Complete list of reads with explanation:
Lunatic- Scum read
He has not really done much to generate discussion so far outside of trying to bus me in the last page after he has faced intense pressure. If anything, all he has done is criticize others methods to generate discussion (coal trying to get people to role claim, zaradi, etc.). He objects to the method of VTLing someone to pressure them in to producing content, except when he did it to Dani 30-40 minutes in to the game starting on the first page. After Dani suggests pressuring him or Ragnar, he doesn't seem to like the idea of pressuring people with a VTL without a thorough explanation, which once again, he did not provide when he pressured Dani. The vast majority of his efforts so far seem less aimed at producing content than frustrating the efforts of the primary people who have been trying to produce content (coal/zaradi). I don't really remember TUF's play style though I have played live with him a few times, but he seems to generate a lot of infighting. Not really pro town.
Ragnar- Slight scum read
Mostly flied under the radar yesterday with no meaningful contribution. Seemed to post just enough to be active but not enough to say anything that would generate suspicion or contribute substantially to the game.
Danielle- Neutral for now
Think I've explained this enough above. Her initial actions were anti town (inactivity and proposing a DP1 no lynch) but there is an innocent explanation for both that I accept for the time being.
Sui- Town. He hasn't really offered any strong takes yet but seems interested in collecting information that will be useful later on as well as trying to read meaning in to other people's post to figure out if they are scum or not. He's posted his reads twice but hasn't offered any sort of explanation for them as far as I can see, or if he has its only been a few words. More detailed reads would be nice
coal- Town. He is probably the person I've played mafia with the most in here and his actions seem consistent with his town meta. I think he is equally active when he is town and scum, but rather than driving the narrative when he is scum, he tries to derail it if it would lead somewhere useful. Haven't really seen him do that yet. I don't like that he said he was considering not checking his role PM but I know he's done it in other games where he is town so I suppose it gets a pass.
Zaradi- Town. The other aggressive/active person so far. I agree with TUF that his initial reasoning for scum reading him was sketchy, but I think what TUF has done to defend himself since has been more revealing than anything else, and it seems like based on Zaradi's other behavior, this was likely his intent anyways (to get TUF talking more to get a better read on him), so I don't think he is trying to pressure TUF for sketchy reasons. He pressured TUF and what has been revealed is fairly illuminating so far
Airmax- Neutral. Not really scum reading or town reading him due to inactivity but I'd still gladly lynch him unless we have a strong scum read by tomorrow night or friday morning, just because inactivity is anti town
oromagi- Town. Based on his interactions so far I'd say town, but he kind of flew under the radar a lot of yesterday. Random voting/VTLing based on activity early on drew some suspicion towards him but it seemed like an earnest mistake. Hopefully he gives a list of reads with explanations soon.
In my defense:
1) I have never played forum mafia so what YY has said about certain mistakes being made due to inexperience is correct
2) I have repeated multiple times why up until now I did not give complete reads with an explanation (was busy last night and this morning)
3) I haven't given very bold accusations yet (outside of the Dani push after people had already accepted her explanation) but neither has oromagi or sui but TUF is not scum reading them yet. Seems like a defensive move but I am not going to go so far as to say that his accusation is total deflection, because there were valid reasons to pressure me up to this point since I was inactive last night.