Also your argument about punishing people to deter them from doing drugs doesn't work, empirically, why do you think the recidivism rate for drug use is so high. It seems like the way to stop people from doing drugs isn't via criminal punishment, but instead via addiction treatment. Maybe if rape victims who used illegal drugs should be given mandatory addiction treatment alongside their criminal immunity, if that's the road you want to go down.
Isn't the problem with not granting victims immunity when reporting rape that you start to cause a chilling effect? We don't want someone who is raped to not report it because they were doing illegal drug and fear that they may face legal ramifications on top the already extreme trauma of the rape and the fear of not being believed by law enforcement.
Also your argument about punishing people to deter them from doing drugs doesn't work, empirically, why do you think the recidivism rate for drug use is so high. It seems like the way to stop people from doing drugs isn't via criminal punishment, but instead via addiction treatment. Maybe if rape victims who used illegal drugs should be given mandatory addiction treatment alongside their criminal immunity, if that's the road you want to go down.
Isn't the problem with not granting victims immunity when reporting rape that you start to cause a chilling effect? We don't want someone who is raped to not report it because they were doing illegal drug and fear that they may face legal ramifications on top the already extreme trauma of the rape and the fear of not being believed by law enforcement.