Coreyinthehouse

Oh was I voted out? RIP

Not sure Y I would be less likely to think of a way to cover for myself if I was mafia but ok

Role is Thorne

Far as IK no one suspects Crystal but ok lol
Y am I supposed to claim my role

Y should I claim my role? 

It still matters tho bc it devalues one piece of evidence, the rest was v flawed anyway

crystalynx confirm I do the thing I said I do

Oh damn nvm lmao

The fact you're not voting me makes me suspect you are not the mafia. You could have waited for others to say something about me being guilty/innocent but you jumped in with Pie. Will back off accusations on you for now unless I see reason otherwise.

Why would my rational for why I do this not matter what

Bc in my head at the time I figured there was more likely less third party than mafia. Later I figured that might not be the case bc 1 Mastermind against everyone else is a set up IK That2 has been interested in b4 in RPs.

Yes because in my head I thot the mafia would use a fake claim to be TP with the hope the real TP would use fake claim to be Town. I was using this logic to justify why someone would lie to be third party if there was only 1, someone else stated it was likely there was only 1 third party. I reasoned they would lie and take this risk assuming the other TP would lie.

I just sorta figured TP could do that, bc otherwise IDK what the point of TP would be?

I guess I can see how it'd be suspect I figured that? But that would imply I'm a secret TP not a secret mafia.

Anyone who knows me personally (crystalynx and that2) would know this about me: I make everything overly wordy and overprotective whether innocent or guilty bc I constantly overthink everything I say and think I have to correct it. Tis the reason I edited my message before I realized it was a rule. I have rampant anxiety OCD but that's besides the point. I do it in games like Among Us all the time.

I will stand that not knowing this about me, it is a valid reason to suspect me. Genuinely. But how do you think it's "scumslipping" ??? Like I can see it being suspicious but what 

I was not the first person to suspect a fake third party claim, I wrote that while catching up with the chat and I was replying to things I wanted to reply to in order of when they occured

The only thing I have some confidence in is Barney being Riddler, but IDK for sure

I don't even understand this people were talking about fake claims pretty early on I thot? I don't remember when I first heard you can fake claim honestly but I thot it was fairly obvious you could? I mean if you can't lie about what you are how could you avoid being caught? Like I'm very confused

Yes was information fishing to figure out who I properly suspect as scum

Plus the game pretty much laid out I'm Bane, it directly quoted a line about the Dark Knight Rises when people voted me 4/5 (At least I think that's why it did?)

In the Dark Knight, the Joker wins regardless of which boat blows up. I thot he wins with either side, unless I misread.

What did I do that you think was scumslipping???

Why in the world do you think I scumslipped??????

My suspicion is solely based on That2's interest in the newest movie/the Riddler. That is genuinely all bc IK he really liked the movie. I never voted him bc I'm not THAT sure of it. But his refusal to admit is highly suspect.

DAMN I DIDN'T REALIZE UNTIL NOW 4 PEOPLE WERE VOTING ME-

My thought process: I still think it's Barney, in fact I wonder if he's the ONLY mafia. As already said the idea of the Riddler being the villain makes sense to me based on how much That2 liked that movie. IDK what other details ya'll want other than IK he likes the movie tho

BatMan being in an asylum isn't that weird, he's probably been in an asylum at one point in the comics before and That2 probably just wanted to use him in someway shape or form.

I didn't respond to U because I didn't see until I needed to head to bed. Like I said b4, That2 really likes the newest movie and the Riddler. I'm less certain on this now because I'm actually pretty sure Joker is telling the truth, though Riddler and Joker could still be "teaming up" in a sense since Joker wins with either side. But main thing is again, this makes things seem all the more likely when I think about it.
He really liked the movie so I can see him crafting a "story" where Riddler is the main villain and Joker will win with either side, crafting chaos. Just like his role in Dark Knight, which IK he also really liked.

I've thot about this some more, I 100% believe the Supa/Joker claim about winning with either. I've done some RPs with That2 and he has a common theme of characters who only desire and/or cause it. It 100% sounds like a role he would give to Joker.

Why are moderators frequently scum? Odd

Yes, Joker was in Gotham b4. I'm not as familiar with BatMan compared to everyone else but IK he was in there in the BatMan VS TMNT movie.

I literally did not know scum talks in a discord chat at all, that's why I didn't realize what was happening

Just got a chance to post now, I was at work and then my girlfriend was panicking and going through personal stuff so I didn't have a chance to post.

Because he's my friend and I know he REALLY liked that movie a lot, that's pretty much it honestly.

??? Why are you asking me to describe my discord DM wat?

^ Feels too soon RN

Yea IK he was third party if he's telling the truth, thot lynching him would still be bad for town but I may be misunderstanding something

Describe my DM? What?

Naw I think it'd be bad to lynch pie if he's innocent, it is sus to believe there's two third parties but I can't really think of a reason to sus him beyond he said it first 

It is very sus yeah, but he could just not wanna give anymore details

Doubtful IMO knowing information based strictly on character would help the mafia. I'm not asking for roles/moves.

Could you provide another detail about your costume? I'm not asking you to out yourself or anything oc. 

I am generally not active on weekdays between 10 PM to - 4PM EDT and probably won't be on weekends either, Saturdays and Sundays I may in general not be as active as normal but I don't have to work.

How was this even missed I missed it 2 but the reason was said in game
Wild

Think I edited something else b4 that 2 but it was only to fix grammar. Won't happen again soz. Legit didn't see rule until rite before you sent.

I saw the rule right before I saw you reply, gottee

YAY WE'RE NOT THE ONLY IDIOTS

It does and even if he doesn't confirm he could leave it up in the air to mess with us/keep the discussion going, so feel inclined to agree it was probably mistake
EDIT: Didn't see he confirmed lmao

Aight, awesome. 

I'm suspecting Barney might be the Riddler. "Part of your costume is green"A
nd if so, given That2 I'm gonna suspect you're the mafia. Thinking Supa/Joker might be the other mafia which would fit well with Riddler and Joker's implied teamup at the end of the newest movie, would make sense.

IK That2 really liked that movie so him making this loosely based on that would totally make sense. Supa's claim also smells suspicious to me, personally.

Is there anything wrong with me having a Google Docs comp of evidence/thoughts so I can organize my thoughts on this game better?

If there's one fake third party Supa is likely the real third party. Pie made the claim first, (I think) he could have been banking on the real third party using a fake claim (if they even claimed) to get away with his claim. I find it unlikely there's two third party but it's possible I think.

I'm Bane, I win with town. I'm going to leave the further specifics to my role secret for now since it was said it might be bad bc of targeting. Not to say I'm stronger or not, for all U know I could be trying to throw mafia off of stronger people.