Exactly, so why would you think this "sacred cow of information" wouldn't come out until after a flip in dp2? Also assuming you would use this logic to lynch someone, as you are implying we should have before supa "fvcked it up" then it would have been obvious at the point said person was lynched...
Because scum knowing would require one flip and a townie to reveal it or two flips. And you wouldn't use the logic to lynch someone because this whole scenario assumes the theme wasn't revealed yet lol
Cuz you just got done trying to make the point that he was dumb for not getting it, manipulating him into outting his guess of the theme. What did you expect from him? Also it wasn't his character that drove that conclusion, oro asked if he had a moment of recognition and you rold him to look up the character remember? Why do that if you thought not knowing the theme would help you get a lynch?
I never said Supa was dumb bruh. And I told him to look up the character to see if he had a moment of recognition, you know, like a townie would do? Instead of just lynching someone without investigating? I had to look up Ray Arnold to know he was SLJ so why would I not give Supa that same benefit of the doubt?
So... you made him seem like an idiot for not having information that everyone else also didn't have? Also this is a bold faced lie, because you told him to look up the character. Why do that then immediately shame him for doing it and putting two and two together?
Bruh what lie. I said "I dropped it because he didn't research his character." The fact that I had to TELL him to research his character means that he didn't research it in the first place, so where is the lie lol. I didn't shame him for researching, I shamed him for blatantly saying it out loud bruh.
You still maintain that we could have used this information to catch scum on. Supa didn't know the theme until it was handfisted down his throat, so naturally that should make him look suspicious to you under the philosophy that mafia not knowing the theme = suspicious, but you never mentioned it again. Yet you still defend to me your original idea that it is scummy for someone not to know the theme.
It's scummy if they looked at their character. Supa literally didn't know who acted Ray Arnold, am I supposed to just call him media illiterate?
This shows hypocrisy in the idea that the theme wouldn't have been revealed until dp2.
I already said it would take town revealing the claim for that to happen.
Maybe you did put two and two together. Or maybe it was inside info, hard to know exactly. Current theory is scum team is you and oro, or smaller chance of it being oro/cookie, but I need oro to answer my question first.
How is it hard to know? Oro is the most socially knowledgeable out of everyone here, of course he's gonna instantly put two and two together. You're literally the one saying town shouldn't be lazy and then when we're not, it's scummy? Bruh
