Paper Mario Chapter 2

I suggest it because our major investigative roles are already outed, or dead. The only other thing I can think of us maybe risking is a potential protective role, and there might not even be one because mharman had a 1x doctor ability. Earth's prior two games only had bodyguard's also. If there is another protective role, I am guessing it's a weak one given the existence of the 1x doc. 

Wait, you weren't given anything?

Fair enough, that's a decent point. I guess the only other person who hasn't claimed yet is Wylted, and he's town in my book. I won't put Pie at L-1 unless he becomes really stubborn, but I suppose pressuring him for a claim isn't such a bad idea. 

Wait, I just realized Mharman didn't even have a Watcher. Sorry, I skimmed through a lot of stuff. I think Luna is probably town in that case. 

I am Huff N. Puff, the leader of a gang of Ruff Puffs keeping Flower Fields cloudy and permanently overcast by my cloud making machine. I have the Jailkeeper role. I can target a player and protect them from any lethal actions and also roleblock them from committing any actions. 

I don't know how Lunatic's ability failed during the NP, but it wasn't because of me 

VTL Cerulean

Since we lost Mharman, I think lynching needs to happen more quickly so we can get rid of a mafia. I am probably not going to be back on for ten hours maybe, so I would rather put in a vote now instead of waiting till later. Cerulean is still in the list of scum for me 

@pie

I gave my claim for a couple reasons, mainly because I was inactive and would be pushed for it today under threat of death. Plus, this is a busy week for me, and I don't know what my powers actually do; so making myself a bigger target wouldn't hurt town as much as if an active player dies (that said, I've asked the mod if whiteflame or mharman are available to replace me).

My powers are tied to Jr. Troopa's forms he used to fight Mario. Each night I select a player to receive one. I gave magic to Casey last night. I still have shell, wings, spiked helmet.

@Casey

What did magic do for you?

I am The Master, and I am a Commuter Survivor. Which is to say that I am not Town-aligned, I win with either Town or Mafia.

The justification for being a Commuter is that I am optional, but very difficult to fight. (Frankly, I think PGO would have been a better role.)

I was considering fake claiming Lava Piranha, 1x Bulletproof, but considering that my true role all but directly contradicts WyIted, I might as well be honest.

If this gets me policy eliminated, c'est la vie. I didn't feel like wolfing for a third game in a row.

VTL WyIted

If I had to pick a partner for Barney that's not WyIted... probably Pie. I haven't seen anything that would really convince me off of him this game. Everyone else has at least something in their favor, in my eyes. But I don't feel I have a solid reason to be townreading Pie.

...Has he even claimed? Have I forgotten?

For the record I believe your claim to be 3rd party and your role, otherwise that's the ballsiest mafia move ever and it still more than likely won't work out, I just don't see you doing that if actually scum. I am not sure I entirely believe you can joint win though. Though we can do what we've done in other games and just not care if third party win or not and just hunt mafia. Doubt town would be sold on that move though. That said I would like to at least try to lynch one mafia before making the decision to lynch you, so I am fine with you living for this day phase at least. 

I'm willing to detour over to Pie for a while. He was very hesitant to claim in Mayday when we were wolfing together, but if I recall right, he did claim fairly quickly in the Bo Burnham game, yes?

VTL Pie

Actually, that brings up a question I've wondered about. Do third parties typically fall on the scum side or the town side of the theme split? 

See my math in my post.

Right now it’s 5-2.

If we mislynch today, it’s game over cause at 3-2 LYLO, Ceru votes with scum and game is over. If we lynch him now, we don’t have to worry about him and have more POE tomorrow as well. It’s objectively a good thing to policy lynch him right now.

He (wylted) claimed ascetic.

So we have an ascetic, a Jailkeeper, and a Commuter. Three roles that deal with preventing actions happening/ blocking.

Eh, I'm not really a fan of mass claiming on DP2 unless the town just gets lucky and kills scum DP1. I think behavioral and mechanical analysis ought to be prioritized. Both of those lead me to Barney.

Again, I don't like the idea of both a JOAT and a Dreaming God existing in this game. It just doesn't make sense to me, and I'm not sold on Barney's excuse for why he suddenly claimed it early. He could always just claim his role whenever he was able to actually log on to DART. 

Joebob has replaced Barney.

Yeah honestly no real way to get him to vote with us in a MYLO situation other than hope he sticks to his word. We might not have a choice but to just go to LYLO. 2 scum will still be alive, but at least the POE will be strong enough that it's very likely you will hit one. Hopefully. 

40% chance we hit correctly 

From my POV there’s definitely one scum in Skipper/Wylted so the odds shoot up to 50% at least because I don’t think Ceru is lying about his role

WE can try guilting ceru into not hammering with scum, as it would make for a boring game?

I’m down to lynch Barney, but we have to be 100% sure, otherwise it’s game over. 

This has to be a policy lynch because the math isn’t on our side.