I do not scum read you for that. I do think you embraced it on the towns behalf too readily. But my main thought is lynching you informs us far more.
You, like Mikal, are dis-regarding that there could be balanced reasons for the mod confirmation like me being a power role. Or the fact that innocent townie is already a common enough role that doesn't get discounted as OP. It also is likely danielle didn't think people would pick up on the riddle so fast. "informs us far more" not really. You learn that the mod wasn't lying, which should have been pretty obvious already, and now you are down a mislynch, something that mikal seems to think is a big deal seeing as his whole case for not testing pie relies on not having enough mislynches to win the game lol.
I agree with him on testing Pie in the sense that if we lynch Pie and he doesn't die, people will still be suspicious, which accomplishes nothing. We then spend the next DP arguing about what it does and doesn't mean. I don't agree with him that you wanting to lynch pie is scummy. My instinct was to lynch him too and I am still not sure I agree that him not dying doesn't confirm his affiliation or even tilt the read. But if the majority of players do not agree on that point then how does it help the team in hunting scum. It is not worth arguing about a thing like that for multiple DPs.
Mikal himself is the one who pointed out that a cop could very easily solve the dilemma to the point where this isn't an issue dp2. But the cop investigation only works if we lynch him first, considering how I pointed out how many different post lynch affiliation changing roles there are. Chances are much better that this isn't an issue dp2 by testing him today. Not testing him today, means this will 100% be still an on going issue going into next day phase.
My read of your typical play is that you as town would be more inclined to see the "town confirmed" riddle and react something like: "interesting, weird the mod would do that. I am town but that doesn't mean any of your should believe it necessarily."
Where have I ever been town confirmed in the past and said anything like that? I don't think you can substantiate that I would have ever said something like what you suggest you think I would say. I think my response was perfectly normal in light of the fact I know I am actually town.
I do not agree you are 100% confirmed town and certainly do not agree scum would kill you. I hate when people make NK predictions like that. We are almost always wrong because 1) we don't know who scum is, 2) we don't know the dyamics between the scum team, and 3) we don't know how their roles or knowledge are influencing their game
It definitely paints a target on me, danielle's post. Though as I've pointed out, I think the FOS from you and mike actually helps my longevity, and considering it isn't particularly convincing, I don't see enough people getting on board with your logic to actually lynch me. I think your logic is doing me a favor if anything. That said, I do think you need to pull your head out of your butt enough to see that lynching pie is the right move here considering all the potential roles he could be. Lynching him also makes cop results more reliable, so there is almost no reason not to test him today.
