South Park Mafia DP3

JARGOM, I believed very strongly that Supa was town, and you said if he flipped town, I must be scum trying to get town credit

Its because you didnt have a strong reason to town read supa. And drafter had even less of a reason to town read toaster. The logic of townreading someone you know will flip town to use as town cred is literally what led me to bugging Warren correctly in virts game. He claimes he knew GP was town and there was literally nothing GP said that should make anyone know he was town in that game.

Well it wasn't that Supa had something townish, it was that he hadn't done anything I saw as scummy. Everything he was accused of sounded like typical Supa to be, and I was right

The problem with that logic is that supa acts like typical supa whether town or scum. I was even giving supa that pass in DP1 of the office mafia. He was scum there. The safest option seems to be, if it walks and talks like a duck, treat it like a duck.

I say VTL Press, Water, or Singularity. Don't forget Singularity hid his experience levels, the same thing SA was correctly lynched for

SA didn't hide any experience though, SA was legit a noob. He was initially pressured because he seemed smarter than your average noob, but still character claimed after one vote (which was a noob thing to do, but since he was being treated an experienced player, was pressured for it anyway). And regardless of his affiliation, any which way you wanna analyze that wagon, most of the people behind it were on it for pretty sheepish reasons. Only arimax and wylted I think truly saw him as scummy, the rest of the wagon was just lazy.

I have never ever ever suggested lynching inactive over scum. Period. If you can find a single instance of my suggesting that, I will VTL myself.

You literally fucking said lynch all inactives, I just pulled the qoute from christmas on DP3 of JARGOM. Lynching inactive over scum is irrelevant, since you said it was obvious he was town, and were defending his inactivity before he was even active, despite stating inactive mafia will rule in the face of an active town. Your attempt to spin what you said there is laughable.

This is a common refrain. An active town will eat itself in the presence of inactive scum. Inactives should always be pressured. The fault lies in Supas complete and utter overreaction as well as the veterans (myself included) that allowed ourselves to get distracted by it. I remember thinking Supa was town, but ultimately just got fed up with his behavior and actually forgot about my town read.

Lynch all inactives.

What's the case against toaster again?

But Supa eventually did a gambit, which revealed him. No such gambit as town. That's the difference

So supa is gonna try a gambit every single time he is scum is the logic here?

And I meant that SA was lynched for acting dumber than he was

We get it. Youre mad I was so much better than you in the office. Even though you’re scum can you at least play this game instead of wallowing in your past poor performances?

Lol I was lowkey expecting you would say something like that. Not once did I bring up your failed hammers in Virt's endgame or JARGOM's endgame, but your right, you are the mafia god, and I am utterly horrible, with your basis being only the office lmao. Your beating me 2-1 on endgame fuck ups.

Then you aren’t paying attention

4 posts DP1. 

No, but Supa will eventually do something he wouldn't as town. You can't lynch him for his own town behavior

And that's your opinion I suppose, but doesn't change the fact that Singularity is suspicious

Singularity is definitely a he lol

I very much doubt that, based on this thread: