Third, I think there are entirely valid reasons to sus Disc at this point, and the relative absence of that analysis from Oro’s posts is surprising to say the least, given how thorough he normally is.
He says he susses Mewtwo over the Narrator, but doesn’t explain why, even going so far as to say that the early claim somewhat vindicates Disc because it’s a “bad claim”. I disagree that it’s a bad claim. Clearly, both Supa and Luna believed it given rather extensive knowledge of the series on the basis that he’s the main character of the first movie. It’s a good claim, but it should stand out. Not only is Mewtwo not in the show, but he’s a creation of Giovanni, Pie’s own character. Evil himself pointed this out in the last DP.
But it’s not just the character claim. Part of the reason I sussed Pie was because the role fit the character too well. Look at Wylted’s flip. Oro, look at your own justification. We’ve got some decently obvious ones like Officer Jenny and Nurse Joy, but the rest are clearly weak or even nonexistent fits between character and role. Yet somehow Mewtwo stands out from that, just like Charizard did.
Behaviorally as well, he stands out. He sussed Pie but didn’t vote for him in DP2, instead choosing to focus attention on Evil when that was an obvious dead end. He had hours to get on and hammer after Supa’s vote. If my unvoting and then hammering somehow gives me away, I don’t see how Disc gets away with being entirely in absentia during a critical time like that.
