My justification is pretty weak. I don't think we should lynch Croc solely on his flawed justification (if he manages to show up and say it)
Civil War Generals Mafia DP1
Posts
Total:
767
-->
@Speedrace
With Croc being as noncontributing as he is I doubt he would be Mafia killed until near the endgame... Frankly, I would rather not be stuck in a ELO situation with Croc as one of my only allies.
Approximately 8 hours remaining
-->
@MisterChris
Eh, they still have to kill him at some point
-->
@Greyparrot
There is a high chance of him making it to an ELO situation regardless.
-->
@MisterChris
With Croc being as noncontributing as he is I doubt he would be Mafia killed until near the endgame... Frankly, I would rather not be stuck in a ELO situation with Croc as one of my only allies.
That's very true.
I'm probably going to be gone for most of the day, so i'll vote croc in case I don't get back on. Speed hasn't made a case for why Croc is town that I find convincing, other than mod psyche guessing; doesn't answer the problem that supa pointed out if he is a role cop or just a weak mafia role. He is downplaying the usefulness of mafia learning what roles are in the game with that role.
vtl croc
vtl croc*
Pro Croc lynch:
Supa
Lunatic
MisterChris
TNB
SirAnon
Anti Croc lynch:
Speedrace
Both?:
Bearman
Neither:
Croc (its about him, duh)
No say:
Oro
Mharman
Greyparrot
That1User
I'm having the feeling Speedrace is also mafia.....
Not sure about Bearman though.
VTL CROC
-->
@Mharman
@oromagi
@That1User
@Crocodile
@BearMan
Pro Croc lynch:
Supa
Lunatic
MisterChris
TNB
SirAnon
Greyparrot
Anti Croc lynch:
Speedrace
Both?:
Bearman
Neither:
Croc (its about him, duh)
No say:
Oro
Mharman
That1User
I'm having the feeling Speedrace is also mafia.....
Not sure about Bearman though.
-->
@Lunatic
@Vader
@Speedrace
@MisterChris
@SirAnonymous
look above
-->
@TNBinc
That about sums it up
-->
@MisterChris
From my point of view, croc and speedrace are scum.
On bearman, i'm not sure if he is town or scum.
-->
@TNBinc
Speed defending Croc isn't really a huge tell, I wouldn't jump to the conclusion that he's scum if Croc is. Still, if Croc turns out to be scum (which is pretty likely imo) that at least warrants some suspicion and would be worth investigating.
As for Bear, he's been pretty mute on many issues thus far. Not sure we can categorize him one way or the other yet
Vote Count:
Croc (6/7) - Supa, MisterChris, BearMan, TNB, Lunatic, GP
Oromagi (1/7) - SA
Please let me know if I’ve made a mistake!
Nani??
well i hope town wins i guess.
peace out
-->
@Vader
@SirAnonymous
@Crocodile
WHAT? You just admit you are scum??????????
-->
@TNBinc
No he never admitted to being scum at all
-->
@Vader
Oh wait
nvm
Man that was close.
i just thought he did.
What if he did???????
Idk.
-->
@BearMan
Ok guys. I got caught up on the DP. I had some really weird thoughts today, and I was thinking about them (actually not lying)
What really weird thoughts were you thinking about?
VTL Bearman
Vote Count:
Croc (6/7) - Supa, MisterChris, BearMan, TNB, Lunatic, GP
Oromagi (1/7) - SA
BearMan (1/7) - That1
Please let me know if I’ve made a mistake!
-->
@TNBinc
On bearman, i'm not sure if he is town or scum.
I find it weird that no one is questioning him, he just says he's been thinking weird thoughts and everyone just let's him go then remains vague af
Neutral on Croc so I'm not voting on him Idk how we got to this point again
His role is so obscure/niche it could be either
Sad he's not defending himself tho wish he did
-->
@That1User
I agree
-->
@Crocodile
Why are you accepting defeat like this this is sad
-->
@Speedrace
I agree
Hope town makes the right decision
-->
@That1User
Existential Crisis
-->
@That1User
Why are you accepting defeat like this this is sad
This sort of solidifies my position to me.