum into a position.
Riddle Mafia - Day Phase 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
497
Speedrace is scummy as hell right now
"Magic is scum if Mikal is telling truth"
"buuuttt... let's not lynch her off that."
If Speed is scum I have a feeling Magic is scum
If Speed is scum I have a feeling Magic is scum
-->
@Greyparrot
Are we lynching pie for claim?
Pie already claimed. Do you mean for 'confirmation'?
-->
@LikeMagic
I feel like this worked well with live mafia. It forces everyone to participate and locks scum into a position.
We did it in reverse in live mafia, ask everyone who they would have targeted after a np passed. It was particularly useful for the werewolf/mafia set up where knowing who was visited by the cops or see was useful in determining who was a werewolf or mafia member.
Projecting who you will target in advance defeats the purpose
Seer*
-->
@Lunatic
She would have. It was a reaction test
-->
@LikeMagic
Since there are likely anti-town roles and I suspect that a riddle theme game will have some trickery and shenanigans, I think everyone should respond by the end of the DP with who they would target in the NP if they had a role.
I don't like this idea. Then scum can just target someone that no one else is targeting and know that they'll get away with it.
I actually am torn from pie being a retard and pie being scum
I don't buy he is big brain , he likes trump. He's like a borderline neanderthal. I mean if you give a monkey a pen, it can write it's name once in a century but I just don't buy it.
My hesitation is that he could be town and stupid and if we don't text it then it's basically a target mafia can't hit.
-->
@Mikal
She would have. It was a reaction test
Kind of figured lol
Test*
-->
@Mikal
So Danielle didn't actually say anything about Magic being scum?
I just can't solidify my read on our as stupid or scum.
Not sure what to do tbh
Not sure what to do tbh
-->
@Mikal
I had a feeling it was a reaction test because I feel like danielle would have said something to defend herself if it was true. I still town read her but I guess she could have yelled at danielle in the pm prior to posting, and danielle could have said she wouldn't have said that under any circumstance, which made her react how she did confidently. Not sure. I won't place too much stalk in it though.
-->
@SirAnonymous
She called magic hot and then went on a rant about yyw being unbearable if I recall but nothing about the game
-->
@Mikal
She called magic hot and then went on a rant about yyw being unbearable if I recall but nothing about the game
Sounds about right.
-->
@Lunatic
Yeah it's possible she pmene danielle prior to posting. Danielle is not active now which was why I did it but I guess she could have texted her
Also
Vtl max
For being a jew
-->
@Mikal
I just can't solidify my read on our as stupid or scum.Not sure what to do tbh
Wouldn't lynching him be the right move in either case? If he's scum, we got him (unless there's lynchproof scum, which I've never seen before). If he's town, he's confirmed.
-->
@SirAnonymous
Him not dying does not confirm him. Scum can easily be lynch proof. If he is scum that's likely he's role. A scum would not claim that without being willing to be tested.
If he is town then we waste a way to force mafia to kill how we want
Anyone gonna point out Speed saying "Magic is scum.....but I don't wanna lynch off that"
-->
@Mikal
Him not dying does not confirm him. Scum can easily be lynch proof. If he is scum that's likely he's role. A scum would not claim that without being willing to be tested.
I suppose that's true. Have you ever seen a lynchproof scum before?
If he is town then we waste a way to force mafia to kill how we want
How so?
-->
@Vader
If you had to lick a pineapple or bite a tomato, how many times would you probe it before you cried?
-->
@SirAnonymous
1) yes , multiple times
2) if he's town , mafia will not kill him. They will force a mislynch
-->
@Mikal
25
-->
@Vader
I reported you to the mobs for being a homo
If I click the flag and type homo alert does that get sent to them?
-->
@Mikal
Idk if you know, but Pie was also bitching about town not pressuring Lunatic as lynchproof at the time. I'm torn with Pie as well because he could easily do that to tell town "I told you so,' but Danielle could have intentionally given him that role because Greyparrot thinks his role was direct
-->
@Mikal
1) yes , multiple times
Ok. I guess I just haven't played enough games to see one yet.
2) if he's town , mafia will not kill him. They will force a mislynch
I think I understand what you're getting at here.
-->
@SirAnonymous
To clarify , for mafia to kill him (if he's town) they would have to actively choose to waste a nk. One to break his deathproof. Would be a lot easier to force a mislynch
I'm assuming dp is some 1x roll. It's fucking retard mode if that is perma.
I don't buy he is big brain , he likes trump. He's like a borderline neanderthal.
bruh