Actually, I want to fully consider this before I push a lynch. Something I'm considering here as well is how the Janitor on Pie has affected the game. We've had multiple claims past the start of DP2:
My Innocent Child (verified)
Wylted's Tracker (verified)
Speed's Vanilla (fake claim)
Evil's Vanilla (uncertain)
Poly's Watcher (uncertain)
So, three options: Pie had a role that scum couldn't use (they would claim Vanilla), Pie was Vanilla (they would claim Vanilla), or Pie was the Watcher (they would claim the Watcher). That last one is nagging at me. It's possible that Poly faked being RB'd in both DPs and simply used the claim that he got from Pie. I don't think that's likely, but I also think there's value in considering it for now.
Poly, could you give me your justification for the Watcher role?