-->
@ILikePie5
There is no town incentive to stealing someone’s vote unless you think they are scum. So please explain why Earth is scum?
My incentive was confirming my role, how was that not obvious?
UPick Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
675
-->
@ILikePie5
Literally no one else is confirmable rn, so I recommend we just lynch someone.
-->
@Savant
My incentive was confirming my role, how was that not obvious?
So you’re trying to gain town cred, got it. You’re claiming a scummy role. Didn’t even steal the person’s vote you thought was scum. And now we should let you have a 1x Vig. Nope. And this is a hill I’m willing to die on.
I mean WyIted claims he is, but now I'm doubting Pie will buy his claim.
-->
@Savant
Literally no one else is confirmable rn, so I recommend we just lynch someone.
I’m fine lynching you after we figure out who to give this 1x Vig to.
-->
@Earth
@Lunatic
We need to decide who amongst the 3 of us should get the 1x Vig.
-->
@ILikePie5
I don't think we can lynch someone if we lynch rsvlts.
-->
@ILikePie5
Lol no. I'm not giving 1x vig to someone with zero role confirmation.
-->
@Savant
I don't think we can lynch someone if we lynch rsvlts.
Austin said the day would continue as normal.
-->
@Savant
Lol no. I'm not giving 1x vig to someone with zero role confirmation.
You have zero credibility right now. The 1x vig is going to one of those 3 players. Rn I’m leaning Lunatic
-->
@ILikePie5
Ok then. Explain why you want to give vigilante powers to a possible scum?? Explain how maybe letting a town member kill someone based on a gut feeling is worth that risk.
-->
@ILikePie5
The 1x vig is going to one of those 3 players.
It should go to no one. Just don't hammer.
-->
@WyIted
@JoeBob
@Casey_Risk
@Moozer325
If either of yall try to get this 1x Vig, you are going to be the lynch today.
-->
@ILikePie5
ok
so then who is
-->
@Savant
Ok then. Explain why you want to give vigilante powers to a possible scum??
Scum are more often than not on that wagon because you as the scum partner gets the Vig shot.
Explain how maybe letting a town member kill someone based on a gut feeling is worth that risk.
I’d rather have a town member keep it than a scum member. And the two scum are likely in the 4, with you being one of them
-->
@Savant
It should go to no one. Just don't hammer.
Scared now are we?
-->
@JoeBob
so then who is
Unvote for now. We need Lunatic and Earth to chime in. Times like these I wish WF was here
Vote count:
RSVLTS SHIRT (3/7): Earth, Joebob, Casey
Barney (1/5): Wylted
I'm running out of shirt jokes for this game. I just can't find a good fit.
what exactly does the shirt do, just give the person who votes last a vigilante kill?
About 44 hours remain in the DP.
-->
@AustinL0926
I'm running out of shirt jokes for this game. I just can't find a good fit.
🙄
I'll be honest, I went along with Savant because I'm still not used to the plethora of roles used in Mafia and I assumed that vote thief/Robin Hood would be a town role. And while I do believe Savant that it is usually, in a game with a lot of custom roles like this one, I don't think we can assume that's the case. I also don't want us to make the mistake of relying too much on 'confirmable' roles. So for now, I'm going to
Unvote
-->
@ILikePie5
@luna
@WyIted
@Casey_Risk
@Moozer325
Pie is my top scumread rn. Without even posting reads, he expects us to follow him for some reason. Right now either Luna is his scum buddy or he is trying to earn Luna's trust, and I am leaning toward the former. Whether or not you think I am confirmed, giving vigilante powers to a possible scum is a terrible idea, and Pie is basing his guess on one data point (people who went along with my plan). Pie could only be this confident if he knows he is scum and wants to earn Luna's trust by letting him hammer.
At first I was town reading Pie despite my annoyance with him because he is usually aggressive, however this time around he is so aggressive at the expense of logic that it doesn't make sense. Then I realized he is probably scum trying to do what he usually does as town but going a bit overboard.
-->
@Casey_Risk
Not seeing me as 100% confirmable is fine. But in that case, we should avoid letting anyone hammer instead of giving a potential scum a night kill. Notice how Pie just called me "scared" without actually contesting my argument.
-->
@Lunatic
@ILikePie5
@WyIted
@Casey_Risk
@Moozer325
I am leaning toward the former.
I meant latter. I do not believe Luna is scum. Sorry.
-->
@Savant
Pie is my top scumread rn. Without even posting reads, he expects us to follow him for some reason. Right now either Luna is his scum buddy or he is trying to earn Luna's trust, and I am leaning toward the former. Whether or not you think I am confirmed, giving vigilante powers to a possible scum is a terrible idea, and Pie is basing his guess on one data point (people who went along with my plan). Pie could only be this confident if he knows he is scum and wants to earn Luna's trust by letting him hammer.
Nice OMGUS. I’ve posted my reads. Scum is in the 4 people who are following this plan, with you being one for sure. I’m fine giving the Vig power to Earth as well, but you stole his vote. When I asked you, you said you didn’t even scumread him.
At first I was town reading Pie despite my annoyance with him because he is usually aggressive, however this time around he is so aggressive at the expense of logic that it doesn't make sense. Then I realized he is probably scum trying to do what he usually does as town but going a bit overboard.
Lol the logic is there. Youre a scum vote thief. Your scum partner joined you Willy nilly. Probably Moozer, JoeBob, or Casey. That makes everyone else town. Barney is town as well. There’s nothing illogical about this. Vote thief is a scum role. If you’re town, you didn’t even use it in a townie way. I don’t blame you, you’re still new. No way you’d have know this.
-->
@AustinL0926
I'm running out of shirt jokes for this game.
I think you have them down to a T.
-->
@Savant
Not seeing me as 100% confirmable is fine. But in that case, we should avoid letting anyone hammer instead of giving a potential scum a night kill. Notice how Pie just called me "scared" without actually contesting my argument.
As scum, you should be scared. You know that you’re giving the shot to a townie if what I am saying is correct. Why should we not let a townie take a shot?
I’m 95% sure it’s Savant + one of Joe, Wylted, Moozer, Casey