Bakugan Battle Brawlers Mafia DP2

I agree with most of this, with the exception of poly being the most town read. I don't see how he is really confirmed here yet.

His action doesn't make a lot of sense, I don't see why wylted would have ever been targeted np1 for the kill, and wylted being roleblocked doesn't help us confirm the redirect... As town the logical move is to forfeit in in almost every scenario, or maybe to use it to prove your role on a less effective town role. 

Not to mention redirect isn't normally a town role, it's a mafia role designed to cause chaos.

The only thing that makes me kind of doubt him as scum was that I wasn't targeted last night after scum reading him, but there is still any amount of reasons why they targeted oro,  those reasons may just not be clear to me at this time. 

Wouldn't be the first time I've seen a Redirector on town, and wouldn't be too surprised if Pie had included one. That being said, if this is a Bron/Poly team, I don't see Poly coming up with a tactic of either fake claiming Redirector (pretty ballsy) or just giving away his role (even more ballsy). I guess this could be a fake claim given to him by Pie, but I find the amount that he's going through to explain why he did it doesn't fit with what I've seen Poly do as scum.

I used to have a watcher role so dr lebronsky does make town over powered. 

Why don't you see poly doing that? I mean scum roles can be town roles, it happens all the time. But I can see how rather than trying to come up with a fake claim and be potentially counter claimed someone like poly might just use their real role since it is technically verifiable. The only time poly has been scum to my knowledge was the game he played with me, and he wasn't particularly active and trying to mastermind plans or anything. While he is technically a vet, I think I would still put him among the lower eschalon of current players (no offense to him of course, I am basing that mostly on the effort he puts in the game). 

Alright, this is frustrating me like crazy. Wylted, could you just ask Pie if you still have the Watcher role or not?

I do not. I don't know if one of the 3 or r people who visited me have a hidden mechanic or what. This is not a trick, you won't see me coming back with watcher results next dp or anything like that. The watcher role is gone. 

I guess you could call it a hunch based on what I've seen him do before. If we're assuming that scum got full claims with associated justifications, I guess I could see him just being lazy and full-claiming the whole thing.

Here's what's bugging me about it, though: he was under the misapprehension from early on, even after Wylted said that his role failed, that Wylted had Watched Bron. As scum, you would think that he'd know that Wylted was RB'd and just acknowledge that the attempt to use the role failed. I have a hard time believing that he would keep pushing the narrative that it went through and Wylted just didn't understand the response he got from Pie.

I mean if he roleblocked him and knew he was roleblocked he could knowingly say he used his action however he wants since there is no way for the action to be proven or disproven. Wylted claimed he was a watcher in post 27 before poly even claimed redirector in post 56

Just so we don't keep digging down into this, I'll just say that I'm willing to consider him in future lynches. I don't think I would do so for this DP, but I think a lynch on Bron would be telling.

just get it over with

vtl meee