I still have an FoS of whiteflame because of his char claim, but behaviorally he leans town. He's not big into revealing info unless town is doing so and that is a key town tell so I am willing to excuse the ehhh char claim for his behavior.
Pokémon Indigo League Mafia - DP 2
Posts
Total:
309
Also in regards #59 to the counterargument of "scum could waive a kill/action," it's a suboptimal move from scum to do such a thing. You need to gather info about roles and such to kill the best targets
-->
@Wylted
I lost my role cuz Bron got lynched
-->
@Vader
VTL pie
Should be obvious why he is top suspect now.
Y’all really are some early birds. Reading now.
-->
@ILikePie5
I have an 8:45 class. Not my fault
Bron was clearly town. Anybody on that lynch is suspect
I’d disagree. The role was wacko.
Yeah, plus he practically claimed to town read Bron and still hammered, but you tracked pie to the NK target right?
Supa lost his tracking power so he couldn’t track anyone.
That's good enough for meVTL Pie
-->
@Vader
I have an 8:45 class. Not my fault
Don’t know why you do that to yourself freshman year lol
-->
@Earth
Stupid lynch aside, lynching Pie should be top priority. Anyone that can read should be able to see Pie constantly misinterpreting my posts and generally being scummy.
If I misinterpret your posts, you correct them for me. Different people read different things. And you know that you yourself are clear sometimes, which is why I ask to confirm what I interpret
-->
@whiteflame
I am kind of baffled by this early wagon on Earth. I understand that Luna's death implicated him somewhat, but as Pie said and as Earth later confirmed (albeit after some back-and-forth), that was likely the result of a mafia RB. Scum might not have known that he was the Doc if he had given a fake claim in DP1, but what's done is done. The fact that Earth was unsure about whether scum using Strongman would result in a similar outcome to an RB (that the action failed) looks townie to me, since I'm sure that if he was scum, he wouldn't have bothered asking here. More importantly, he has claimed Nurse Joy and we now have confirmed that Officer Jenny is in this game. I would have a very hard time believing that Nurse Joy is not in this game, and given that no one has CC'd him and no one else protected Luna, I'd say he's virtually town confirmed at this point.
I agree. Earth is practically Town unless Nurse Joy and Doctor are fake claims given by the mod.
-->
@Vader
Nah this is some pretty shit townplay. Sure I'm town confirmed to an extent and Disc is now essentially town confirmed, but that doesn't narrow down the POE. We still have
I agree you are practically Town confirmed, but Disc is not in my opinion. Miller claims are still inherently sus in my opinion.
1. oromagi2. Whiteflame3. Pie4. Evilgenius5. Earth6. WyltedMy only town reads atm are evilgenius and wylted so that's only1. oromagi2. whiteflame3. Pie4. EarthThat's a 2/4 chance of hitting scum fmpov, 50% odds, but looks what happens if you are lynchedWe'd have1. oromagi2. Wylted3. Whiteflame4. Evilgenius5. Earth6. LeBronAssuming you are town, we'd have results on Lebron that would essentially lock him as town. This also assuming my reads stay the same
I’ve already explained why there is no way to confirm Bron. You tracking him means nothing cause he could’ve waived his action, been a passive scum role, or just not have done the NK.
1. oromagi2. Whiteflame3. EarthThere's 2/3 chance we hit scum in that pile. You would obviously throw me into that pile as well if you weren't me, but if I tracked Lebron to nothing he'd be confirmed. And if Earth was RB'd, two action would've happened.
One scum can kill and RB. You realize that right?
Essentially, game would've been easier and that scenario assumes you are TOWN, if you are SCUM, town are in a better position because we now know theme
No, the scenario would be much worse because Bron’s affiliation would still be unknown, as well as yours. You keep looking at it from your perspective, when you also have to look at it from everyone else’s.
-->
@Vader
Mafia has a RB or Strongman then. Could be the reasoning as to why Lunatic. Still this could be an intricate lie and I have no way of knowing. For now I will hold off to prevent anything
I could theoretically see a game where my role isn’t possible with a Doc, but I think the theory doesn’t really have merit
-->
@Vader
Also in regards #59 to the counterargument of "scum could waive a kill/action," it's a suboptimal move from scum to do such a thing. You need to gather info about roles and such to kill the best targets
I meant Bron just wouldn’t do the NK. His scum partner would. Or Bron would be a Ninja and kill Luna while Earth is supposedly roleblocked
-->
@ILikePie5
You constantly twist my words. Like to the point where its scummy.
-->
@Earth
You constantly twist my words. Like to the point where its scummy.
I don’t do it on purpose. I really don’t understand what your point is or what you’re saying half the time. It’s not just me. Others are confused too.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
VTL pieShould be obvious why he is top suspect now.
Can you please elaborate?
-->
@ILikePie5
You keep going on about how being one of only 2 pokemon and being the only character that can't talk is not suspicious at all because Charizard "fits your role super duper gud". Why not elaborate on that?
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
You keep going on about how being one of only 2 pokemon and being the only character that can't talk is not suspicious at all because Charizard "fits your role super duper gud". Why not elaborate on that?
Alright, I wanted to avoid it but I can make life hell for mafia even by claiming.
I’m a flavored Bomb. The flavor is either Even Night, Odd Night. Not going to reveal which one. If scum want to kill me that’s on them.
Now can we get off this stupid wagon?
-->
@ILikePie5
Justification
Are we really going to say that Charizard fits the bomb role perfectly when there are literally pokemon that blow themselves up ad an attack?
as an attack*
I remember Charzard being hard to control so I guess fiery/hard to control = bomb.
Huh
-->
@ILikePie5
Is bomb just for lethal actions
Maybe Mafia has a ninja to kill bomb.
-->
@Earth
I remember Charzard being hard to control so I guess fiery/hard to control = bomb.
I will have to think of this further but right now I am just picturing the mod setting up this game and wanting a bomb role then thinking to themselves "what pokemon fits the role of bomb really well?" and somehow NOT choosing a pokemon that is an actual bomb, of which I can think of several just in the 1st generation.
It's a weird picture.
-->
@Discipulus_Didicit
Maybe polyglot forgot about Voltorb.
It is odd and my vote is staying.
-->
@Earth
My tracker and bomb would make sense for mafia to have a ninja now