-->
@WyIted
Why does Town need an extra DP to make a lynch? Also, I assume Bullish is 1x because otherwise Bullish's role would be fucking busted. Also Town always wants to lynch DP1, even if it leads to a mislynch.
Classic Movies Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
223
-->
@Earth
Why does Town need an extra DP to make a lynch?
whatever choose a lynch have him save them and then lynch them again who cares. I figure there seems to be no consensus now so might as well buy another 72 hours/
I assume Bullish is 1x because otherwise Bullish's role would be fucking busted
Yes it's the governor which I have never seen as a town role but he is widely town read for making the claim for some reason.
-->
@WyIted
whatever choose a lynch have him save them and then lynch them again who cares. I figure there seems to be no consensus now so might as well buy another 72 hours/
What's even the point of that besides role confirming Bullish? You even say that you never saw a Town Governor so you should still scumread him for that.
-->
@Earth
The point is that I am telling you it is a negative town utility as the best case scenario so it is literally retarded not to make him use the ability. There is no good reason not to force his hand.
You even say that you never saw a Town Governor so you should still scumread him for that.
Ehh no strong reads at the moment though I have picked up on a behavioral scum tell. It's oly about 65% accurate though
-->
@Earth
The point is that I am telling you it is a negative town utility as the best case scenario so it is literally retarded not to make him use the ability. There is no good reason not to force his hand.
You even say that you never saw a Town Governor so you should still scumread him for that.
Ehh no strong reads at the moment though I have picked up on a behavioral scum tell. It's oly about 65% accurate though
-->
@WyIted
The point is that I am telling you it is a negative town utility as the best case scenario so it is literally retarded not to make him use the ability. There is no good reason not to force his hand.
Fair enough.
I'd like to get AnaBanana's genre or five year time frame.
-->
@Owen_T
I'd like to get AnaBanana's genre or five year time frame.
I’m not looking for a claim from Banana. She softed her claim and I’m more than satisfied with that.
-->
@whiteflame
Gun to your head, who do you lynch?
-->
@whiteflame
I’m not looking for a claim from Banana. She softed her claim and I’m more than satisfied with that.
She did?
Yes she did.
Town Block so far
Pie
Earth
Cerulean
Bullish
Wylted
It’s actually interesting that in her third game she knows what soft claiming is and did it adequately as well. My paranoia makes me think she’s scum and her scum buddy told her to do that so there’s a redux of last game
-->
@Earth
@Lunatic
@Bullish
@AustinL0926
@WyIted
What do yall think of above?
-->
@Earth
Gun to your head, who do you lynch?
If I had to pick, it’d be between WyIted and Austin. Don’t really have a preference yet, so flip a coin if I have to choose.
-->
@ILikePie5
It’s actually interesting that in her third game she knows what soft claiming is and did it adequately as well. My paranoia makes me think she’s scum and her scum buddy told her to do that so there’s a redux of last game
Possibly, though she’s also not the only one this game to have softclaimed that way.
I am down for a banana claim or at the very least for her to talk more. I know that’s hypocritical based on my own activity so far but I will be much more active during the week. I just need something to read her by at least.
-->
@whiteflame
Possibly, though she’s also not the only one this game to have softclaimed that way.
She did it very early. And she’s a noob. Other people are vets. It’s odd imo
-->
@iamanabanana
unvote
VTL banana
Full claim please
-->
@ILikePie5
It’s actually interesting that in her third game she knows what soft claiming is and did it adequately as well. My paranoia makes me think she’s scum and her scum buddy told her to do that so there’s a redux of last game
I think it's possible that she learned fast. I don't see that soft as some master stroke of a soft. Maybe she was coached, maybe not.
Okay, I doubt anyone cares, but I need to be more active, so here’s some reads.
Bullish: Theres nothing behaviorally that makes me scumread him, but his role gives me some pause. I like his justification and his movie is definitely a classic, but I’ve never seen a governor that also skips the nightphase. It seems like a weird role, because it basically just resets the clock on the DP, and town would almost always just pick the same lynch. I think it’s a good idea for him to confirm himself, if not now then next DP.
Owen_T: Same as what I said before. He’s usually about this active, so I don’t think it indicates anything. I might be open to lynching on just activity, but I’d rather not. Not that I think it’s going that way, but just in case.
I’ll have more in a bit, just going to post this first.
-->
@ILikePie5
She did it very early. And she’s a noob. Other people are vets. It’s odd imo
Fair enough. I hadn’t checked back to see when she posted it relative to others. I’ll give it some thought, though I’ll probably join the pursuit of a claim if she’s intransigent.
-->
@whiteflame
I just find it odd that banana was a able to do nothing thus far but do a very vague soft claim. But you're obviously the more experienced player so I'll trust you with this one.
Votes:
Wylted (2/6): Wylted, Austin
Banana (2/6): Cerulean, Pie
A boy's best friend is his mother
-- Norman Bates, Psycho
Mod note: Due to personal schedule reasons, DP1 will receive a small 45 minute extension. It will end tomorrow, October 16, at 3:00 PM EDT. Roughly 18 hours remain in the DP.
-->
@Bullish
Okay, I see no reason not to have you confirm yourself this DP. I don't think we're going to use your ability anytime this game, and it seems to be just a time extension anyways.
I don’t line post 144 by Owen either
I'll throw my vote on the VTL anabanana pile for fullclaim.
-->
@Owen_T
I just find it odd that banana was a able to do nothing thus far but do a very vague soft claim. But you're obviously the more experienced player so I'll trust you with this one.
Like Pie, this post seems sus. You initially said you wanted her claim. You’ve since been made aware that she clearly softed it, but your response is that it’s “vague” (it isn’t), and that you trust… something I said? What do you trust?
Votes:
Banana (3/6): Cerulean, Pie, Earth
Wylted (2/6): Wylted, Austin
It wasn't the airplanes. It was beauty killed the beast.
-- Carl Denham, King Kong