You're not addressing the issue. We're all familiar with Wylted taking hardline stances on who is suspicious utilizing reasoning that the rest of us find unconvincing. I specifically have been pointing out that he went to far greater lengths in DP1 to make his point than I've ever seen from him, including writing up a whole Google Doc with sources to better establish his points. Have you ever seen Wylted do that in a game?
Ok your argument is that Wylted, as town, takes hardline stances. So, you're argument for him being scum, is that he took...more hardline stances? It only makes sense that he would do more and more of these things as time goes on;
Like seriously, if this is his town meta, him doing a Google Doc for it only shows that it's more likely that he's town because he IS obeying his meta even more
I'm genuinely curious about why doing this MORE makes him scum, I think it's more likely that you think he's anti-town and you write that off as scum
Also I could be wrong but don't you say this about him every game lol
Evil was about as active as you were, actually, with 4 posts to your 7. He didn't provide his reads until after you gave yours, so I'll give you that he wasn't exactly contributing heavily, but he had already been sussing Wylted up to that point. I could understand dismissing his contributions as uninformative up to that point,
Scum is the one that has to scrounge for good reads. As town, I'm not wasting time pouring over 4 scrawny posts to come up with town/scum reads. Also, I could be wrong but everyone at that time also was null on Evil or just didn't talk about him. If someone hasn't contributed, I'm moving on (you seem to agree on this one so it's whatever)
but I also pointed out several times that GP did not claim according to his meta, which is to full claim in his first post rather than only claiming his role.
He didn't full claim
here until prompted,
here, and in both he was town, meaning always full claiming is not his meta. His meta is claiming first post either role or character, sometimes both. Beyond that his reads are incomprehensible and he doesn't really elaborate, which he also does as town
,
I also disagree that there wasn't much to go on for Pie. I know he's notoriously hard to read, but seriously, question marks dude?
Sorry, I'll rephrase. My reads for Pie are much like mine for GP where if he checks certain criteria then I townread him; his activeness and pressuring is what it was always like when he is town, so that was my reason for townreading him. I wasn't trying to say that there wasn't anything to go off us, I was trying to say that there wasn't much to say about him;
But again, I've been town and had null reads multiple times lol so how does that make me scum?
