-->
@ILikePie5
No, not story time
Diary Mafia DP4
Posts
Hot
Read-only
Total:
502
-->
@ILikePie5
he called me the crab god...gave me an essay about everything evolving into crabs and wondered if there was a spiritual connection, as though the ultimate form is a crab
-->
@Mharman
60% chance? You can do yourself one better by saying Greyparrot is clear. He was targeted by a bioengineer who hasn’t fessed up. It’s probably a scummy role. Meaning Greyparrot was targeted by scum.
It’s possible he’s scum and just lying about the Bio Engineer
-->
@ILikePie5
lol, i'm not lying. I rarely ever lie in these games.
-->
@Greyparrot
@Barney
@whiteflame
@AustinL0926
Posts 56 and 58
I was guessing scum would try to kill town confirmed people.
-->
@Lunatic
@ILikePie5
@Savant
Post 56
-->
@Lunatic
Any reason why you chose to leave out “Bible” as a part of your character claim?
-->
@Mharman
I already answered
-->
@Mharman
The only reason why I’m even including Austin here is because legendary =/= town confirmation.
There’s no guarantee either that he’s relying on inside knowledge and using it as the definition of Legend.
-->
@Mharman
If you consider GP town then the odds rise to 75% with
Austin
Lunatic
Barney
Whiteflame
In this scenario, I frankly don’t see how WF is town. Austin has something going for him. Lunatic does as well. Barney would come after WF for me.
-->
@ILikePie5
Austin has something going for him. Lunatic does as well.
Fair. I expect at least one of them to be town, so it's Barney or WF.
Probably both actually.
Character Role DAY1 DAY2 DAY3
Austin people try to gain status and money... Legendary N/A NP2 (activated power) N/A <<< Is town.
Pie Hylics pneumatics and psychics Spiritualist(talks to Casey) Had role PM Chatroom Chatroom <<< I strongly believe they are town, even with a role that overlaps with mine (so if I die, know that I am specifically disagreeing with the the obvious theory scum would bring up)
Whiteflame Victim Complex Absorber (steals powers used to reuse the next night) N/A N/A N/A <<< I am not 100%, but I may have talked to Wylted about people weaponizing victimhood before; so thematically it makes sense. Mechanically, with him having been hit by nothing (unless there's an update I overlooked), I find it slightly sus.
Lunatic The 120 year life cap Apportioner [sic] (weak doctor) Pie(blocked) Pie Pie <<< Excellent use of this tactic from Black Adder: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rblfKREj50o
Savant Israel's suspicious activity during 9-11 Crisis Actor NP1 Faked Death NP2 left hiding N/A <<< It would be a bastard mod move to let scum fake their death, so I flipped a coin between him and Austin for whom to target last night.
Barney Christianity's views on life extension Neighborizer Action failed (Pie) Action failed (Pie) Action failed (Savant) <<< Did use the word "cool" in a sentence, which only scum ever do (DP3 #88).
Greyparrot carcinization Crab God (Moves side to side) / Bio-Engineer Role stolen by Bio Engineer. N/A N/A <<< Honestly, I think he's pretending to eat paint chips avoid being NKed. But it could be a WIFOM tactic of acting like he's just pretending 🤣 ... That said, there were some suspect interactions between him and JoeBob (like him thinking JoeBob is town even after Banana's death).
Mharman Non religious actually missed it, but it gets data on two people ??? Barney/Lunatic ??? ??? <<<Seems to confirm that someone RBed me, but I am not sure Lunatic directly connects to that as opposed to just a misleading sentence structure from Wylted while moving on to give whatever hints about Lunatic. ... Which posts had the other results?
🪦🪦🪦 Character Role DAY1 DAY2 DAY3
Earth Can't live without doing evil Removed Lynched DP1 (guilty).
Casey activism is easy activist (restarts DP) Town Killed NP1 <<< In active communication with Pie
Vader are incels right Blackpilled (vig) Savant(success) Suicide Bombed by Banana DP2
Joebob Frozen Jesus Rolecop/role hijack coped(???) coped(???) Lynched / hijacked(???)
I'm sure I'm missing a bit, but I have to help a friend with some BS legal drama (I'm not spending my whole life on it anymore, but it's not quite over yet).
Since scum had a rolecop, I really feel it'd be best if we all engage in full transparency.
Oh I did mention the whole brackets thing to Wylted, and he informed me that he accounted for the likelihood of people looking into that in the setup. Anyone can easily ask him the same thing for confirmation.
-->
@Barney
Can you answer Mharman’s questions plz
-->
@Mharman
I just realized that there is no reason why Barney would be roleblocked if he was scum. If we take Barney, GP, and Savant all out, we’re left exactly with Luna, WF, Austin
-->
@ILikePie5
Claimed roleblocks, but we do know one of them is confirmed thanks to my results. I also firmly believe my DP2 results weren’t interfered with, so it does seem like Lunatic did roleblock someone.
My theory on what crab god does is that it randomly roleblocks a teammate. I think when the scum team stole it from Greyparrot it backfired.
-->
@AustinL0926
Anybody home?
-->
@Mharman
If anyone here is still hiding something about their role, come clean now. I may have caught you.
I'm straight forward with my role and my actions. I don't know why it keeps failing (usually it's a role blocker, but there are other things which can cause an actin to fail). I don't think it's a side effect of Lunatic also targeting Pie, since their target thereof failed NP1; I suspect it's a limit on Lunatic not being able to join a neighborhood. But that doesn't explain why it failed when targeting Savant NP3.
In addendum, I have a question for everyone. What would you have predicted scum’s night actions would be, heading into NP3?
We don't know who they role copped, nor what remaining powers they have. But were I in their shoes, I most likely would have had the doctor target the most scum read from their team (thereby protecting them from a lynch), and kill Pie (he'd leading town right now). Since they didn't do that, your previous question is all the more important for us to know what could have gone wrong when one of us was controlled (I mean maybe they'd chance delaying that power; if so I believe it'd be held on to for the use I just outlined).
They have either two or three powers we don't know of (I mean, a goon or two is likely, but we can't bet the farm on that).
-->
@Lunatic
For NP1 were you informed your action failed or that you were roleblocked?
As I mentioned at this time last week, I do have a class I teach on Mondays. Catching up, will respond where appropriate.
-->
@Mharman
If anyone here is still hiding something about their role, come clean now. I may have caught you.
That would be news to me. I don't have anything to add.
In addendum, I have a question for everyone. What would you have predicted scum’s night actions would be, heading into NP3?
I had every reason to believe that you'd be dead. As the sole claimed informational role who, apparently, gets quite a bit of information from your targets, it seemed pretty obvious that you'd either be RB'd or killed, and the latter seemed more likely.
-->
@ILikePie5
He seems pretty frustrated with my character. He emphasizes multiple times how damaging this mentality is, both to the present and future of the Israelis in particular.
I'm pretty tired tonight and I haven't gotten much downtime, so I'm going to keep my time on here short. I'll be more available tomorrow so I'll address any follow-up questions then. Whatever information Mharman has as a result of his role, I'll have to wait to see it then as well.
-->
@Barney
What’s your justification and what is Wylted’s thoughts on Christianity’s compatability with radical life extension
Hi, had a school event, catching up now
First note is that no NK, only role that would explain that (other than maybe some crab god shenanigans, which I find unlikely - assuming it's real, scum has it, so idk why it would block their own NK) is either Luna being apportioner, or scum waiving an NK to try and confirm Luna.
Idk, seems risky to forfeit an entire NK to try and confirm one member, but the POE is tight and I could see a play like that happening.
The mechanically correct play here is to look for a scum lynch today - even if Luna is scum, that still makes two - and then see if Pie dies tonight, along with another townie.
If Pie dies and another NK dies, then Luna is mechanically confirmed.
If only Pie dies, then there are two options. Either Luna is scum and we lynch him, or he's being town framed by scum forfeiting a kill. Regardless, even in the latter possibility, that basically forces scum to lose an NK and have to deal with a tighter POE.
I think this should work? Generally I'm decent with mechanics and we had a similar plan with me being the roleblocker last game, and this feels similar in terms of it only being able to go right.
-->
@Mharman
If anyone here is still hiding something about their role, come clean now. I may have caught you.
Nothing to report here. BTW I would recommend holding your story for a bit longer if you caught a scum in order to potentially let scum out themselves by defending their teammate, but make sure to get it by the end of the day in case you're NKed.
-->
@Mharman
In addendum, I have a question for everyone. What would you have predicted scum’s night actions would be, heading into NP3?
Pie is the obvious NK target, especially since I presume his role of communicating with Casey is a constant thing and can't be roleblocked or interfered with. I think it's likely scum have some sort of roleblocker, though as far as I know, no one except Barney has claimed being roleblocked which is... kinda odd? Especially I feel if scum had a roleblocker they would have used it on Vader NP1, idk, just a thought. I presume that if they didn't have a roleblocker or interferer, you would be a higher priority target as an investigative role, while otherwise they would just use it on you.
No one else stands out as an obvious target by scum actions, maybe only Luna if he's telling the truth and is town.
-->
@AustinL0926
Why do you lie?