-->
@Casey_Risk
Banana, I would like to know why you targeted me specifically
This is a great question
Bo Burnham Mafia DP2
Posts
Read-only
Total:
107
My spider sense is tingling a lot. I feel like there are 3 scum
-->
@ILikePie5
I feel like there are 3 scum
In a game with a Mafia Super Saint and a Town Compulsive Bus Driver? Plus, I think Moozer is very likely to be town, so add on a Hated Townie. Seems super scumsided to me.
-->
@Casey_Risk
In a game with a Mafia Super Saint and a Town Compulsive Bus Driver? Plus, I think Moozer is very likely to be town, so add on a Hated Townie. Seems super scumsided to me.
Maybe I’m just paranoid after Luna’s previous game
-->
@ILikePie5
Maybe I’m just paranoid after Luna’s previous game
The fact that there were three scum plus a third party was pretty surprising, but even so, this game would have to be absurdly scumsided to have three mafia given everyone's flips/claims so far. I don't buy that there's more than two mafia. If there are, I'm gonna expect a written apology from Luna for making such a lopsided game, or I'm not playing one of his again lol
What roles am I suppose to immediately claim and not claim?
I didn't use the role because I wasn't notified of the NP and even if I was on during it, wouldn't it be best to wait to see the dead roles I could take instead of guessing? How much of an idiot am I being?
-->
@Owen_T
I didn't use the role because I wasn't notified of the NP and even if I was on during it, wouldn't it be best to wait to see the dead roles I could take instead of guessing? How much of an idiot am I being?
How much have you asked about your role?
-->
@Owen_T
Sorry, you said Gravedigger and I thought you were talking about this type of Gravedigger. It's basically the Tracker/Watcher equivalent of a Miller. You can understand why I was upset lol.
-->
@Owen_T
Can you clearly explain how your role works?
Full claim. I am Words, Words, Words.
My quote is "“We the people of the USA, Jose, we're not talkin to you, esse. We got a border in order to keep you out, it's what my NYU essay's about”
My song is very silly but doesn't have a serious twist and because of that I am a vanilla.
I gotta read what happened lol
Ok so it looks like WF tried to spin Suicide Bomber as town. Luckily were (assumably) in a 5v1 so we have some room for error but let's not let that cloud our judgement
-->
@Moozer325
Huh
-->
@Owen_T
Can you explain your role?
I had a read on Owen but if it's the role he's describing, he can confirm himself and bring back someone from the dead. This means Owen SHOULD bring back Mharman from the dead. There's a way we can solve this game pretty easy
Pie is being very vague on "being an investigative." Don't love that to be honest and not to mention he is the last to make a char claim (unless I missed it DP1).
This is a tough game but I'm going to use POE
I am town
I think Owen can be confirmed if he uses his role in the NP and I want to hold off voting him.
I think Banana's role and Mhar's role make sense and seems like it could be more town than scum. I am not ruling out Banana as scum but I don't think it's feasible to put in my final poe.
This leaves
Moozer
Pie
Casey
I am going to have to reread these but honestly. I am sort of leaning toward Moozer.
As much as I don't like Moozer's claim, I think I'm taking him out of my POE
The argument for each -
Pie - The argument you can make for Pie being scum is that he hasn't fully claimed a role and soft claimed "investigative." From what I've seen (could be wrong), he hasn't claimed a song either. Most likely waiting til all claims comes out to do such. I don't hold activity into high account so that's a non argument, but I think he was a bit hard on banana in Dp1 and definetly was pushing him hard until the WF claim where he very quickly changed his vote to ensure he wasn't the L-1. Not to mention the biggest opposer of Pie who was catching on is dead.
Casey - Casey does not have a role that is "confirmable" by really any means and seems inherently weak considering what has been claimed. I also did not like their post when they were discussing the read on me. I didn't like the flip flop aspect of "I originally had Supa in my scum but when he changed his reasoning he was null. I also just think they're posts are also very safe. Not necessarily any big reads and game solving and just soft safe posts. However there is a way that Casey can use their role to essentially give mafia a free win and I hope they see it. Not to mention not on the wagon for WF.
I am more confident in a Pie than I am in a Casey lynch because Casey's mechanic could really help push the game to a town win. I am also not ruling out Moozer and Banana but right now I am not as eager to lynch them. Moozer's role is scummy but his behavior just feels too towny
Hold on need to ask Luna a question
Once a game, during and DP, I can assume the role of a dead player. That becomes my role for the rest of the game.
I'll be somewhat inactive today for reasons I think you all can guess
I'm conflicted with that response
-->
@Vader
Pie - The argument you can make for Pie being scum is that he hasn't fully claimed a role and soft claimed "investigative." From what I've seen (could be wrong), he hasn't claimed a song either.
I said my character DP1: From God’s Perspective
Most likely waiting til all claims comes out to do such. I don't hold activity into high account so that's a non argument, but I think he was a bit hard on banana in Dp1 and definetly was pushing him hard until the WF claim where he very quickly changed his vote to ensure he wasn't the L-1.
The claim was scummy af lol.
Not to mention the biggest opposer of Pie who was catching on is dead.
-->
@Owen_T
Once a game, during and DP, I can assume the role of a dead player. That becomes my role for the rest of the game.
Can you assume the role of a mafia player?
Wait sorry y'all I'm graverobber not grave digger.
-->
@ILikePie5
I assume I could, don't know why I would.
I have a few thoughts for now. I townread Moozer and Owen. Vader claiming Vanilla while being the last to claim is convenient for him, but behaviorally I don't have much reason to sus him. Last scum is probably between Banana and Pie. I'll expand on my thoughts after I get back from voting.
I have class all day today so activity will be limited
And before anyone asks...I voted early by mail in ballot