-->
@warren42
Why do you think Pie is scum? I honestly can't tell whether Pie or Bullish is scum (or both), so I'm good with lynching either of them.
Captain America: Civil War Mafia - DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
1,166
-->
@warren42
Maybe, but I'm bad at reads, so I don't trust my scumreads. Unless I have a really good reason to suspect someone, lynching an inactive is my backup plan.I don't care about your current read, I care about that logic which makes no sense to me.Shouldn't someone who has not at all posted be the truest "null" there is?
-->
@SirAnonymous
I'm ok with bullish being lynched but Pie's catch up felt fake, as though he knew what was going on but was going through the motions (aka mafia chat brought him up to speed beforehand) and his claim was hot garbage
-->
@ILikePie5
What's your role justification? I have no idea how rhodey would be a rolecop
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
I didn't attempt to keep trying because I was new to playing mafia and commanding and gave up
UVC
ILikePie5 - drafterman, warren
Bullish - Discipulus_Didicit, Singularity, GreyParrot
WaterPhoenix - WaterPhoenix
warren42 - Lunatic, oromagi, SirAnonymous
VTNL - Ragnar,
Not Voting: warren42, ILikePie5, SupaDudz
Wasn't really a fair lynch tbh
Whoops. Forgot to update mine.
UVC
ILikePie5 - drafterman, warren
Bullish - Discipulus_Didicit, Singularity, GreyParrot, SirAnonymous
WaterPhoenix - WaterPhoenix
warren42 - Lunatic, oromagi,
VTNL - Ragnar,
Not Voting: warren42, ILikePie5, SupaDudz
You have me as both voting for pie and not voting. It's the former.
-->
@ILikePie5
@warren42
I have no idea how rhodey would be a rolecop
Now that's an interesting question. I'd be very curious to hear the answer.
And I forgot to update the not voting players.
UVC
ILikePie5 - drafterman, warren
Bullish - Discipulus_Didicit, Singularity, GreyParrot, SirAnonymous
WaterPhoenix - WaterPhoenix
warren42 - Lunatic, oromagi,
VTNL - Ragnar,
Not Voting: ILikePie5, SupaDudz
Disc reads feel manufactured perfectly, and I don't buy the Bullish scum thing. I am way more down to lynch Pie
VTL PIE
VTL PIE
UVC
ILikePie5 (3/7) - drafterman, warren, Supadudz
Bullish (4/7) - Discipulus_Didicit, Singularity, GreyParrot, SirAnonymous
WaterPhoenix (1/7) - WaterPhoenix
warren42 (2/7) - Lunatic, oromagi,
VTNL (1/7) - Ragnar,
Not Voting: ILikePie5,
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
In my experience even on DP 1 going with your gut and lynching early is generally a good thing for much the same reasons that bullish is saying now.
How do you reconcile agreeing with my position after you've made this statement against me: https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/3593/post_links/153154
"Notice also how post 61 advocates for the DP to be as short as possible. Again, unlikely to come from someone known as a decent town player."
-->
@SirAnonymous
It's because he's mafia and doesn't have one cause it's a fake claim
-->
@Greyparrot
@Discipulus_Didicit
@Singularity
Warren brought up the point of what justification Pie could have for Rhodey being a role cop. What do y'all think of this?
-->
@Bullish
Did you claim yet? My gut tells me pie is town. My scum list is narrowing and you are on it. If you are town I would appreciate you making that known so we can catch scum before time expires
-->
@SirAnonymous
I honestly think speed most likely half assed the justifications and I am not putting g much stock in those sort of connections
-->
@Bullish
@Singularity
He hasn't claimed, although it would probably be a good idea given the pressure on him.
-->
@drafterman
@Vader
Who is on your non town list other than pie, I think my scum pool and everyone else's should be pretty small at this point. It should be easy to decide on a lynch. I can tell you I have pie in the town pile for now, u less you have inside information which you did hint at earlier. (I THINK)
-->
@Singularity
I think we have enough people to lynch either Pie or Bullish. It's just that half of us prefer one lynch and the other half prefer the other.
-->
@SirAnonymous
I think we have enough people to lynch either Pie or Bullish. It's just that half of us prefer one lynch and the other half prefer the other.
I have a pretty strong town read on everyone on both wagons despite the fact that scum has had plenty of time to get on either train. Maybe they are both mafiosos? I still prefer bullish but will switch to pie if needed.
-->
@Bullish
@ILikePie5
Y'all should vote for each other to speed this up.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
+1
-->
@Speedrace
Singularity/SirAnonymous/BrotherDThomas: (looking up from her laptop) I told him mods know who I. Who is mods zis veek? Who is Speedrrrace? Vlad? Oh, Vlad. Zat is good. Vlad! please vould you please (pause for vodka) be Speed und plus one zat asshole (pause for vodka) so he goes avay good?
Speedrace/Ragnar/Trent0405: I'm rrreading Biden emails just now.
Singularity/SirAnonymous/BrotherDThomas: Spasibo, Vladdie, darrrling"
Speedrace/Ragnar/Trent0405: Fuck zat orowutzit guy!
Singularity/SirAnonymous/BrotherDThomas: Fuck zat guy. Get another thousand rrrubles out of 'is devit kount, qvik.
-->
@oromagi
YOUR QUOTE: "Singularity/SirAnonymous/BrotherDThomas: (looking up from her laptop) I told him mods know who I."
Oromagi,
I...don't want to be banned for impersonating, so I'll stop right here.
Vote Count
ILikePie5 - drafterman, warren42, SupaDudz
Bullish - Discipulus_Didicit, Singularity, GreyParrot, SirAnonymous
WaterPhoenix - WaterPhoenix
warren42 - Lunatic, oromagi
VTNL - Ragnar
Not Voting: ILikePie5
-->
@Vader
@warren42
@SirAnonymous
What's your role justification? I have no idea how rhodey would be a rolecop
I wrote the justification earlier. All it says is I’m in the military and Speed wanted to hit the hay.
Regardless, I’m literally the only investigative role on town side. Not to mention the only town power role so far at that. There’s no reason why I should be lynched
-->
@SirAnonymous
We do not speak of that fraud BDT
-->
@oromagi
Lol yes Singularity is 100% BrotherDThomas
Comparing SA and BDT is kinda insulting tho