drafterman's QuickFire Series 1 (QFS1)

#91

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:39AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:39AM

-->

@ILikePie5

@Zaradi

Popcorning makes that a lot more difficult for the scum to do, though. The odds that they would be picked last are only 1/6.

#92

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:39AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:39AM

-->

@Zaradi

Are we still talking about a potential protective role outting themselves or you and Speed's role PMs? My rejection of people getting town confirmed was addressed to the former.

I’m referring to Speed’s and my role PMs. The former, I agree still has a slight suspicion

#93

Zaradi

Debates: 4

Posts: 705

2

3

7

Zaradi

11.20.2019 02:41AM

2

3

7

11.20.2019 02:41AM

-->

@Lunatic

You're still not getting it xD it's not like someone who's needing to fake-claim is going to be sitting there until it's his turn to go, then starts researching a fake-claim. While we're dragging claims out of everyone else they're going to be researching what else would be a good fit so that there isn't any delay.

#94

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:42AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:42AM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Popcorning makes that a lot more difficult for the scum to do, though. The odds that they would be picked last are only 1/6.

The last person still would be FOS. Plus considering time constraints like school for me, I won’t have time to claim till the very end.

#95

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:46AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:46AM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Popcorning makes that a lot more difficult for the scum to do, though. The odds that they would be picked last are only 1/6.

<br>

You’re not factoring that even if scum is chosen I’m the middle that their fake claim saves their ass. Otherwise it’s like a normal mass claim, the last person is inherently FOS for the rest of the game

#96

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:46AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:46AM

-->

@ILikePie5

The last person still would be FOS.

Agreed, but a mass claim will make POE much easier. It could make it possible to town confirm players. If the scum claims in the middle of the popcorn, it could get him lynched.

#97

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:48AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:48AM

-->

@ILikePie5

You’re not factoring that even if scum is chosen I’m the middle that their fake claim saves their ***.

a mass claim will make POE much easier. It could make it possible to town confirm players. If the scum claims in the middle of the popcorn, it could get him lynched.

#98

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:48AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:48AM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Agreed, but a mass claim will make POE much easier. It could make it possible to town confirm players.

Not necessarily

If the scum claims in the middle of the popcorn, it could get him lynched.

He’d have the time to fake claim just like at the end. Either way the last person would be FOS

#99

Speedrace

Debates: 63

Posts: 6,283

4

9

11

Speedrace

11.20.2019 02:49AM

4

9

11

11.20.2019 02:49AM

-->

@Lunatic

@ILikePie5

@Zaradi

Disc told me that roles were picked randomly, so my PM is pretty much irrelevant

I'm a Coroner, so I can see someone's true role and affiliation after they die, even if it was altered. I thought this meant there was a role alterer, but random roles means there isn't necessarily one. However, I would advise EVERYONE to put their role and affiliation and what not into their will, just in case there is an alterer

I love the popcorn idea, so I'm popcorning Zaradi

Also, the third party should align themselves with town if possible

#100

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:50AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:50AM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Agreed, but a mass claim will make POE much easier. It could make it possible to town confirm players. If the scum claims in the middle of the popcorn, it could get him lynched.

Have you considered the alternative I’ve put forth. Make Speed claim cause he knows the role of another person? That inherently should confirm him and the secondary player cause the options are TP, Town, or Town Town

#101

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:50AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:50AM

-->

@ILikePie5

Not necessarily

No, not necessarily, but it is likely.

He’d have the time to fake claim just like at the end.

Time isn't the question. The question is whether or not the scum can be CC'ed.

Either way the last person would be FOS

Sort of, but it would be a different dynamic because they weren't last deliberately.

#102

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:51AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:51AM

-->

@Speedrace

Disc told me that roles were picked randomly, so my PM is pretty much irrelevant

I'm a Coroner, so I can see someone's true role and affiliation after they die, even if it was altered. I thought this meant there was a role alterer, but random roles means there isn't necessarily one. However, I would advise EVERYONE to put their role and affiliation and what not into their will, just in case there is an alterer

So your claim of knowing the role and name of that person was incorrect?

#103

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:52AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:52AM

I love the popcorn idea, so I'm popcorning Zaradi

I guess that ends the debate, since a majority is for the mass claim. For better or worse, here we go.

#104

Speedrace

Debates: 63

Posts: 6,283

4

9

11

Speedrace

11.20.2019 02:53AM

4

9

11

11.20.2019 02:53AM

-->

@ILikePie5

Well it's likely wrong. Also, I never claimed to know anyone's name, just a role that was in the game

#105

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:53AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:53AM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Sort of, but it would be a different dynamic because they weren't last deliberately.

You’re gambling which is debatably a good idea. Personally I’m anti-gambling, whether it be bets over who wins matches or something else. You’re hoping that the person CCs, but if it doesn’t happen then e’re back at square one with mafia knowing all the roles

#106

PressF4Respect

Debates: 10

Posts: 3,159

3

8

11

PressF4Respect

11.20.2019 02:54AM

3

8

11

11.20.2019 02:54AM

I’m a redirecter

I can visit someone each night and if they visit someone else, I can force them to visit the target of my choosing.

I’m town

#107

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:54AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:54AM

-->

@PressF4Respect

You were supposed to wait for it to be your turn with the popcorn! Blabbing out your role early ruins the point.

#108

PressF4Respect

Debates: 10

Posts: 3,159

3

8

11

PressF4Respect

11.20.2019 02:55AM

3

8

11

11.20.2019 02:55AM

-->

@Speedrace

Ok Speed what’s your claim?

#109

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:55AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:55AM

-->

@ILikePie5

but if it doesn’t happen then e’re back at square one with mafia knowing all the roles

Except that we know all the roles and have a high chance of town-confirming people.

#110

PressF4Respect

Debates: 10

Posts: 3,159

3

8

11

PressF4Respect

11.20.2019 02:56AM

3

8

11

11.20.2019 02:56AM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Popcorning is stupid

Someone is inherently going to be called last, and they’re gonna be the lynch target.

#111

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 16,132

3

7

10

ILikePie5

11.20.2019 02:56AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:56AM

-->

@Speedrace

Well it's likely wrong. Also, I never claimed to know anyone's name, just a role that was in the game

This is what you said:

I'm not gonna reveal what the role is JUST YET so that person isn't exposed but yeah

So you know a role. Only one person has that role. Therefore that person can be pretty much confirmed.

#112

SirAnonymous

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

SirAnonymous

11.20.2019 02:57AM

3

7

10

11.20.2019 02:57AM

-->

@ILikePie5

You’re gambling which is debatably a good idea. Personally I’m anti-gambling, whether it be bets over who wins matches or something else.

I'm opposed to gambling money as well. However, I am very aware of the value of gambling in a game. It works very well in pitch, but not so well in chess.

#113

PressF4Respect

Debates: 10

Posts: 3,159

3

8

11

PressF4Respect

11.20.2019 02:57AM

3

8

11