Inheritance Cycle Mafia DP1

We're talking about a role with a hostile effect that wipes people's abilities. It's not unreasonable to think it would belong to an "evil" character.

My point isn't that this specific aspect must make Lunatic scum. My point is that it doesn't make him Town and there's not much of a reason to townread him otherwise.

If it wasn’t obvious already, I do support a Cerulean lynch. I think was fishing for information and switched to looking at characters once he got pushed off that. I really do not like his logic about why he went for Post #7 at all. The fact that his character is apparently not main is a little sus. Given his behavior, I’m going to have to assume he was anticipating more people to have offbeat characters, or just did not want to get locked into fake claiming one. May also connect him to Whiteflame, who iirc made some point about offbeat characters being expected. Note: I am defining offbeat characters as characters not in the important characters list on the wiki.

I think Wylted and Earth are obvious town, more Earth than Wylted. 

Lunatic is slight town for me. I really don’t think there’s much of a case for him. I like how he’s asking questions about stuff (specifically his questioning of Wylted, even if I townread Wylted), and his general contributions elsewhere.

Casey is reasonably town; I’m not ready to say solid town yet. I like how she pointed out what Cerulean was doing, and I think she’s been generally helpful, love the vibes.

ADOL is null.

Austin is a conditional scumlean if we are wrong on Creulean. I don’t think he’s explaining his thoughts well enough on his a couple of his townreads. Bit of a vibe thing as well. Null otherwise.

My other top scumread is Whiteflame. The vibes on him are fine, but the defense of Cwruean is weird to me. I firmly disagree with a few of his points.

Why haven't you full claimed. I am very curious about what you are and if it might avoid being mislynched than ai don't know why you haven't done it

Oh I missed that from Lunatic. Maybe there’s a slight point there, but at any rate I can understand why he’d look for it then if he’s working with his theory, considering he openly thought about it long pretty quickly. Still always good to double check. I will say that I do think Wylted is obviously townie by behavior and I don’t really understand what Lunatic sees.

To me, he looks townie because he claimed with no pressure and it was because he was thinking there was negative utility to it. It looks like he’s avoiding his mistake from last game. I’m not sure that compulsive vanillize is sop, but I can see why he’d do it anyway.

Right. That.

I'm Oracle, but a very weak version of it, at least from my point of view. If I get nightkilled, the role of my last chosen target gets revealed. Not even the alignment, just the role.

By saying this out loud, I will never be nightkilled and the ability is therefore worthless.

Although to be fair, at this point, I was never going to be in a position to get nightkilled anyway.

That is a pretty weak version. With all the heat on you, I think an No has always been pretty unlikely anyway

What is your character

My focus this game has not been great so far. I don't believe him though. I am willing to vote him but wouldn't be terribly disappointed with a no lynch also

I got you ty

The one thing that gives me pause is he stated annoyance at me and adol being absent and it's something that scum shouldn't mind. Unless ADOL is the scum partner

I don't think pie would make ADOL scum. I just don't believe that all mods completely randomize roles and pie is one who I think would be about 80% randomized but tweaked to provide a good experience. And so if ADOL did roll scum he would just flip him to town IMO

I will be here last minute I can't speak the same of mharman

We have a decision to make and 45 minutes to make it. What do you guys want to do

If the game ends soon I will

I’ve been posting during the 3rd quarter. I’m watching this whole 4th one though 

I would prefer to lynch Cerulean.

I hate that this effects me, but I would feel stupid if he is scum and I let him make it to dp2

Yeah might as well

I’m preparing dinner so I’m trying to keep track of what’s happening, but I’m probably only going to be able to make a decision in the last 15 minutes at this rate.

Gut says no lynch, but I suspect we’ll encounter a lot of the same issues next DP.

Like I said, I’ll trigger the hammer if no one else does beforehand. If that’s where we’re leaning (no one else beyond WyIted has mentioned a NL and he’s got his vote back up), then I’ll VTL in 10 minutes to prevent it from getting too close.

Gun to head team is Lunatic/WF

ADOL needs to be pressured to play the game tomorrow

Earth, WyIted, Mharman probably fine

Austin, Casey outer POE

Good luck, try not to implode next Day Phase.

Buddy, what are you doing?

I keep going back and forth but at this precise second I am okay with a no lynch.

I am just going back and forth on what is the right decision here. How lazy is he as scum would he fake a read list when a lynch looks certain

Well, we gotta make this call. Going to be on intermittently from here.