And Supa...
Pokemon Mafia D2
Posts
Total:
652
-->
@Mharman
Why is it even possible that both Disc and I are on the scum team? That’d be way too hard of a bus to even be possible
This crosses me as some sort of weird gloat. It wouldn't even be a bus, just creating separation and disc wanting g to be in the majority.
-->
@bsh1
I did not soft claim anywhere. Eevee is the Universal Backup because it can evolve into many different Pokémon, similar to how a Universal Backup can take on many different roles.
I think speed was activity prompted given what he posted, which makes me think he is scum, because me and bsh1 were clearly not activity prompted
-->
@Mharman
Is that a safe claim from the mod?
-->
@Mharman
Is ever a fire water earth or air pokemon or however they fucking classify them
-->
@Club
What am I supposed to say? Bananas?
Read my post. I said "Is it this thing or is it this other thing?"
You said "yes" lmao.
It's like if someone asked "was Abraham Lincoln or Andrew Jackson our 16th president?" And someone else says "yes".
Then you act like I'm the one spouting nonsense hahaha.
You are hilarious. I think I'll lynch your scum buddies first and save you for last, I like having some comic relief around.
-->
@Wylted
I will post a thread about the relation between DP length and Lynch accuracy after this game is over.
-->
@Greyparrot
Not a safe claim. Real role. The claim would be easy to sniff out as bullshit if he was forced to prove his role
-->
@Wylted
Longer DPs do not benefit town, though they should not be rushed
I don't recall FT ever saying that, and I wouldn't put it past you to have just made all that up. But your remark here seems a bit contradictory and to miss the point. Ultimately, we agree that DPs should never be rushed, and when they aren't rushed, they're longer. My lynch last game is a case-in-point for why rushing is a bad idea.
-->
@bsh1
Because there was no NK and no town is stepping up..so either town is going to repeat the action (which is fine) or scum is a poisoner.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
Disc, can you list all of your reads from most town to most scummy and everything in between please?
-->
@Greyparrot
Why does the lack of an NK have anything to do with it? Why does town not stepping up lead you to conclude that the poisoner is scum?
-->
@Mharman
So the justification is fine, but it is not reassuring to me that you didn't breadcrumb your claim somewhere.
-->
@bsh1
My issue is I think it sometimes allows obvious scum to vullshit their way out of a lynch. Particularly when most of town has 2 digit IQs. When the average is 3 digits in length I can tolerate longer DPs
-->
@bsh1
On the one hand, I agree. On the other, not everyone is refreshing the page constantly. It's not like people were piling on him not to VTNL. So, a simply lack of situational awareness could explain his hammer. I don't really see it as suspicious.
He confesses in this DP that his VTNL hammer was intentional.
Sorry if I am saying anything that has already been said, just responding as I catch up.
-->
@Wylted
I think speed was activity prompted given what he posted, which makes me think he is scum, because me and bsh1 were clearly not activity prompted
This.
I am actually okay doing g a utility lynch on club, since he is unpredictable and may kill as many town members as mafia
-->
@Speedrace
I'd like a response from you to Wylted's query.
-->
@Wylted
Probably a safe move given poisoner could very well be scum.
-->
@Wylted
Disc, can you list all of your reads from most town to most scummy and everything in between please?
Grey and the new kid whose name starts with P are obviously town. Mharm and club are suspects. Null on everyone else until I have time to properly catch up (I get off work in 9 hours, currently on my first break).
-->
@Wylted
Clearly you have nowhere near the knowledge of the theme that I have.
There are currently 18 types of Pokémon:
Steel
Rock
Ground
Water
Electric
Grass
Fire
Flying
Normal
Fighting
Psychic
Ghost
Dark
Fairy
Bug
Dragon
Ice
Poison
-->
@Greyparrot
Okay, seriously dude is unpredictable and equally as deadly as legitimate scum. Look at disc closely after this dp1 please, others in my scum pool are mharman, pie and speed racer. You and bsh1 cross me as town.
VTL Club
-->
@Wylted
I find that it's harder for scum to bs their way out of a lynch when they are under pressure for longer. They tend to crack. Rushed lynches on easy targets, however, play right into mafia's hands.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
Let's lynch club. He is unpredictable and uncontrollable. He also has terrible reads. I believe he is town, but a good utility lynch
I am not debating theory with you now. I think we are both right anyway, as far as the strengths of each method
-->
@Mharman
I think Disc is scum because he and Grey came up with the VTNL idea, a stupid idea which I fell for.
Grey and I came up with a good idea, it was club and you hammering that was the stupid idea.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
Why is Phione obvious town?
-->
@Wylted
Let's lynch club. He is unpredictable and uncontrollable. He also has terrible reads. I believe he is town, but a good utility lynch
Okay sure. I am pretty sure my vote is already on him but just to be sure...
UNVOTE VTL CLUB
The scummy thing about mharman is that he went along with a supposedly scummy ideal. Just lynch him or club in whatever order you feel like. To avoid an extra town death I prefer club first anyway